Our Professional Opinion on the Prudential PruSecure Annuity
We consider PruSecure a good accumulation fixed indexed annuity when one of its traditional-index strategies is competitive and the selected crediting term matches how long you can leave the money untouched. It is not our first choice for guaranteed lifetime income, but the accumulation design is cleaner than many FIAs that rely heavily on engineered indexes.
Prudential is an excellent annuity company. Pruco Life Insurance Company is rated A+ by AM Best and comfortably exceeds our minimum financial-strength standard.
One of the best features is the index menu. PruSecure uses recognizable market benchmarks, including the S&P 500, MSCI EAFE, Dow Jones U.S. Real Estate Index, and Bloomberg Commodity Index. We like that the owner does not have to rely on an engineered volatility-control index to find the product’s main growth opportunities.
The contract offers cap-rate, participation-rate, and performance-trigger strategies with one-year and multi-year crediting terms. The longer index terms can reduce annual renewal-rate risk because the initial cap or participation rate applies for the selected term.
That term lock comes with a major tradeoff. The index strategy generally must be held through its full term without withdrawals to receive the calculated index credit. A three- or five-year strategy can leave the owner waiting several years for interest to be measured and credited.
We generally prefer the one-year S&P 500 annual point-to-point strategy unless a longer-term option offers a meaningfully better guaranteed cap or participation rate and the owner is comfortable leaving the allocation untouched. The five-year index term is only available at issue and cannot be renewed.
PruSecure does not eliminate renewal-rate risk. Caps, participation rates, performance-trigger rates, and the fixed-account rate can change when a new term begins. The contractual minimums are low enough that they should not be treated as meaningful growth guarantees.
The fixed-rate strategy renews annually and can change each year. Someone who wants a guaranteed fixed return for the entire surrender period should also compare a MYGA or a product that contractually locks the accumulation terms. See how cap-lock annuities and MYGAs reduce renewal-rate risk.
Liquidity is limited during the first year. Other than an eligible required minimum distribution, normal penalty-free withdrawals do not begin until after the first contract anniversary. After that, the owner can generally withdraw a portion of the account value annually without surrender charges or a Market Value Adjustment.
Withdrawals above the free amount can be reduced by surrender charges and an MVA during the selected five- or seven-year surrender period. PruSecure does not charge an annual contract or administrative fee, but the absence of an explicit fee does not make an uncompetitive cap or participation rate acceptable.
PruSecure is primarily an accumulation product. Someone whose main objective is lifetime income should compare FIAs designed around competitive guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefits. Someone concerned about future care expenses should evaluate long-term care insurance or a hybrid solution separately.
Bottom line: PruSecure is a good FIA for safe accumulation when the traditional-index terms are competitive. We like the transparent index choices and the ability to lock a cap or participation rate for a selected multi-year term. We do not like the delayed crediting on longer terms, first-year liquidity restriction, MVA, or the insurer’s ability to lower future renewal terms.
What We Like
- A+ AM Best Rating: Pruco Life is a financially strong issuing company.
- Traditional Index Choices: The contract uses recognizable equity, international, real estate, and commodity benchmarks.
- No Dependence on Engineered Indexes: The primary strategies do not require trusting a manufactured volatility-control index with a limited live history.
- Multiple Crediting Methods: Cap-rate, participation-rate, and performance-trigger choices provide several ways to earn interest.
- Multi-Year Term Locks: The initial cap or participation rate applies throughout the selected index term.
- Principal Protection From Market Losses: Negative index performance does not directly reduce the protected annuity value when the contract rules are followed.
- Annual Liquidity After Year One: A portion of the account value can generally be withdrawn without normal surrender charges or an MVA.
- No Annual Contract or Administrative Fee: The base design does not impose a separate annual product charge.
- Legacy Protection: Beneficiaries may receive the account value and applicable index growth under the contract’s death-benefit provisions.
What We Don’t Like
- Longer Crediting Terms Delay Interest: A three- or five-year index term can require waiting years before the strategy’s interest is calculated and credited.
- Withdrawals Can Eliminate Index Credit: An allocation generally must remain in the strategy through the full term to receive the expected credit.
- The Five-Year Term Cannot Be Renewed: It is available only when the contract is issued.
