Is Thrivent a Good Company To Buy From?
Short Answer: Yes—Thrivent is a financially strong and stable life insurance company with excellent long-term reliability. It’s a solid option for buyers who qualify for membership. However, its products must still be evaluated carefully, because strong ratings alone do not guarantee strong product design or consumer value.
Thrivent Financial is a fraternal benefit society that has been in business for more than 120 years. Originally formed in 1902, it operates as a not-for-profit organization with a Christian mission and serves over 2 million members. Its mission focuses on helping Christians be wise with money and live generously. Thrivent’s unique positioning as a faith-based financial services provider sets it apart from traditional insurers and banks.
Thrivent is consistently ranked among the most financially secure companies in the insurance industry. It maintains:
- A++ (Superior) from A.M. Best
- AA+ (Very Strong) from Standard & Poor’s
- Aa2 (Excellent) from Moody’s
These ratings reflect strong claims-paying ability, liquidity, and long-term financial health. However, a high rating doesn’t always equal the most competitive pricing or features.
Insurance and Financial Products Offered
Thrivent sells a wide selection of insurance and retirement products, including:
- Life Insurance: Offers term, whole life, and universal life policies. Whole life policies may earn dividends, although they are not guaranteed. Life insurance is only available to individuals who identify as Christian or are married to a Christian.
- Annuities: Fixed annuities, fixed indexed annuities (FIAs), and variable annuities. Income riders (GLWBs) are available to provide guaranteed lifetime income. Not all annuities are available in every state or account type.
- Disability Income Insurance: Offers income protection in the event of illness or injury, but policy options and claims procedures are limited.
- Long-Term Care Insurance: Offers both traditional LTC policies and hybrid policies that combine life insurance with long-term care coverage.
- Mutual Funds, IRAs, and Brokerage Services: Includes managed portfolios and financial planning services under a faith-based investment philosophy.
Our Thrivent Annuity Reviews
Compare Thrivent Life Insurance With 25+ Companies
Why You Must Compare Premiums, Interest Rates, and Payouts
Premiums for life insurance and long-term care can differ by hundreds or even thousands of dollars over the life of a policy. Similarly, annuity interest rates and income rider payout percentages vary dramatically by insurer.
- Premiums: You might be paying more at Thrivent simply because of brand loyalty or religious alignment. Other carriers may offer the same or better coverage for less.
- Annuity Interest Rates: Fixed annuities and fixed indexed annuities from Thrivent may not offer the highest crediting strategies, participation rates, or renewal rate transparency.
- Income Payouts: Lifetime income payouts from a Thrivent annuity with a GLWB rider could be lower than those offered by competing carriers, especially for older buyers or joint contracts.
Never assume a company’s strong reputation equates to better payouts. Every contract must be compared on actual performance and features.
Compare Thrivent Annuity Income
Pros and Cons
Pros
- 120+ years of experience and stability
- Top financial strength ratings
- Faith-driven mission that appeals to Christian households
- Wide variety of life insurance and annuity products
- Emphasis on charitable giving and community impact
- Offers both traditional and hybrid long-term care solutions
Cons
- Religious Eligibility: Only Christians or their spouses are eligible. This restricts access to coverage for non-Christians and may exclude people who don’t meet the religious criteria even if they are otherwise qualified.
- Digital Limitations: Many services, such as claims for disability income insurance, must be completed manually or over the phone. There is limited online account management, particularly compared to fully digital-first companies.
- Underwriting Leniency Varies: Thrivent may not be as flexible with health issues compared to other mutual insurers that specialize in impaired risk underwriting.
- Less Competitive for Maximum Growth: Fixed indexed annuities offer limited upside potential and often lower participation rates than top-tier FIA providers. Some contracts lack popular index strategies or offer overly complex proprietary indexes with short track records.
- Customer Service Complaints: Some policyholders report delays or denials in long-term care claims, as well as long wait times for phone support. Customer service quality appears inconsistent across product lines.
- Fewer Riders and Customization: Compared to other large carriers, there may be fewer optional riders available for annuities and life insurance. This could limit personalization for advanced income or protection strategies.
- Dividend Performance Isn’t Guaranteed: While whole life insurance policies may pay dividends, the actual returns may lag behind mutual insurers like Penn Mutual or MassMutual.
- Less Transparent Fee Disclosure: For investment accounts and variable products, the fees aren’t always easily accessible or explained upfront. This could affect long-term performance and total cost of ownership.
Who Should Consider Thrivent?
Best For:
- Practicing Christians seeking alignment between faith and financial decisions
- Individuals who value charitable giving and community involvement through membership benefits
- Buyers who prioritize long-term company stability and conservative investment strategy
- Retirees who want basic lifetime income features and don’t need high growth from their annuity
Not Ideal For:
- Non-Christians or those without a Christian spouse, as they won’t qualify for most products
- Tech-savvy individuals who expect modern digital tools, online claims, and 24/7 account access
- Consumers seeking the highest possible lifetime income payouts or index-based returns
- Individuals with unique health concerns who need specialized underwriting flexibility
- Financially independent buyers who want full control of investment choices and fee transparency
Other Insurance That May Be Necessary
Long-Term Care Insurance
Even with a Thrivent annuity, nursing home expenses exceeding $100,000 per year will drain your savings quickly. Consider a standalone LTC policy or a hybrid life and long-term care policy if you’re concerned about protecting retirement assets.
Disability Insurance
If you rely on your paycheck and are under 60, disability coverage is essential. Thrivent’s options are worth considering, but you must compare features like elimination period, benefit period, and definition of disability across carriers.
Fixed Indexed Annuities
Some other insurance companies offer more competitive FIA options than Thrivent, including better index selection (such as the S&P 500), higher participation rates, and stronger income riders. Consider these when building retirement income.
Immediate or Deferred Income Annuities
If your primary goal is maximizing guaranteed income now or later, compare these contracts. Thrivent may not always offer the highest payout rates, particularly for joint-life or inflation-adjusted income options.
How You Can Fund These Products
Thrivent annuities and life insurance can be funded with:
- Traditional IRAs and Roth IRAs
- 401(k) or 403(b) rollovers
- SEP or SIMPLE IRAs
- Nonqualified savings or CDs
- Inherited IRAs (spousal and non-spousal options)
The source of funds determines the taxation of withdrawals, required minimum distributions (RMDs), and estate planning strategy. Work with a licensed agent to align funding sources with the right product.
Final Verdict
Thrivent Financial is a strong, reputable, and financially secure insurance company—but that doesn’t make it the best option for every buyer. If your values and eligibility align, it may be a worthwhile choice for stable protection and income. But for consumers looking to maximize growth, flexibility, and income, it may not be the most competitive in today’s marketplace.
Want to see how Thrivent stacks up against other top-rated insurance companies and annuities?
Contact The Annuity Expert for free quotes and personalized comparisons. We’ll help you avoid costly mistakes and build a protection strategy that fits your life.
Book A Free Consultation
Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.
Let Us Answer Your Questions
Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.