How To Find And Compare The Best APYs (Annual Percentage Yields)

Shawn Plummer, CRPC

Retirement Planner, Financial Advisor, Annuity Broker, and Insurance Agent

APY Calculator

This APY calculator allows you to calculate your APY and compare multiple savings accounts to decide where to put your money next. Enter the annual interest rate, choose the compounding frequency (weekly, monthly, quarterly, annually), and the calculator will do the rest.

What Is APY and Why Does It Matter

APY (Annual Percentage Yield) is the real rate of return earned on a deposit account over a year, taking compounding into account. It’s more accurate than just looking at the “interest rate,” which may not reflect how often interest is added to your account balance.

Understanding APY is critical for anyone comparing high-yield savings accounts, certificates of deposit (CDs), money market accounts, or even annuities that guarantee interest. The higher the APY, the faster your money grows—but only if the terms are favorable.

Our Favorite Rates To Grow Your Money

These are our preferred accounts because the savings, money market, and CDs only require $1 to open. This allows you to spread out risk in case a bank or credit union closes in the future. The fixed annuity offers one of the highest interest rates, provides penalty-free annual withdrawals for liquidity, and typically has a longer term than a CD.

TermSavings AccountInstitutionAPY
N/AMoney Market AccountSkyOne Federal Credit Union4.16%
N/ASavings AccountNorthpointe Bank4.30%
6 MonthsCDMerrick Bank4.16%
12 MonthsCDNexBank4.55%
2 YearsFixed AnnuityOceanview Harbourview MYGA5.15%
5 YearsFixed AnnuityWichita National6.40%

Disclaimer: This is a comparison review. The Annuity Expert is not associated with a bank or credit union. We aim to help you find the highest interest rates for your savings. We may receive a small referral fee if you purchase something using a link in this guide.

APY Meaning

1. Compare Online Banks, Not Just Local Branches

How it works: Online banks and credit unions often offer higher APYs than brick-and-mortar institutions because they have fewer overhead costs.

  • Pros: Often among the highest APYs on savings and CDs.
  • Cons: No physical locations for in-person service.
  • Who needs it: People comfortable with managing finances online.
  • Who doesn’t need it: Those who prefer face-to-face banking or cash deposits.

2. Use Real-Time Rate Comparison Tools

How it works: Use our aggregate and update APYs across multiple financial institutions in real time.

  • Pros: Save time, avoid manual research.
  • Cons: Rates may not include local credit union offers.
  • Who needs it: Rate shoppers and comparison seekers.
  • Who doesn’t need it: People already committed to a long-term product or loyalty banking.

3. Understand the Fine Print: Minimum Balances and Tiered Rates

How it works: Many high APYs apply only to specific balance tiers or require monthly activity (like direct deposits or spending thresholds).

  • Pros: Some accounts offer tiered incentives for higher balances.
  • Cons: Failure to meet criteria means a lower APY or no interest at all.
  • Who needs it: Disciplined savers with predictable banking activity.
  • Who doesn’t need it: People who keep low balances or have irregular income.
APY Calculator

4. Compare Different Financial Products: Savings vs. CDs vs. Annuities

Product TypeTypical APYUnique Features
High-Yield SavingsVariableDaily liquidity, but subject to rate changes
Money Market AccountsVariableHigher limits and check-writing privileges
CDs (Certificates of Deposit)FixedLocked rates, terms from 3 months to 5+ years
Fixed Annuities (MYGAs)FixedTax-deferred, multi-year lock-in, no FDIC but insurer-backed
  • Who needs MYGAs: Savers seeking tax deferral and higher fixed APYs without market risk.
  • Who doesn’t need MYGAs: Those needing full liquidity before the surrender period ends.

5. Use Annuities With Fixed Interest Rates For Higher Guaranteed Returns

How it works: Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuities (MYGAs) offer fixed APYs over 3-, 5-, 7-, or 10-year terms. Unlike bank CDs, the growth is tax-deferred until withdrawn.

  • Pros: Higher guaranteed APYs, tax-deferred growth, and can be used inside IRAs or funded with cash.
  • Cons: Withdrawals before maturity may trigger surrender charges and tax penalties (if under age 59½).
  • Who needs it: Those who won’t need access to the funds and want predictable, higher growth.
  • Who doesn’t need it: Investors seeking flexible access or FDIC insurance.

Compare fixed annuity interest rates and confirm how each contract credits and compounds interest.


6. Watch for Introductory “Teaser” Rates

How it works: Some banks advertise promotional APYs that drop significantly after a few months.

