Our Professional Opinion on the Prudential FlexGuard Annuity
We generally do not recommend the Prudential FlexGuard annuity. FlexGuard is a registered index-linked annuity, or RILA. You can lose money when an index declines beyond the selected buffer, while your gains are still controlled by caps, participation rates, spreads, tier levels, step rates, term lengths, and other contract rules.
Prudential is an excellent annuity company. Pruco Life Insurance Company is rated A+ by AM Best and comfortably exceeds our minimum financial-strength standard.
We view RILAs as a gimmicky middle ground between a variable annuity and a fixed indexed annuity. If you are comfortable accepting market losses, we would rather compare a lower-cost variable annuity or managed investment portfolio. If avoiding market losses is the priority, we would rather use a fixed indexed annuity.
FlexGuard is one of the more flexible RILAs because it offers several traditional market choices, including the S&P 500, Russell 2000, Nasdaq-100, and MSCI EAFE. It also provides multiple crediting strategies, term lengths, buffer choices, variable investment subaccounts, and a Performance Lock feature.
Those features do not create complete principal protection. Partial buffers only absorb losses within the selected protection level. Losses beyond the buffer reduce the account value. Variable investment subaccounts do not provide buffer protection at all.
Some strategies may provide full protection against an index decline at the scheduled term-end date, but that protection depends on following the strategy rules and holding the allocation through the full term. An early withdrawal or reallocation can produce a lower interim value and may result in a loss in addition to any applicable surrender charge.
The “no explicit product fee” description does not mean FlexGuard is free. The index strategies still limit the owner’s return through caps, participation rates, spreads, tier levels, term rules, and index adjustments. Certain indexes and exchange-traded-fund-linked strategies may also include underlying fees, reductions, or tracking differences. Variable investment options have their own expenses.
We prefer the traditional index choices over the AB 500 Plus Index. The AB 500 Plus is an engineered index with an embedded annual reduction. A higher-looking participation rate does not automatically mean that strategy will produce a better net return than a transparent traditional index.
Renewal control is another concern. Caps, participation rates, spreads, step rates, and tier levels can change when a new strategy term begins. The initial terms should not be treated as permanent contract terms.
The Performance Lock can protect a gain or limit a developing loss, but it requires the owner to make a timing decision. Locking at the wrong time can permanently lock in a loss, eliminate additional index credit, or provide less buffer protection than waiting until the scheduled term-end date.
FlexGuard is primarily an accumulation product. It does not solve a future long-term care need. Someone concerned about care expenses should evaluate long-term care insurance or a hybrid long-term care solution separately.
Bottom line: FlexGuard is one of the better-designed RILAs, but we still do not see a compelling reason to use it over the cleaner alternatives. You can lose money, your upside remains controlled by the insurer, renewal terms can change, and the contract is substantially more complicated than either a variable annuity or a fixed indexed annuity.
What We Like
- A+ AM Best Rating: Pruco Life is a financially strong issuing company.
- Traditional Market Choices: The contract includes the S&P 500, Russell 2000, Nasdaq-100, and MSCI EAFE.
- Several Crediting Strategies: Point-to-point, enhanced cap, dual-directional, step-rate, and tiered-participation choices provide flexibility.
- Multiple Protection Levels: Buyers can select different buffers based on the index, strategy, and term.
- Performance Lock: The owner can lock an eligible performance value before the scheduled term-end date.
- Variable Investment Options: Buyers who deliberately want direct market exposure can combine variable subaccounts with index strategies.
- Reallocation at Term End: Allocations can be changed when an index strategy reaches the end of its term.
What We Don’t Like
- You Can Lose Money: Index losses beyond the selected buffer reduce the account value.
- Variable Subaccounts Have No Downside Protection: Those allocations can experience full investment losses.
- The Upside Is Still Limited: Caps, participation rates, spreads, step rates, tier levels, and term rules control the credited return.
- “No Explicit Product Fee” Can Be Misleading: Implicit costs, index reductions, underlying expenses, and surrender charges still affect the result.
- Renewal Terms Can Change: The initial crediting terms are not guaranteed for the life of the contract.
- Performance Lock Can Lock In a Bad Result: Exercising the feature at the wrong time can permanently capture a loss or reduce the eventual credit and protection.
- Full-Term Holding Is Important: Early withdrawals can produce an unfavorable interim value and cause the owner to lose expected index credit.
