Our Professional Opinion on the Atlantic Coast Life Safe Haven MYGA
We would not touch the Atlantic Coast Life Safe Haven MYGA with a 10-foot pole, regardless of the term or advertised rate.
Safe Haven offers several guarantee periods and may advertise rates that look better than competing MYGAs. None of that matters enough to overcome Atlantic Coast Life’s current financial condition and rating situation.
Our normal rule allows us to consider a B++ insurer for a MYGA term under five years when the guaranteed rate is meaningfully higher than what an A- or better-rated company offers. Atlantic Coast Life is C+ Rated and remains under review with negative implications, and is involved in a rehabilitation proceeding.
We would not make an exception because the contract is short-term, the premium is below a state guaranty association limit, or the rate is substantially higher. State guaranty associations are an important safety net, but they are not a reason to intentionally purchase a new annuity from a company with this level of financial and regulatory uncertainty.
A higher MYGA rate is supposed to compensate you for committing your money—not for accepting an avoidable risk that the issuing company could enter rehabilitation or insolvency. If that occurs, the eventual contract benefits may be protected within state limits, but access to the money and the resolution of the contract could take time.
Existing owners should not automatically surrender or replace a Safe Haven contract. That decision requires reviewing the current cash surrender value, surrender charges, Market Value Adjustment, tax consequences, maturity date, and available replacement rates. Our refusal to recommend a new purchase does not mean every existing owner should make a rushed exit.
Compare Safe Haven with current fixed annuity rates from A- or better-rated insurers.
Overview
The Safe Haven Bonus Guarantee annuity from Atlantic Coast Life Insurance Company is a multi-year guaranteed annuity (MYGA) designed for conservative savers seeking tax-deferred accumulation, principal protection, and interest rate guarantees. This annuity offers flexible term lengths —3, 5, 6, 7, 10, or 20 years—and the option to customize liquidity and death benefit features through add-on riders.
It includes a first-year interest bonus on most terms to enhance early growth and offers penalty-free withdrawal options (with optional riders). However, it lacks a guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit (GLWB), relies solely on annuitization for income, and the issuing carrier, Atlantic Coast Life, is rated C+ (Marginal) by AM Best, following a recent downgrade, which is below the A-level benchmark we recommend for long-term contracts.
WARNING: Do not buy this annuity or any of the company’s annuities. In our professional opinion, Atlantic Coast Life is a sinking ship.
Product Type and Structure
- Annuity Type: MYGA (Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuity)
- Issuer: Atlantic Coast Life Insurance Company
- Available Terms: 3, 5, 6, 7, 10, and 20 years
- Minimum Premium: $5,000
- Maximum Premium: $1,000,000
- Funding Types: Qualified and non-qualified money
Key Features
- Guaranteed Interest: Fixed rate locked in for the entire term; includes year-one interest bonus on select terms
- Tax Deferral: No taxes on growth until you make a withdrawal
- Surrender Charge Waivers: Optional riders waive charges for 10% free withdrawals, interest-only withdrawals, and death benefit payments
- Flexible Term Lengths: Choose from 6 term options tailored to your financial horizon
- 30-Day Renewal Window: Switch, renew, or withdraw at the end of the term without penalties
- Probate Avoidance: Contract passes directly to beneficiaries if structured properly
- Annuitization Option: Income available through conversion to a 3–20 year income stream (not lifetime guaranteed without annuitization)
- MVA (Market Value Adjustment) applies during the surrender period. After each term ends, there’s a 30-day window during which you can exit without incurring charges or MVA.
What Happens After the Term Ends?
When your contract matures, you enter a 30-day renewal window. During that time, you may:
- Withdraw all or part of your funds without any penalties or MVA
- Renew the contract for another guarantee period with new rates
- Annuitize the contract into income for up to 20 years (no GLWB available)
If no action is taken, your contract may automatically renew, resetting the surrender charges. It’s essential to review options during this period to avoid being locked into another term.
Optional Riders
- Preferred 10% Free Withdrawal Rider – Waives surrender charges and MVA for one withdrawal annually up to 10% or RMD.
- Accumulated Interest Withdrawal Rider – Allows periodic withdrawals of interest earned without penalties.
- Death Benefit Rider – Required for ages 86–90 or 70–75 (20-year term) to ensure full account value is passed to beneficiaries without surrender charges or MVA.
Note: Once selected, riders cannot be removed during the guarantee period.
Death Benefit Options
If the optional rider is not selected:
- Death benefit = Cash Surrender Value (lump sum)
- Or, Account Value over 5 years in equal annual payments
If the spouse is the sole beneficiary, they may continue the contract without incurring any penalties.
Pros and Cons
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Multiple term options (3–20 years) | Carrier is rated C+ (Marginal), below our A- minimum recommendation |
| First-year interest bonus increases early growth | No guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit (GLWB) |
| Optional liquidity and death benefit riders | No inflation protection |
| Surrender schedule is steep in the early years | The surrender schedule is steep in the early years |
| 30-day renewal window after each term | Income only available through annuitization (less flexible) |
Why Comparing Annuities Matters
While Safe Haven offers multiple terms and customizable riders, it lacks an income rider, has a relatively weak AM Best rating (B), and is less flexible for retirees who need a guaranteed lifetime income. Other A-rated MYGAs or fixed indexed annuities may offer:
- Better rates or shorter surrender schedules
- Built-in or optional income riders (GLWBs)
- More favorable death benefit provisions
Comparing across top-rated insurers ensures you don’t sacrifice growth, income, or security.
What We Recommend Instead of Atlantic Coast Life Safe Haven
We recommend avoiding every new Atlantic Coast Life Safe Haven purchase at this time and using an A- or better-rated MYGA instead. Contact The Annuity Expert for free quotes and a no-obligation comparison of current fixed annuity rates, insurer ratings, surrender terms, liquidity, and death benefits. Existing Safe Haven owners can also contact us for a contract-specific second opinion before surrendering or transferring the annuity.
Book A Free Consultation
Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.
Let Us Answer Your Questions
Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.