Is The American Equity Immediate Annuity Any Good?

What This Annuity Is—and What It Isn’t:

The American Equity Immediate Annuity (a Single Premium Immediate Annuity, or SPIA) turns a lump sum into a series of guaranteed payments that start within 30 days to a year. The payments are based on your age, the payout option you choose, and current interest rate assumptions. Once started, you can’t change or stop them. This annuity doesn’t build cash value, doesn’t grow with markets, and isn’t meant for liquidity. It’s designed for a predictable, lifelong income.

What We Like

• Guaranteed Lifetime Income: Provides financial security with a predictable income stream that will not decrease over time, regardless of market conditions.
• Tax Benefits: For non-qualified plans, only part of the income is taxed, which can be advantageous in tax planning.
• Flexible Payment Options: Offers several payout options, including joint life coverage, ensuring that a surviving spouse can continue to receive income.

What We Don’t Like

• No Commutation Benefit: Once issued, the annuity cannot be converted into a lump sum, limiting financial flexibility.
• No Liquidity: The annuity is non-liquid, meaning funds cannot be accessed after issuance, even in emergencies.
• Little to No Interest Earned: The annuity does not offer the opportunity for significant interest growth on the funds, making it less appealing for those seeking investment growth.
• Limited Income Start Date Flexibility: Options to change the income start dates are restricted, which can be a drawback for individuals who need more flexibility in their financial planning.
• No Cash Refund Option to Beneficiaries: In the event of the annuitant’s death, the beneficiaries do not have a cash refund option, which could limit the ability to pass on unused funds to heirs.
• Taxable for Qualified Plans: For those with tax-qualified contracts, all income is subject to taxation, which can reduce the overall benefit.

Our Honest Take:

This annuity is solid if you need income now, but it lacks flexibility and growth potential. For most retirees, a Fixed Indexed Annuity (FIA) with a Guaranteed Lifetime Withdrawal Benefit (GLWB) is a smarter option. It provides lifetime income, keeps control of your principal, and can leave money to your heirs—features that a SPIA often sacrifices. The only time a SPIA truly stands out is for early retirees using non-qualified money before age 59½, where it can avoid IRS penalties.

Who Needs It and Why:

• Early Retirees (Before 59½):
  Avoids the 10% IRS early withdrawal penalty when using non-qualified funds.
• People Needing Immediate Income:
  Converts cash or a rollover into a guaranteed paycheck within months.
• Those Who Value Simplicity:
  No market tracking, no management, just predictable income.

Who Doesn’t Need It and Why:

• Anyone Wanting Liquidity:
  Once income starts, you generally can’t stop or access your funds.
• Those Wanting Growth or Inflation Protection:
  Payments are fixed and can lose purchasing power over time.
• Those Wanting a Legacy:
  Unless you select a refund or period-certain option, heirs may receive nothing.

How It Works:

You give American Equity a lump sum (from cash, a rollover, or a 1035 exchange). In return, they send you regular payments for life or for a set period. You pick a payout option, such as life-only, joint-life, or period-certain. Payments are based on your age, life expectancy, interest rates, and the guarantees you select. Once issued, the terms are locked in permanently.

Payout Options Explained:

• Life Only: Highest payout; ends at death—no refund.
• Life with Period Certain: Pays heirs if you die early; lower income.
• Joint & Survivor: Pays as long as either spouse lives; survivor benefit affects payout.
• Period-Certain Only: Pays for a fixed number of years—usually better handled with a MYGA.

Liquidity and Flexibility:

SPIAs offer little to no liquidity. You can’t pause, increase, or withdraw lump sums. Refund or commutation features, if offered, reduce your overall value. For flexibility, compare to an FIA with a GLWB rider instead.

Death Benefits:

Your payout option determines whether your heirs receive anything. “Life Only” ends at death. “Refund” or “Period Certain” options continue payments to beneficiaries. For legacy protection, pair with life insurance or use a GLWB annuity instead.

Tax Treatment:

• Non-Qualified Money: Only the gain portion is taxable until your cost basis is recovered.
• Qualified Money (IRA/401(k)): All income is taxable.
• Benefit: Converts part of your savings into a predictable income, reducing sequence-of-returns risk.

Funding Sources:

You can fund this annuity using:

• Cash or savings (non-qualified funds)
• 1035 exchange from another annuity
• Rollover/transfer from qualified accounts (IRA, Roth IRA, 401(k), 403(b), TSP, or 457(b))

Use non-qualified money if you retire before age 59½ to avoid IRS penalties.

What Happens After Purchase:

Once issued, income begins as scheduled. You no longer have access to the principal, and there’s no rate renewal. Payments continue for life (or the chosen period), then stop once all guarantees are met.

How It Compares to Other Income Options:

• Fixed Indexed Annuity (FIA) with GLWB:
  Offers lifetime income, growth potential, control, and better legacy protection.
• Deferred Income Annuity (DIA) or QLAC:
  Defers payments for higher lifetime payouts later.
• MYGA (Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuity):
  Provides guaranteed growth with annual liquidity for short-term needs.
• Variable Annuities and RILAs:
  Add market risk and higher fees—usually unnecessary for fixed income needs.

Pros:

• Guaranteed Lifetime Income: Predictable, immediate payments.
• Simplicity: No management or market risk.
• Early Retirement Loophole: Avoids IRS penalty for pre-59½ non-qualified money.

Cons:

• Inferior Flexibility: Compared to an FIA with GLWB.
• No Liquidity: Payments are typically irrevocable.
• No Growth or Inflation Protection: Payments are fixed.
• Reduced Legacy Value: Heirs may receive nothing.

Smart Money Tips:

• Compare before you commit: Always check FIA or MYGA alternatives for flexibility.
• Use life insurance: To offset lost principal if you choose a “life-only” payout.
• Shop multiple carriers: SPIA rates differ daily, and independent brokers can find higher payouts.
• Avoid buying direct: Carriers sell only their own products, while brokers compare all options.

The Bottom Line:

The American Equity Immediate Annuity is reliable for guaranteed income, but you sacrifice flexibility and future growth. Most retirees do better with a Fixed Indexed Annuity with a GLWB, which offers similar income with more control and legacy protection.

Get Free Quotes to Compare Before You Buy:

The Annuity Expert is an independent annuity agency and broker that compares multiple carriers to help you find the best income at the lowest cost.
Call 1-770-755-1565 or request free quotes today to see if this annuity fits your retirement plan.

Book A Free Consultation

Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.

Let Us Answer Your Questions

Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.

Related Reviews

• Is The Accumulation Protector PlusSM Annuity Any Good?
• Is The IncomeShield 10 Fixed Index Annuity Any Good?
• Is the Allianz 222® Annuity Any Good?
• Is Allianz Core Income 7® Annuity with Core Income Benefit Rider Any Good?
• Are North American Life Insurance And Midland National Reliable Annuity Companies?
• Is The USAA Protected Retirement Income Annuity Any Good?
• Is Nex Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuity (MYGA) by The Ohio State Life Insurance Company Any Good?
• Is NAC VersaChoice 10 Fixed Index Annuity Any Good?
• Is the AIG American Pathway Immediate Annuity Any Good?
• Is The Guardian Fixed Target Annuity Any Good?

Questions From Our Readers