  • Pros: Short-term rate boosts.
  • Cons: Often not sustainable; long-term yield is much lower than advertised.
  • Who needs it: Short-term savers who plan to move money again soon.
  • Who doesn’t need it: People looking for consistent returns over time.

7. Factor In Taxes on Interest

How it works: Interest from savings accounts, CDs, and money markets is taxed annually as ordinary income. MYGAs, however, are tax-deferred until withdrawn.

  • Pros of tax deferral: Grow your account faster without annual tax drag.
  • Cons: Distributions are taxed as ordinary income when taken.
  • Who needs it: People in higher tax brackets or those planning for retirement.
  • Who doesn’t need it: People in very low tax brackets or those needing short-term liquidity.

Additional Insurance That Can Enhance or Protect Your Growth

Who Should Compare APYs


Who Shouldn’t Focus Solely on APY

  • Those with high liquidity needs
  • People prioritizing market growth over guarantees
  • Tax-exempt investors (Roth IRA savers) where APY is less relevant

Final Thoughts

The best APY isn’t always the highest headline number—it’s the most efficient return after taxes, fees, and liquidity needs are factored in. Comparing APYs across banks, credit unions, and annuities ensures you don’t leave yield on the table.


Speak to The Annuity Expert

We’re a licensed annuity broker and insurance agency. We’ll help you compare fixed annuities, MYGAs, and other interest-bearing options to find the highest guaranteed APY based on your goals—at no cost to you.

→ Contact us now for free quotes and guidance on maximizing your APY.

Book A Free Consultation

Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.

Let Us Answer Your Questions

Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.

Contact Us
First
Last

APY Calculator Questions From Our Readers

What is an annual percentage yield?

Annual percentage yield (APY) is a financial term that represents the total interest earned on a savings account or investment over a year, including compound interest. It factors in the effects of compounding, allowing investors to compare various investment options accurately. In essence, APY indicates the actual return on investment, accounting for the frequency at which interest is added to the account.

What is APY in banking?

APY, or Annual Percentage Yield, is a measure used in banking to calculate the total interest earned on a savings account or investment over a year, taking into account compounding. It is a key factor for customers to compare the earning potential of different financial products. APY reflects the actual return on investment and is typically higher than the simple interest rate.

How do you calculate APY?

To calculate APY (Annual Percentage Yield), use the formula: APY = (1 + (interest rate/n)) ^ n – 1. Here, “interest rate” is the annual interest rate, and “n” represents the number of compounding periods per year.

How does APY work per month?

APY, or annual percentage yield, represents the total amount of interest earned on an investment in a year, including compound interest. To determine the APY per month, divide the annual percentage yield by 12.

What is an APY calculator saving?

An APY calculator is a useful tool for determining the annual percentage yield on a savings account. By entering the account balance and interest rate, the calculator can provide an estimate of the total interest earned over a year. This helps individuals make informed decisions regarding their savings goals.

How does APY work?

APY, or Annual Percentage Yield, calculates the total amount of interest earned on a savings account or investment over a year. It takes into account compound interest, which means that the interest is added to the account balance regularly, allowing the interest to earn interest. APY provides a more accurate measure of the real return on an investment compared to simple interest.

What does 5% APY mean?

A 5% APY (Annual Percentage Yield) represents the rate of return earned on an investment or deposit over a year, including compound interest. It is a competitive interest rate that can be found in high-yield savings accounts or certificates of deposit (CDs), offering a higher return compared to traditional savings accounts.

Shawn Plummer, CRPC

Retirement Planner, Financial Advisor, Annuity Broker, and Insurance Agent

I am a licensed Retirement Planner (CRPC), insurance agent, financial advisor, annuity broker, and former financial trainer with more than 18 years of hands-on experience in annuities and insurance. My National Producer Number (NPN) is 15524738. I spent 12 years training financial advisors nationwide on annuity, insurance, and retirement planning strategies, in addition to 18 years of direct field experience selling annuities and insurance products, helping clients protect their savings and secure reliable retirement income.

I have been quoted in Time Magazine, Bloomberg, Entrepreneur, Yahoo! Finance, MSN, SmartAsset, LegalZoom, U.S. News & World Report, Women’s Health Magazine, Forbes, and many other leading publications.

I am also the founder of The Annuity Expert, an independent online insurance agency and annuity broker serving consumers across the United States. Through this platform, my team and I help Americans remove the guesswork from retirement planning and compare insurance solutions to find the strongest value at the most competitive rates. I want to see you get the best products at the lowest prices.

Scroll to Top