Independent Insurance & Financial Reviews

Shawn Plummer, CRPC

Retirement Planner, Financial Advisor, Annuity Broker, and Insurance Agent

Carriers and Products

Choosing an insurance policy or a retirement vehicle is a long-term commitment. You aren’t just buying a piece of paper; you are buying a promise that a company will be there to protect your family or pay your income decades from now.

Our review directory is built on a “Company-First” philosophy. We believe you must first verify the financial strength and integrity of the carrier before you ever look at the “bells and whistles” of a specific product. Before you make a purchase, we highly recommend reading our guide on how insurance company ratings work and our updated list of insurance companies to avoid. You can also check out recent regulatory action against some insurance companies.

Below, you can browse our independent ratings of the top insurance companies in the industry, followed by deep dives into their specific product lines.

️ Insurance Company Reviews (Carrier Ratings)

We analyze the world’s leading insurance carriers to see how they stack up in the areas that matter most: financial solvency, claims-paying history, and customer satisfaction. Every company review includes current A.M. Best Ratings, Comdex Scores, and a “Trust Factor” assessment.

Company (Linked to Current URL)AM Best RatingRating Meaning
Accordia LifeAExcellent
AflacA+Superior
Allianz LifeA+Superior
American Century Life B++Good
American GeneralAExcellent
American GulfB++Good
American EquityAExcellent
American Income LifeAExcellent
American Life Security CorpB++Good
American National (ANICO)AExcellent
AmericoAExcellent
AmeritasAExcellent
Aspida LifeA-Excellent
Assurity LifeA-Excellent
Athene Annuity & LifeA+Superior
Atlantic CoastC+Marginal (Recently downgraded)
AxonicA-Excellent
Baltimore LifeB++Good
Bankers LifeAExcellent
Banner LifeAExcellent
Brighthouse FinancialAExcellent
Canvas AnnuitiesB++Good
Cincinnati LifeA+Superior
Cigna Health & LifeAExcellent
CL LifeB++Good
Clear Spring LifeA-Excellent
CMFG LifeAExcellent
Colonial LifeAExcellent
Colorado Bankers LifeEUnder Regulatory Supervision
Commonwealth AnnuityAExcellent
Corebridge FinancialAExcellent
Delaware LifeA-Excellent
Eagle LifeAExcellent
Edward Jones Not RatedN/A
EthosAExcellent
Equitable FinancialAExcellent
Equitrust LifeB++Good
Farmers Life B++Good
Fidelity & GuarantyAExcellent
Fidelity InvestmentsA+Superior
First Security Benefit A-Excellent
Forethought LifeAExcellent
GainbridgeA-Excellent
GBUA-Excellent
GenworthB-Fair
GerberA+Superior
GILICOA-Excellent
Global AtlanticAExcellent
Guardian LifeA++Superior
Hartford LifeA+Superior
Heartland NationalB++Good
Horace MannAExcellent
Ibexis LifeA-Excellent
Integrity LifeA+Superior
Investors HeritageB++Good
Jackson NationalAExcellent
John HancockA+Superior
Knighthead LifeA-Excellent
Legal & GeneralA+Superior
Liberty BankersA-Excellent
Lincoln Financial GroupAExcellent
Manhattan LifeB++Good
MassMutualA++Superior
Midland NationalA+Superior
MetLifeA+Superior
Modern WoodmenAExcellent
Mountain LifeB-Fair
Mutual of OmahaA+Superior
Nassau LifeB++Good
National Life Group (LSW)A+Superior
National Western LifeA-Excellent
NationwideA+Superior
New England Life (NELICO)AExcellent
New York LifeA++Superior
North American LifeA+Superior
Northwestern MutualA++Superior
Oceanview LifeAExcellent
Ohio State LifeB++Good
OneAmericaA+Superior
Oxford LifeAExcellent
Pacific Guardian AExcellent
Pacific LifeA+Superior
Penn MutualA+Superior
PHL Annuity and Life Under Court Supervision N/A
Protective LifeA+Superior
PrudentialA+Superior
Reliance StandardA++Superior
Revol OneB++Good
Riversource LifeA+Superior
Royal NeighborsAExcellent
Sagicor LifeAExcellent
SBLIAExcellent
Securian FinancialA+Superior
Security BenefitA-Excellent
Sentinel Security LifeC+Marginal (Recently downgraded)
SILACBFair
Sons of NorwayA-Excellent
State FarmA+Superior
Stellar National B+Good
Symetra LifeAExcellent
Talcott Financial GroupA-Excellent
Texas LifeA+Superior
The StandardAExcellent
ThriventA++Superior
TIAAA++Superior
TransamericaAExcellent
TruStageAExcellent
United LifeA-Excellent
Unum LifeAExcellent
Upstream LifeB++Good
USAAA++Superior
VALICAExcellent
Voya RetirementAExcellent
Western & SouthernA+Superior
Wichita NationalB+Good
Zurich AmericanA+Superior

