Quick Verdict
Bottom Line: American Century Life is a specialty annuity carrier, not a full-service life insurance company. If you want maximum claims-paying strength, a B++ rating is below the A- or better standard we recommend for long-term guarantees. If you still want to use a B++ insurer, keep commitments short (under 5 years) when possible and compare stronger carriers first before you lock in lifetime payments or Medicaid planning structures that are hard to undo.
Our Professional Opinion on American Century Life Annuities
American Century Life falls below our minimum financial-strength standard, so we do not recommend its annuities. AM Best rates the company B++ (Good), below the A− rating we require. We would choose an A− or better-rated insurance company for fixed growth, income, or Medicaid planning.
The company offers deferred annuities with different approaches to interest guarantees and access. Its immediate annuities provide payments for a selected period, and its Medicaid annuity is designed for a specific planning purpose. Those features do not change our concern about the insurer’s rating.
For fixed growth, compare rates and withdrawal provisions from stronger insurers. For lifetime income, compare a guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit. If Medicaid planning is the goal, work with an elder-law attorney to compare appropriately structured contracts from stronger insurers. A product marketed for Medicaid does not automatically qualify under your state’s rules.
What We Like
- A range of purposes: The company offers fixed savings, immediate payments, and a Medicaid-oriented annuity.
- Optional access features: Some deferred annuities offer withdrawal options, subject to the contract and rider selected.
- Fixed-period payments: Immediate annuities can provide income for a defined time, which can help cover a specific income gap.
What We Don’t Like
- Below our rating minimum: The B++ AM Best rating does not meet our A− standard.
- Access and death benefits vary: Deferred annuity provisions depend on the product and any riders selected.
- Immediate payments are a commitment: The income annuities restrict access to the deposit after issue.
- Medicaid qualification is not automatic: The contract must fit the applicant’s circumstances and applicable state rules.
Explore our individual American Century Life annuity reviews using the links below to learn how each product works and why we would compare other insurers.
Company Snapshot
- Founded: 1940
- A.M. Best Rating: B++
- Sells: Fixed deferred annuities, fixed immediate annuities, Medicaid-compliant annuities
What This Means For You: This company is built around guaranteed interest and payout contracts, not market-based products or life insurance. Your decision hinges on carrier strength, contract restrictions, and how permanent your income decision is.
What They Sell And How Each Product Works
Fixed Deferred Annuities:
You deposit money now, it earns fixed interest for a period, and you can later withdraw or convert it into income. These typically include a surrender period where early withdrawals trigger charges. This is used for conservative growth, tax deferral (when funded with after-tax money), and future income planning.
Fixed Immediate Annuities:
You deposit money, and income starts quickly (often within 12 months). This is essentially annuitization, meaning you’re converting a lump sum into a paycheck. Once you start, it’s typically irreversible, and your ability to change course is limited.
Medicaid-Compliant Annuities:
These are usually immediate annuity structures designed to fit Medicaid planning rules by converting countable assets into an income stream. These are technical and state-sensitive. If set up incorrectly, you can create Medicaid problems instead of solving them.
Our Annuity Reviews
Every Realistic Solution If You’re Considering American Century Life
- Solution 1: Shop and compare higher-rated insurers first. If you’re buying anything that lasts a long time, the most practical “feature” is financial strength. A stronger company reduces the risk that you’re depending on a weaker balance sheet for decades.
- Solution 2: Use American Century only when the contract term is short. With a B++ rating, short commitments reduce your exposure. For deferred annuities, that typically means keeping the surrender period and intended holding period tight.
- Solution 3: If you want a lifetime income, be honest about the permanence. Immediate annuities and many Medicaid-compliant annuities are built around annuitization. If you want flexibility, these products are usually the wrong tool because you’re trading control for certainty.
- Solution 4: If Medicaid planning is the real goal, treat the annuity as a legal strategy, not a rate play. Medicaid-compliant annuities are about eligibility and timing, not maximizing return. You need coordination with your Medicaid planning professional and an insurance agent who has done these correctly.
