Company Overview
Eagle Life Insurance Company is a subsidiary of American Equity Investment Life Holding Company, which was founded in 1995. Eagle Life focuses exclusively on fixed and fixed indexed annuities (FIAs), offering products through independent financial professionals. The company serves clients who value principal protection, tax deferral, and guaranteed retirement income without stock market risk.
Financial Strength
- AM Best Rating: A (Excellent)
- Our Recommendation: Only consider A– or higher rated carriers.
- Parent Company Stability: Backed by American Equity, a well-established annuity carrier.
Our Professional Opinion
Eagle Life is a good annuity company, and we like both its accumulation and guaranteed-income options when their terms are competitive. The products we reviewed offer features we look for, but the details matter—especially how long the money is committed and whether the crediting terms are guaranteed.
Eagle Life Insurance Company has an A (Excellent) financial strength rating from AM Best. That is a good rating and above our A− minimum for recommending an insurer.
For accumulation, we like that Eagle Life offers a traditional S&P 500 strategy with a cap that can be locked for the surrender period. Knowing the cap cannot be reduced during that period is valuable, although the locked cap may start lower than a cap that can change at renewal. We generally prefer the shorter commitment unless the longer version offers enough of an advantage to justify tying up your money for additional years.
For lifetime income, we like that the income design includes a contractual roll-up and payout factors established when you purchase the annuity. That gives you a more dependable starting point than relying entirely on future index performance. We would compare the actual guaranteed paycheck with other A− or better-rated insurers for the same age, deposit, income start date, and spouse protection.
We are less enthusiastic about paying extra for higher participation rates when future crediting terms can still change. We also would not choose a longer surrender period just because it offers more attractive accumulation terms on an annuity purchased primarily for income.
What We Like
- Good financial strength: Eagle Life’s A rating is above our minimum standard.
- A traditional index with a cap-lock option: Some accumulation strategies let you lock an S&P 500 cap for the surrender period.
- Guaranteed income growth: The income design we reviewed includes a contractual roll-up rather than relying solely on index performance.
- Flexible premium options: Some contracts allow additional deposits, subject to their rules.
What We Don’t Like
- The locked cap may start lower: The certainty of a cap lock can come with less initial upside than a renewable cap.
- Optional fees: Paying for enhanced participation rates does not guarantee a better result.
- Income rider costs: The rider fee can reduce account value, and the income base used to calculate benefits is not cash you can withdraw.
- Longer commitments need a reason: More years of surrender charges should deliver a meaningful benefit—not just a slightly more attractive feature.
Explore our individual Eagle Life annuity reviews using the links below to see how the accumulation and income options compare.
Products Offered
Eagle Life offers several versions of fixed indexed annuities, typically available in 5, 7, and 10-year surrender periods, with both bonus and no-bonus options.
Key Features:
- ✅ 1-Year Fixed Account for guaranteed interest
- ✅ Engineered index options with participation rates (no traditional index options like the full S&P 500)
- ✅ GLWB income riders available for guaranteed lifetime income
- ✅ MVA (Market Value Adjustment) to enhance renewal rates or penalize early withdrawals
- ✅ Terminal illness & nursing home waivers
- ✅ Death benefit or return of premium options
Our Eagle Life Annuity Reviews
Pros
- Principal protection with market-linked growth potential
- Optional Guaranteed Lifetime Withdrawal Benefit (GLWB) rider
- Access to penalty-free withdrawals after 1 year
- Waivers for terminal illness and nursing home confinement
- Includes a 1-Year Fixed Account for stable returns
- Available through independent brokers, not captive agents
Cons
- Only offers engineered indexes with limited historical performance
- No variable or immediate annuity options
- Slightly above-average NAIC complaint index (due to low market share)
- Lower transparency on renewal cap rates and participation rates
Liquidity & Income Options
- Penalty-Free Withdrawals: Up to 10% annually after the first contract year
- GLWB Rider: Allows lifetime income without giving up control
- Annuitization: Available but not recommended (it’s irreversible and less flexible than a GLWB)
Compare Lifetime Income
Why It’s Important to Compare
While Eagle Life offers secure, conservative options, many of their annuities rely on engineered indexes with uncertain performance and limited flexibility.
Better options may be available that:
- Offer true S&P 500 indexing
- Include no-fee GLWB riders
- Come from higher-rated carriers
- Provide better growth potential and income payouts
Not all annuity products are created equal. A licensed broker can help you shop across multiple carriers to ensure you get the most value.
Death Benefit
- Standard: Lump sum paid to beneficiary
- With GLWB: Spousal continuation may be available
- No forced annuitization upon death
After the Surrender Period
Once the surrender schedule ends:
- You can withdraw funds without penalty
- Begin income payments or
- Leave the contract to grow (subject to renewal rates)
Always compare renewal rate history and crediting strategy competitiveness after the term.
Final Verdict
Is Eagle Life a good insurance company?
Yes—Eagle Life is a financially sound provider offering fixed indexed annuities built for protection and guaranteed income. However, the limited indexing options, reliance on proprietary strategies, and lack of diversity in product types may leave you with fewer opportunities for long-term growth.
If you’re considering an annuity, we strongly recommend comparing Eagle Life against other A-rated carriers that offer more traditional indexing options and better income guarantees.
Book A Free Consultation
Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.
Let Us Answer Your Questions
Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.