Is Nationwide Life & Annuity Insurance Company a Good Company To Buy From?
Short Answer: Yes—Nationwide Life & Annuity Insurance Company is financially strong, well-established, and dependable for long-term annuity and life insurance commitments. Its high ratings and long history make it a trustworthy carrier. Still, strong ratings do not automatically mean every product is ideal for you, so evaluating each policy’s structure, cost, and features remains essential.
Nationwide has been in business for nearly a century, originally founded in 1926. It has built a reputation as a financially stable and diversified insurer offering a wide range of insurance and retirement solutions. Nationwide is rated A+ by A.M. Best, A1 by Moody’s, A+ by S&P, and A+ by Fitch. These ratings reflect strong claims-paying ability and financial discipline, giving policyholders confidence in the company’s long-term stability.
Insurance and Financial Products Offered by Nationwide
Nationwide provides a comprehensive suite of insurance and retirement products for individuals and families:
- Auto Insurance: Offers traditional coverage, accident forgiveness, vanishing deductible benefits, and usage-based insurance such as SmartRide® and SmartMiles® for low-mileage and safe drivers.
- Homeowners Insurance: Covers standard property risks and offers optional features like Better Roof Replacement and enhanced valuables coverage. Not available in all states.
- Life Insurance: Includes term life, whole life, and universal life policies, each designed to meet different protection and wealth transfer needs.
- Annuities: Offers fixed, indexed, and variable annuities designed to provide tax-deferred growth and guaranteed lifetime income options.
- Other Insurance: Includes renters, pet, umbrella, and business insurance solutions.
Why Comparing Rates and Income Payouts Matters
When evaluating insurance or annuity products from any company—including Nationwide—it’s critical to compare:
- Premium Rates: Even among top-tier insurers, pricing can vary significantly for the same level of coverage. Always compare quotes.
- Interest Rates on Fixed Accounts: For fixed annuities or universal life policies with cash value, compare current interest rates to ensure your money grows competitively.
- Income Payouts from Annuities: Not all annuity income guarantees are created equal. Review payout options, guarantee periods, and whether a product includes a guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit (GLWB) rider.
These comparisons will help you assess whether Nationwide is competitive with other providers—not just in name recognition but in actual value.
Compare Nationwide Annuities To Other Companies
Our Professional Opinion
Nationwide is a great insurance company, and we especially like some of its annuities for guaranteed lifetime income for couples. Its fixed annuity and long-term care options are also worth comparing, but we are less enthusiastic about using its income-focused indexed annuities for accumulation.
Nationwide Life Insurance Company and Nationwide Life and Annuity Insurance Company both have A+ (Superior) ratings from AM Best, comfortably above our A− minimum.
For couples, we like that an available income option can continue the same guaranteed payment to the surviving spouse after the first spouse dies. Some riders also provide contractual income growth while you wait to start withdrawals. Compare the actual guaranteed paycheck for both spouses—not just the size of the income base.
We also like Nationwide’s long-term care options that can pay cash benefits after a qualifying claim, giving families flexibility in how care is provided. The reviewed family includes both life insurance and annuity-based coverage, so the contract choice matters.
For accumulation, we would compare Nationwide’s indexed annuities with a simpler product that locks a competitive cap on a traditional index. Some Nationwide contracts have longer surrender periods, fees, and crediting terms that can change at renewal.
What We Like
- Great financial strength: Nationwide’s A+ ratings exceed our standard.
- Joint lifetime income: An available option can maintain the payment for the surviving spouse.
- Guaranteed income growth: Some riders provide a contractual roll-up before withdrawals begin.
- Flexible care benefits: Qualifying long-term care coverage can provide cash for care under its rules.
What We Don’t Like
- Renewal-rate risk: Some caps and participation rates can change while surrender charges still apply.
- Income rider fees: Charges can reduce the account value available to you or your beneficiaries.
- Complex indexed strategies: We generally prefer a straightforward traditional index with a competitive cap lock.
- Income annuity access: Some payment contracts limit control over the original deposit.
Explore our individual Nationwide reviews using the links below to see which products we like and how they compare.
Nationwide Annuity Reviews
- Secure Growth Annuity
- New Heights Annuity
- Peak 10 FIA
- Nationwide Income Promise Select Annuity
- Nationwide CareMatters
Who Nationwide Is Right For
Nationwide is best for individuals who want a financially sound, well-known insurer with multiple product offerings under one roof. It’s especially suitable for those seeking usage-based auto insurance, flexible annuity income options, and strong life insurance options with long-term guarantees.
Who Might Consider Other Options
Nationwide may not be the best fit for cost-sensitive buyers focused solely on the lowest price or individuals seeking specialized products not available in all states. Additionally, those interested in high-income annuity payouts should shop around, as other insurers may offer higher GLWB payout factors or better cap and participation rates on indexed annuities.
Complementary Products to Consider
- Fixed Indexed Annuities (FIAs): If you’re evaluating retirement income solutions, FIAs offer principal protection with upside potential linked to market indexes.
- Long-Term Care Insurance or Hybrid Life/Annuity Products: Consider these for asset protection in the event of a long-term care need.
- Life Insurance with Accelerated Benefit Riders: Provides flexibility in the event of chronic illness or a terminal diagnosis.
Final Thoughts
Nationwide’s long history, strong financial ratings, and full portfolio of insurance and annuity products make it a reliable choice for many Americans. However, product value varies by offering, and policyholders should always compare premium rates, interest crediting strategies, and guaranteed income payouts before making a final decision. Want help comparing Nationwide to other top insurers? Contact The Annuity Expert for personalized guidance and free quotes on insurance and annuity options.
Book A Free Consultation
Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.
Let Us Answer Your Questions
Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.