Is OneAmerica a Good Insurance Company?

Shawn Plummer, CRPC

Retirement Planner, Financial Advisor, Annuity Broker, and Insurance Agent

What You Need to Know Before Buying Coverage or Planning Retirement with OneAmerica

OneAmerica Financial Partners, Inc. is a mutual insurance holding company that has been serving U.S. policyholders since 1877. With over a century of continuous operation, the company offers insurance and retirement solutions through a network of companies including American United Life Insurance Company (AUL). It has consistently maintained strong financial ratings, demonstrating its commitment to financial strength and long-term promises.

Financial Ratings

OneAmerica earns high marks from major rating agencies:

  • A.M. Best: A+ (Superior)
  • S&P Global: AA- (Very Strong)
  • Fitch: A- (Strong)

These ratings reflect strong claims-paying ability and a solid financial foundation. While not the highest available, they place OneAmerica among the more stable insurers in the market.

Products Offered

OneAmerica offers a full suite of insurance and retirement products, including:

Why Comparing Premiums, Interest Rates, and Income Payouts Matters

Before committing to OneAmerica or any insurer, it’s essential to compare:

  • Premium Rates: Life insurance and long-term care policy costs can vary significantly across carriers. Comparing premiums helps ensure affordability over time.
  • Interest Rates: For annuity products, declared fixed interest rates and index crediting strategies will impact long-term growth. Some fixed index annuities (FIAs) include annual fixed-rate alternatives.
  • Income Payouts: If your goal is retirement income, evaluate how guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefits (GLWBs) and payout options compare to other insurers. Higher GLWB income payouts can increase retirement security.

Pros and Cons of Choosing OneAmerica

Pros:

  • Over 140 years of experience and mutual ownership, focused on long-term customer interests
  • Strong financial ratings, ensuring long-term claims-paying ability
  • Unique asset-based long-term care options
  • Competitive suite of annuities and retirement plan services

Cons:

  • Limited online policy management tools compared to some competitors
  • Customer service has received mixed feedback, especially in claims and administrative areas
  • Not all product types (like RILAs or enhanced GLWB income riders) are as competitive as those from specialized annuity carriers

Who Needs OneAmerica—and Who Doesn’t?

Who might benefit from OneAmerica:

Who might not benefit:

  • Individuals seeking top-tier customer support and claims responsiveness
  • Clients looking for the most competitive income riders, fixed index annuity strategies, or cutting-edge technology
  • People who want wide access to multiple market indices or structured annuity options

Consider Other Insurance or Annuities That Could Help

  • Fixed Index Annuities (FIAs): If you’re considering long-term growth and principal protection, FIAs from specialized carriers may offer higher caps or participation rates than OneAmerica’s versions.
  • GLWB Income Riders: If your goal is guaranteed lifetime income, compare GLWB payouts across multiple insurers.
  • Long-Term Care Insurance Alternatives: Compare traditional LTC policies, hybrid annuities with LTC riders, and asset-based LTC options.
  • Life Insurance for Estate Planning or Tax-Free Retirement: Consider IULs (Indexed Universal Life) for supplemental income or tax-free legacy planning.

Funding Options for Annuities

OneAmerica annuities can typically be funded by:

  • 401(k) or 403(b) rollovers
  • Traditional and Roth IRAs
  • Non-qualified brokerage or savings accounts
  • Trust-owned or business-owned plans for executive benefits

Get Help From an Expert

Before making a decision, get a free quote and side-by-side comparison from The Annuity Expert. Whether you’re looking for income for life, long-term care protection, or tax-deferred growth, we’ll help you compare OneAmerica with other top-rated providers to make sure you get the best possible outcome for your financial goals.

Book A Free Consultation

Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.

Let Us Answer Your Questions

Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.

Contact Us
First
Last

Shawn Plummer, CRPC

Retirement Planner, Financial Advisor, Annuity Broker, and Insurance Agent

I am a licensed Retirement Planner (CRPC), insurance agent, financial advisor, annuity broker, and former financial trainer with more than 18 years of hands-on experience in annuities and insurance. My National Producer Number (NPN) is 15524738. I spent 12 years training financial advisors nationwide on annuity, insurance, and retirement planning strategies, in addition to 18 years of direct field experience selling annuities and insurance products, helping clients protect their savings and secure reliable retirement income.

I have been quoted in Time Magazine, Bloomberg, Entrepreneur, Yahoo! Finance, MSN, SmartAsset, LegalZoom, U.S. News & World Report, Women’s Health Magazine, Forbes, and many other leading publications.

I am also the founder of The Annuity Expert, an independent online insurance agency and annuity broker serving consumers across the United States. Through this platform, my team and I help Americans remove the guesswork from retirement planning and compare insurance solutions to find the strongest value at the most competitive rates. I want to see you get the best products at the lowest prices.

Scroll to Top