- Solution 5: If you already own one, get an in-force review before you touch it. Surrendering or exchanging can trigger surrender charges and tax issues. The contract you already own may still be the least-bad option depending on timing.
Pros And Cons That Actually Matter
Pros:
- American Century’s focus on fixed products means you are not dealing with market volatility. Fixed deferred annuities can work for conservative savers who want predictable accumulation and a future income option.
- Immediate annuities can create a stable paycheck quickly, which can help with budgeting when other income sources are inconsistent.
- Medicaid-compliant annuities can be useful in very specific Medicaid planning scenarios when structured correctly.
Cons:
- The biggest issue is financial strength. A B++ rating is below the A- level we prefer for long-term promises.
- Immediate annuities and Medicaid-compliant annuities can be functionally irreversible, which means one bad decision can be permanent.
- Deferred annuities can limit liquidity through surrender charges.
- Not all annuities are FDIC insured, and earnings are generally taxed as ordinary income when withdrawn (rules vary by funding type).
Who Needs These Products And Why
Good Fit: Someone who wants fixed, predictable contract terms and understands the trade-off of using a lower-rated carrier. A conservative saver who wants a fixed deferred annuity for a specific, shorter goal can be a fit. A retiree who needs immediate income and is intentionally trading flexibility for a paycheck can be a fit. Medicaid planning clients who need a Medicaid-compliant annuity as part of an eligibility strategy can be a fit, but only with proper coordination.
Who Doesn’t Need These Products And Why
Bad Fit: Anyone who wants flexibility, wants to keep full control of principal, or might need to change course later. If you want “income you can turn on later” with control, a product line limited to immediate and fixed contracts may not match your goals. If you want long-term guarantees with the lowest company risk, a B++ carrier is not where you should start. If you’re rate-shopping without understanding Medicaid rules, a Medicaid-compliant annuity can backfire.
What Accounts Can Fund These Annuities
Funding Options: After-tax cash (non-qualified), Traditional IRA, Roth IRA, 401(k) rollover, 403(b) rollover, 457(b), SEP IRA, SIMPLE IRA. Your tax treatment depends on the account type. Non-qualified annuities are taxed on gains, while qualified annuities generally produce taxable withdrawals. Medicaid planning annuities are especially sensitive to ownership, beneficiary, and payout setup, so funding and titling must be done carefully.
Related Insurance That Often Solves The Bigger Problem
- Long-Term Care Insurance: If the worry is future care costs, long-term care insurance can solve the problem directly instead of trying to “Medicaid engineer” around it later.
- Life Insurance: If you’re converting a lump sum into income and giving up legacy, life insurance can replace what might be lost for heirs.
- Disability Insurance: If you’re still working, disability insurance protects your income while you’re alive. Annuities don’t.
- Medigap: For retirees, Medigap helps control short-term healthcare out-of-pocket costs so you’re not draining assets unnecessarily.
Ways To Save Money And Avoid Costly Mistakes
- Compare contracts before you commit: Different carriers handle surrender charges, payout options, and beneficiary provisions differently, and those details matter more than marketing.
- Don’t buy an immediate annuity casually: Once you annuitize, you typically can’t undo it. Make sure you are comfortable giving up control.
- Don’t DIY a Medicaid-compliant annuity: The wrong setup can trigger a Medicaid denial or penalties.
- Use your agent for an in-force review: If you already own a contract, your agent should review it, or you can have us review it independently before you surrender, exchange, or start income.
Talk To The Annuity Expert For Free Quotes And A Second Opinion
Next Step: If you’re thinking about buying an American Century fixed deferred annuity, fixed immediate annuity, or Medicaid-compliant annuity, or you already own one and want to know if it still makes sense, talk with a licensed insurance agent first. You can work with your current agent, or contact The Annuity Expert for free quotes, a second opinion, and help shopping and comparing options. We’re licensed in all 50 states, and we’ll tell you the downsides before you sign anything.🌟
Book A Free Consultation
Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.
Let Us Answer Your Questions
Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.