- Renewal Terms Can Drop: Future caps, participation rates, trigger rates, and fixed rates may be lower than the initial terms.
- Low Contractual Minimums: The guaranteed minimum renewal terms are not strong enough to create meaningful long-term growth expectations.
- No Normal First-Year Liquidity: Standard penalty-free access begins after the first contract anniversary, apart from qualifying RMD treatment.
- Market Value Adjustment: Excess withdrawals during the surrender period can be increased or reduced by changes in market interest rates.
- Five- or Seven-Year Surrender Commitment: The owner may need to renew or reallocate index strategies before the surrender period ends.
- Not Our First Choice for Lifetime Income: The product is designed more for accumulation than for a top-of-market GLWB payout.
Overview
The PruSecure Fixed Indexed Annuity is a deferred fixed indexed annuity (FIA) issued by Prudential, founded in 1875 and headquartered in Newark, New Jersey. The carrier holds strong financial ratings (A+ AM Best, AA- S&P, A1 Moody’s) and a solid Comdex score. This product is designed for principal protection with the opportunity to earn interest based on the performance of a market index, while deferring taxes until funds are withdrawn. You can fund the annuity with IRA, Roth IRA, SEP IRA, SIMPLE IRA, 401(k), 403(b), and non-qualified funds.
How It Works
The PruSecure FIA allows you to allocate your premium to one or more index strategies or a 1-Year Fixed Account. Index crediting strategies include the S&P 500 (a traditional index), Dow Jones U.S. Real Estate, Bloomberg Commodity Index, and MSCI EAFE. However, many of these are engineered variations and may not have more than 10 years of performance history, which makes long-term performance assumptions unreliable. We prefer traditional indexes with transparent data and a verifiable ticker symbol.
The crediting options include:
- Annual Point-to-Point with Cap
- Point-to-Point with Participation Rate
- Multi-Year Point-to-Point
All strategies are reset at the end of each term. This gives you a new opportunity to “swing at the next pitch” annually or every few years, depending on the term selected.
Compare Income From The PruSecure With 25+ Other Companies
Who Should Consider It
- Conservative investors looking to preserve principal while earning better potential than CDs or fixed annuities.
- Pre-retirees or retirees who want growth without market loss.
- Clients funding with IRAs or rollovers from 401(k)s who want tax-deferred growth and are okay without income riders.
- Legacy-minded investors who want their account value to avoid probate.
Who Should Avoid It
- Anyone needing lifetime income: This product does not offer a GLWB. You’d need to annuitize, which is not reversible and strips control from your money.
- Growth-focused investors: Participation in index gains is capped or limited, with no dividends, and upside potential is lower than direct equity investments.
- People unwilling to commit to long surrender schedules: You’re locked in for up to 10 years and may pay surrender charges and MVAs for early access.
- Those seeking engineered indexes with no track record: These indexes often reset parameters annually, reducing transparency and making them hard to evaluate.
Other Insurance That Can Help
- Fixed Indexed Annuity with a GLWB: This allows guaranteed lifetime income without annuitizing and keeps control in your hands. It also lets you pass the remaining value to your heirs.
- Life Insurance: A permanent life insurance policy can recover funds lost through annuitization or cover taxes upon death.
- Long-Term Care Insurance: Avoid annuities that drain your account to fund LTC benefits. A separate LTC annuity or insurance policy protects more of your income and estate.
Funding Types Accepted
This annuity can be funded using:
- Traditional IRA
- Roth IRA
- SEP IRA
- SIMPLE IRA
- 401(k) rollover
- 403(b) rollover
- Non-qualified funds
Bottom Line
The PruSecure Fixed Indexed Annuity may be appropriate for conservative investors who want principal protection and modest growth without income needs. However, if you need guaranteed lifetime income, inflation protection, or traditional index exposure, there are better FIA options available—particularly those with GLWB income riders. By choosing PruSecure, you give up the option for guaranteed lifetime income with growth and flexibility.
Get Expert Help
Contact The Annuity Expert today for free quotes and a personalized comparison of fixed indexed annuities that do include GLWB income riders, better index options, or premium bonuses. Let us be your advocate—not the insurance company’s.
Book A Free Consultation
Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.
Let Us Answer Your Questions
Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.