- Six-Year Surrender Schedule: The contract creates a long commitment for a product whose future crediting terms can change.
- Too Complicated for Most Buyers: Buffers, term-end values, interim values, variable subaccounts, engineered indexes, and multiple crediting formulas make the outcome difficult to evaluate.
What Is Prudential’s FlexGuard Indexed Variable Annuity?
FlexGuard is Prudential’s flagship indexed-variable annuity (IVA), a hybrid annuity product that combines elements of a registered variable annuity with index-linked strategies. It offers a menu of risk-adjusted growth strategies tied to various stock market indices with the goal of delivering buffered market exposure and potential for higher interest than traditional fixed products.
This is a long-term investment designed for retirement income planning, with a six-year surrender charge period starting at 8% and dropping to 0% after year 6. FlexGuard allows funding from non-qualified assets, IRAs, Roth IRAs, and other qualified retirement plans. You can allocate premiums into fixed interest options, index-linked strategies, or separate account variable subaccounts.
While it may sound appealing, this annuity comes with several trade-offs that could impact your retirement plan if you’re not careful.
How It Works
You choose one or more index strategies with various crediting methods—capped return, participation rate, or tiered return—and a buffer that shields against a set percentage of market loss (typically 10% or 20%). Investment terms can range from 1 to 6 years depending on the strategy.
It also includes a performance lock feature that allows you to lock in gains or losses within the term. After each strategy term, you can reallocate.
A standard death benefit is included that returns your premium (minus withdrawals) to your beneficiary, which can help bypass probate but does not offer any enhanced income or growth unless optional riders are added (at an additional cost).
Who Needs It and Why
FlexGuard may appeal to pre-retirees or conservative investors seeking equity-linked growth with some downside protection. If you’re comfortable with complexity and plan to hold for at least 6 years, this can provide a blend of risk-managed growth and death benefit protection. It’s suitable for tax-deferred growth in IRAs or Roth IRAs where liquidity isn’t a top concern.
Who Doesn’t Need It and Why
This annuity is not for investors who:
- Want simple, transparent growth and income solutions.
- Need guaranteed lifetime income—FlexGuard doesn’t offer a GLWB.
- Value traditional index strategies with verifiable, long-term history.
- Require full liquidity or short-term flexibility.
- Prefer working with an advisor who acts as an advocate and explains fees and performance expectations clearly.
If you’re seeking protected income for life, a fixed indexed annuity with a GLWB is a better fit. If you want guaranteed growth with no risk or fees, a MYGA offers higher fixed rates and full transparency. If your goal is market upside, a traditional brokerage account or Roth IRA invested in index ETFs will outperform FlexGuard without the fees, caps, and participation limits.
Alternatives That May Work Better
- Protected lifetime income → Choose a Fixed Indexed Annuity with a GLWB.
- Guaranteed growth → Choose a MYGA with 3–10 year durations and penalty-free RMD access.
- Principal protection with simple structure → Use a traditional FIA with a declared rate or participation strategy and no rider fees.
Compare Income From The FlexGuard With Other Options
What You’re Giving Up
By choosing FlexGuard, you give up:
- The option for lifetime income with guaranteed withdrawal benefits.
- Access to traditional S&P 500 index strategies with 10+ year performance history.
- Simplicity—this is a complex annuity with moving parts and renewal rate risk.
- An advocate—buying direct or through commission-based channels gives you no fiduciary to help with strategy selection, allocation rebalancing, or withdrawal planning.
Related Insurance to Consider
- Fixed Indexed Annuities (FIAs): Provide market-linked growth without market loss risk and usually offer income riders for lifetime paychecks.
- Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuities (MYGAs): Offer predictable growth with a guaranteed interest rate and penalty-free withdrawals in many cases.
- Life Insurance: Use permanent life insurance to protect beneficiaries and recover lost value from annuitization if required in other contracts.
- Final Expense Insurance: If you’re using FlexGuard for its death benefit, final expense insurance could be a lower-cost, simpler alternative.
Final Thoughts
Before buying Prudential FlexGuard, compare it with other annuities that offer lifetime income, better index choices, and lower complexity. Contact The Annuity Expert for free quotes and guidance on the best option for your specific goals. We’ll help you determine whether FlexGuard is worth it—or if better alternatives exist for your retirement income plan.
Let’s review your options together. Get peace of mind with a product that actually fits your goals.
Book A Free Consultation
Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.
Let Us Answer Your Questions
Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.