Review of New England Life Insurance Company: Is It a Good Choice?
Short Answer: Yes—New England Life Insurance Company is backed by solid financial strength ratings, as it is a subsidiary of Brighthouse Financial. However, strong issuer ratings don’t automatically equal the best policy fit, so you still need to compare the specific product details before buying.
Financial Ratings & Company Strength
- A.M. Best: A (Excellent)
- S&P: A (Strong)
- Moody’s: A3 (Upper-Medium)
- Fitch: A (Strong)
- Comdex Score (approximate): 76
These ratings indicate that NELICO has good claims-paying ability and financial backing that should support long-term guarantees.
What New England Life Sells
New England Life no longer sells new policies directly. If you want new coverage, you’d buy it through their parent company, Brighthouse Financial, and its affiliated issuing companies. Available products may include (varying by state):
- Life insurance: Term life and universal life
- Annuities: Fixed annuities and multi-year guaranteed annuities (MYGAs) through affiliated issuers.
- Riders and features: Options like accelerated death benefit riders and other living benefit features, depending on the specific policy.
Why Company Stability Matters
When buying life insurance or an annuity, you’re depending on the insurer to:
- Honor death-benefit or income guarantees many years down the road
- Maintain stable operations over decades.
- Support policy servicing and claims reliably
NELICO’s strong ratings make it a viable issuer for long-term commitments.
Why Strong Ratings Don’t Automatically Mean Great Products
Even with strong ratings, a policy may:
- Have higher premiums than comparable alternatives
- Features less competitive cash-value growth in permanent life products.
- Restrict flexibility, liquidity, or rider options.
- It should be designed more to benefit the company than the consumer.
Thus, issuer strength is necessary but not sufficient—you still must evaluate policy design and fit.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Strong ratings across major agencies
- Comdex around 76, indicating above-average strength
- Suitable for long-term protection from a financially credible issuer
Cons:
- It may cost more compared with specialized or lower-cost carriers.
- Product features, cash-value performance, or rider options may not match niche or best-in-class carriers.
- Not all policy types or riders may be available in every state.
Who Needs NELICO and Why
- Individuals or families seeking lifetime protection with a strong issuer
- Buyers wanting both life insurance and annuity solutions backed by a reliable company
- People are willing to pay for issuer strength rather than chasing the absolute lowest cost.
Who Should Consider Other Options
- Shoppers whose sole goal is the cheapest term life and are comfortable switching carriers later
- Buyers needing ultra-large face amounts or very advanced riders, and willing to explore niche carriers
- Users whose coverage need is extremely short-term (<5 years), where issuer longevity is less critical.
Additional Insurance to Consider
- Disability income insurance to protect your earnings
- Long-term care insurance or hybrid life + LTC solutions
- Annuities with guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefits (GLWB) if income in retirement is a goal
- Supplemental accident or critical illness insurance
- Permanent life insurance with living benefit riders for future flexibility
People Who Benefit Most
- Long-term planners holding coverage for decades
- Families wanting a reliable death benefit and strong issuer backing
- Consumers value issuer stability over minimal cost.
- Business owners or high-net-worth individuals needing a trusted provider
How to Evaluate NELICO Before Buying
- Compare quotes with other A-rated carriers.
- Review the policy’s premium cost, rider fees, surrender charges, and flexibility.
- Confirm the underwriting class, state availability, and policy features.
- Make sure the policy matches your health, budget, and timeline.
- Use an independent broker to compare multiple insurers.
How NELICO Compares to Other Strong Carriers
- Strengths: strong ratings, credible issuer, long-term viability
- Trade-offs: some carriers may offer lower cost, more aggressive cash-value accumulation, or more flexible riders
Your choice depends on whether you prioritize cost, features, or issuer strength.
How to Save Money When Buying Coverage
- Obtain multiple quotes from A-rated companies, including NELICO.
- Choose term life if your need is temporary.
- Skip riders you won’t use
- Optimize your health and lifestyle to qualify for a better underwriting class.
- Work with an independent broker for full market access.
What If You Already Own a NELICO Policy?
- If it still meets your goals and the premiums are reasonable, keeping it makes sense given the issuer’s strength.
- Review your policy if your financial, health, or family situation has changed.
- Replace only if the new policy clearly offers better long-term value after accounting for lost benefits and higher costs.
- Have a professional review your in-force policy to compare with current market options.
How to Know If NELICO Is Right for You
You may be a good fit if:
- You value issuer strength and plan to keep coverage long-term
- You’re comfortable with a moderate premium cost in exchange for stability.
- The policy you’re considering aligns with your budget and goals.
Always Compare Before Buying
- Strong company + wrong product = poor value.
- Make sure you evaluate cost, features, flexibility, and long-term suitability.
What To Do Next
Contact The Annuity Expert for free quotes comparing New England Life Insurance Company with other top-rated carriers. We’ll help you evaluate policy cost, features, and fit so you buy with confidence.
Book A Free Consultation
Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.
Let Us Answer Your Questions
Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.
Questions From Our Readers
Is New England Life financially strong? Yes—ratings include A (A.M. Best), A (S&P), A (Fitch), A3 (Moody’s), and Comdex ~76.
Does a strong insurer guarantee a great policy? No, you still must evaluate policy design, cost, and fit.
Does NELICO offer both life insurance and annuities? Yes—life insurance and annuity solutions are available (depending on state and product).
Should I compare NELICO with other insurers? Yes—comparison ensures the best value.