Compare 1035 Exchange Options: 1035 Exchange For Annuities And Life Insurance

How to “Refinance” Your Annuity for Better Rates and Higher Income

Most people say they want to “refinance” their annuity, but what they actually mean is they want to replace an old, underperforming contract with a new one that offers better terms. That can mean a higher guaranteed interest rate, a vastly superior lifetime income payout, or modern features that didn’t exist when you bought your original policy.

Because annuities are heavily influenced by the interest rate environment at the time they are issued, an annuity bought in 2015 when rates were near zero is likely underperforming in today’s higher-rate environment.

However, you cannot just “cash out” an old annuity to buy a new one without triggering a massive tax bill. To upgrade your contract tax-free, you must execute a Section 1035 Exchange (for non-qualified money) or a Trustee-to-Trustee Transfer (for IRA money).

Here is exactly how to upgrade your annuity, beat the surrender charges, and ensure the math actually works in your favor.

Note: Did you inherit this annuity? Stop. You cannot use a standard 1035 Exchange. Go to our Non-Qualified Stretch Guide to see your options.

Real Case Study: Dale’s Annuity “Refinance”

Insurance companies do not create annuity payouts out of thin air; they are based on prevailing interest rates. Here is a real-world example of how moving from a low-rate era to a high-rate era changes the math:

• The Situation: Our client, Dale, owned a Prudential variable annuity purchased in 2015 (a historically low interest rate environment). He was ready to turn on lifetime income for himself and his wife.
• The Old Contract: Under the 2015 Prudential annuity, his joint lifetime income rider would have guaranteed $5,255 annually.
• The Replacement: By executing a tax-free transfer into a Nationwide Peak 10 fixed indexed annuity, Dale secured a guaranteed payout of $7,150 annually—starting immediately, for the rest of their lives.

That is a 36% increase in guaranteed lifetime income. It wasn’t magic, and it wasn’t a sales gimmick. It was simply the mathematical result of replacing an outdated contract with a modern design supported by a stronger economic environment.

The Math: How to Overcome Surrender Charges

The biggest fear most people have when replacing an old annuity is paying a surrender penalty to their original insurance company.

While you should never replace an annuity if the math doesn’t make sense, a modern Premium Bonus can often wipe out your old penalties on Day 1.

If your old annuity charges a 5% surrender penalty to leave, but your new Fixed Indexed Annuity (FIA) offers a 10% upfront premium bonus, the new bonus instantly absorbs the penalty and puts your account value ahead. Always have an independent fiduciary run this exact math before signing replacement paperwork.

The 4 Main Reasons to Execute a 1035 Exchange

Not every annuity should be replaced. A 1035 Exchange makes the most sense when your goals align with one of these four upgrades:

1. To Secure a Better Fixed Interest Rate (MYGA)

• The Goal: Moving from an old contract paying 2% into a Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuity (MYGA) paying 5% or more.
• Best For: Conservative savers who want a protected principal and a predictable yield, not a lifetime income.

2. To Generate Higher Lifetime Income

• The Goal: Swapping an older, weak income rider for a modern contract that produces a substantially higher monthly payout (like Dale’s example above).
• Best For: Retirees or near-retirees ready to turn their accumulated wealth into an irreversible, guaranteed paycheck.

3. To Escape a Variable Annuity

• The Goal: Moving away from high subaccount fees, market risk, and complex moving parts by exchanging into a simpler Fixed Indexed Annuity (FIA).
• Best For: Investors who no longer want to ride the stock market roller coaster and want to lock in their gains with downside protection.

4. To Upgrade Spousal or Long-Term Care Protection

• The Goal: Upgrading to a contract with enhanced joint-survivor benefits, better death benefit multipliers, or modern Long-Term Care (LTC) doublers.
• Best For: Married couples focused on legacy planning and protecting the surviving spouse from healthcare costs.

Allowed vs. Not Allowed Transfers

If you process a transfer incorrectly, the IRS will treat it as a taxable distribution. Here is what is legally allowed under a 1035 Exchange:

Partial And Split 1035 Exchanges

• Partial 1035
  • Move only a portion of your value into a new, better-fit product while keeping legacy features you still want.
• Split 1035
  • Divide value into two targets (e.g., part to a MYGA for guaranteed yield, part to a FIA + income rider for future retirement income).
  • Why it helps: you don’t have to choose a single strategy—blend income, growth, and flexibility to match your timeline.

Costs, Timing, And Paperwork (What To Expect)

• Costs you could face
  • Surrender charges and possible Market Value Adjustment (MVA) on the old annuity
  • New surrender schedule for the replacement
  • Rider fees (income/LTC/chronic-illness) on the new contract
• Timing considerations
  • Rate locks: Some fixed annuities (e.g., MYGAs) offer a rate hold; pin this down before initiating.
  • Dividend timing (WL): Exchanging rights after a policy anniversary can preserve credited values.
• Paperwork you’ll sign
  • New application, 1035 transfer form, beneficiary confirmations, suitability questionnaire, replacement disclosures

When Refinancing an Annuity is a Bad Move

Even if a new illustration looks impressive, a replacement can backfire if you are not careful. You should stay in your current contract if:

• You have valuable older riders: Some contracts issued in the early 2000s have guaranteed roll-up rates (like 7% or 8%) that do not exist today.
• The surrender charges are too high: If the penalty outpaces the premium bonus and the new growth potential, the math fails.
• You need immediate liquidity: A new annuity restarts a new surrender clock. If you need cash tomorrow, do not lock it up today.

Money-Saving Tips And “Loopholes” (All IRS-Compliant)

• Verify state guaranty association coverage and diversify carriers when large balances are involved.
• Consider a partial 1035 to keep legacy features you still value while upgrading part of your money.
• If moving to a MYGA, request a rate lock/hold from the new carrier before the old carrier releases funds.
• If surrender charges are high, consider a staged plan: partial exchange now, with the remainder after the charges drop.
• For life policies, coordinate MEC testing and loan handling before paperwork to avoid accidental taxation.
• If income is your goal, compare GLWB payouts at multiple start ages (e.g., 65 vs. 67)—small delays can materially improve lifetime income.

Get a Free 1035 Exchange Math Audit

Do not guess if replacing your annuity is worth it.

Before you make a move, let us run the numbers. Send us your current annuity statement, and our fiduciaries will run a side-by-side analysis. We will calculate your exact surrender penalty, compare your current income guarantees against the top 50 carriers in today’s market, and determine if a premium bonus will wipe out your fees.

If it makes mathematical sense to upgrade, we will handle the transfer tax-free. If your current contract is still your best option, we will tell you to stay put.

Book A Free Consultation

Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.

Let Us Answer Your Questions

Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.

Questions From Our Readers