Why Settling for Simplicity May Cost You Long-Term Retirement Income
If you’re evaluating TruStage annuities through your credit union, you’re likely attracted by the brand’s convenience and reputation for security. But while TruStage offers safe options, the real question is: Are you sacrificing growth, income, and flexibility by not comparing with other carriers? In this breakdown, we’ll show you how TruStage stacks up against other top-rated insurance companies—and how annuities with guaranteed income riders, premium bonuses, and stronger crediting strategies can offer more for your retirement.
How TruStage Annuities Work
TruStage annuities are issued by CMFG Life Insurance Company, rated A (Excellent) by AM Best. TruStage typically offers:
- Fixed Deferred Annuities with guaranteed interest rates
- Immediate Annuities for income starting now
- Limited fixed indexed annuity options with basic S&P 500 strategies
Most TruStage annuities are marketed through credit unions. They’re positioned as conservative, principal-protected products—but they rarely include features like income riders, premium bonuses, or competitive index strategies.
How TruStage Compares to Other Annuity Companies
| Feature | TruStage (CMFG Life) | Top Annuity Companies (e.g., Allianz, Athene, F&G, Corebridge) |
|---|---|---|
| Financial Rating | A (Excellent) with AM Best | A to A+ ratings depending on carrier |
| Distribution | Credit unions only | Independent brokers offer unbiased product selection |
| Product Types | Fixed and basic immediate annuities | Full suite: FIAs, MYGAs, SPIAs, DIAs, GLWBs, LTC hybrid annuities |
| Fixed Indexed Annuities | Limited to simple crediting methods | Participation rate strategies, reset-friendly index options with no caps |
| Income Riders (GLWB) | Rarely offered | Available with increasing, level, or performance-based income options |
| Bonus Annuities | Not typically offered | Commonly included for income or accumulation benefits |
| Liquidity Features | 10% annual free withdrawal | RMD, confinement, and terminal illness waivers with cumulative liquidity options |
| Death Benefit | Basic lump sum payout | Enhanced death benefits and spousal continuation with GLWBs |
| Post-Surrender Growth | Renew at new fixed rate | FIA accounts continue to grow or can convert to income with or without fees |
TruStage Annuity Pros and Cons
Pros
- Simple, conservative annuity structure
- A-rated carrier backed by CUNA Mutual Group
- Basic principal protection and fixed interest
Cons
- No GLWB riders for guaranteed lifetime income
- Limited growth due to fixed or capped strategies
- No premium bonuses for accumulation or income
- No long-term care integration
- Fewer options for legacy and spousal planning
Who Should Consider TruStage
TruStage is suitable for:
- Credit union members who prefer a conservative, no-frills annuity
- Investors prioritizing capital preservation with limited interest growth
- People not seeking guaranteed income, death benefit customization, or index growth potential
Who Should Not Use TruStage:
- Investors needing guaranteed income for life through a GLWB
- Anyone seeking competitive fixed annuity rates or uncapped index crediting strategies
- Clients planning for long-term care or legacy planning with life insurance integration
- Buyers comparing multi-year guaranteed annuities (MYGAs) with better liquidity and growth
Alternatives to TruStage
If you’re serious about creating predictable income or maximizing safe returns, consider annuities from companies like:
- Athene: Market-leading FIAs with strong GLWBs
- F&G: Innovative no-fee income options and hybrid annuity-LTC products
- Allianz: Increasing income riders, inflation-based income, and multi-index options
- Corebridge, MassMutual Ascend, Oceanview, Brighthouse: Top-rated MYGAs and fixed annuities with market value adjustment (MVA) provisions for higher renewal rates
What Happens After the Term?
With TruStage annuities, after the surrender period ends, the contract either renews at a new rate or continues earning interest at the renewal rate offered at the time. With other carriers, especially fixed indexed annuities (FIAs) or MYGAs, you may have the option to roll the contract into:
- A new annuity with a GLWB
- A MYGA with better rates
- Or begin guaranteed lifetime withdrawals without annuitization
TruStage lacks post-surrender options like income riders or flexible renewal products.
Best Ways To Fund an Annuity (Including TruStage)
You can fund a TruStage or other annuity with:
- 401(k) rollover
- Traditional or Roth IRA
- 403(b) or TSP transfer
- Inherited IRA (non-spouse rules apply)
- After-tax (non-qualified) lump sum
- Cash value from life insurance (1035 exchange)
Insurance You May Also Need
- Permanent Life Insurance: Use this alongside any annuity to recover principal left behind after withdrawals or death. TruStage doesn’t offer estate planning integration.
- Standalone Long-Term Care Insurance or Hybrid LTC Annuities: TruStage annuities don’t include LTC waivers or riders. You’ll need separate protection to avoid depleting your retirement assets from nursing home care.
- GLWB Annuities: A fixed indexed annuity with a lifetime income rider allows you to maintain growth potential while taking guaranteed withdrawals for life, without annuitizing the contract.
Final Thoughts
TruStage annuities may feel familiar and safe, but they often lack the income and growth flexibility most retirees need. You’re getting conservative features—but missing out on guaranteed income riders, better interest rates, and stronger death benefits offered by other top-rated insurance companies. The cost of convenience is lower income and fewer long-term benefits.
Get A Free Annuity Comparison Today
Don’t settle for low interest or limited options. Contact The Annuity Expert for a free quote comparison. We’ll show you how TruStage stacks up against the best A-rated annuity companies—so you can protect your retirement income with confidence and at the lowest cost.
Book A Free Consultation
Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.
Let Us Answer Your Questions
Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.