 

 

Independent Insurance & Financial Reviews Retirement & Annuity Product Reviews

If your goal is protected growth or guaranteed lifetime income, these reviews break down the complex math behind today’s most popular retirement contracts.

Fixed Index Annuities: See the real caps and participation rates.

Before checking out specific products, learn how we evaluate fixed index annuities.

MYGAs: Find the best multi-year guaranteed rates.

Immediate Annuities: Compare payout rates and inflation protection.

Fixed Deferred Annuities: Evaluate the true cost of death benefits and income riders.

RILAs: Contrast buffer protection depths against maximum loss floors.

Variable Annuities: Uncover hidden fees and sub-account performance.

Online Annuity Platforms: Brokers vs. Lead Generators

When you search for annuity information online, you will likely stumble across heavily advertised websites that look like insurance agencies but are actually lead generation platforms.

What is a Lead Generation Platform? These websites do not actually sell annuities, and they are not financial advisors. Their sole business model is to collect your personal information (name, phone number, email) and sell it to the highest-bidding insurance agents in your area. If you fill out a form on these sites, expect your phone to ring constantly from multiple salespeople.

How We Are Different (We Are Brokers) At The Annuity Expert, we are a licensed, independent brokerage. We do not sell your data to random agents. When you contact us, you work directly with our licensed retirement planners. We shop the market, do the math side-by-side, and actually help you buy the policy—staying with you for the life of your contract.

Before you give away your contact information online, read our transparent reviews on the internet’s largest annuity lead generation platforms to understand exactly what happens to your data:

Why Our Reviews Are Different

Most review sites are simply “brochure summaries.” We go deeper.

  • Financial Strength Verification: We don’t just list products; we verify the company’s ability to pay.
  • “Who It’s For” Analysis: Every product review ends with a clear verdict on the ideal buyer vs. who should stay away.
  • Independent Updates: The insurance world changes fast. We regularly update our product reviews to reflect current interest rates, caps, and participation changes.

What You Should Do Next

If you’re considering buying annuities, life insurance, disability insurance, or long-term care insurance, don’t work through the insurance ratings and reviews alone. The Annuity Expert can help you understand which companies are financially strong and which products fit your needs.

Schedule a free consultation below, or give us a call at (770) 755-1565 to purchase coverage from reputable companies that fit your needs. We’ll compare ratings, explain risks, and help you save money while protecting your future.

 

Shawn Plummer, CRPC

Retirement Planner, Financial Advisor, Annuity Broker, and Insurance Agent

I am a licensed Retirement Planner (CRPC), insurance agent, financial advisor, annuity broker, and former financial trainer with more than 18 years of hands-on experience in annuities and insurance. My National Producer Number (NPN) is 15524738. I spent 12 years training financial advisors nationwide on annuity, insurance, and retirement planning strategies, in addition to 18 years of direct field experience selling annuities and insurance products, helping clients protect their savings and secure reliable retirement income.

I have been quoted in Time Magazine, Bloomberg, Entrepreneur, Yahoo! Finance, MSN, SmartAsset, LegalZoom, U.S. News & World Report, Women’s Health Magazine, Forbes, and many other leading publications.

I am also the founder of The Annuity Expert, an independent online insurance agency and annuity broker serving consumers across the United States. Through this platform, my team and I help Americans remove the guesswork from retirement planning and compare insurance solutions to find the strongest value at the most competitive rates. I want to see you get the best products at the lowest prices.

Scroll to Top