Our Professional Opinion on the Northwestern Mutual Fixed Annuity
We would not purchase a Northwestern Mutual fixed annuity without first comparing it with MYGAs from the broader A- or better-rated market. Northwestern Mutual is an exceptionally strong insurance company with an A++ AM Best rating, so financial strength is not the concern.
The concern is the distribution model. Northwestern Mutual annuities are sold through Northwestern Mutual representatives rather than independent annuity brokers. That means the person presenting the annuity is showing you Northwestern Mutual’s product—not independently comparing fixed annuities from dozens of competing insurers.
A strong company does not automatically mean the strongest MYGA rate. Northwestern Mutual may offer a perfectly good fixed annuity, but we would not accept a lower guaranteed return merely because the company has an excellent name and financial-strength rating.
Before purchasing, ask for the exact guaranteed term, annual effective rate, guaranteed maturity value, surrender schedule, penalty-free withdrawal provisions, Market Value Adjustment rules, death benefit, renewal provisions, and any premium-band requirements. Those details need to be compared with the entire market using the same premium and contract term.
We are currently in a high-interest-rate environment, so locking a competitive rate for several years can be a good idea when you do not need the money. The key word is competitive. A longer lock is only valuable when Northwestern Mutual’s guaranteed return compares favorably with other financially strong insurers.
Bottom line: Northwestern Mutual’s financial strength is excellent, but its captive distribution model creates a comparison problem. We would only use the fixed annuity after confirming that its guaranteed return and contract features are competitive with independent MYGA options.
Compare Northwestern Mutual with the current fixed annuity rates before committing your money.
What We Like
- A++ AM Best Rating: Northwestern Mutual has one of the strongest financial-strength ratings available.
- Strong Company Reputation: The insurer has substantial financial resources and a long operating history.
- Guaranteed Fixed Growth: A fixed annuity can provide predictable interest without stock-market losses when held according to the contract.
- Potential Planning Integration: Existing Northwestern Mutual clients may value having the annuity coordinated with their other company products and planning relationship.
What We Don’t Like
- Captive Distribution: The Northwestern Mutual representative is selling Northwestern Mutual’s annuity rather than independently shopping the full annuity market.
- Limited Market Transparency: Consumers may have difficulty comparing current contract terms and rates without going through the company’s sales process.
- Company Strength Can Distract From the Rate: An A++ rating does not justify accepting a materially lower guaranteed return.
- Independent Comparison Is Still Necessary: The annuity should be compared with A-, A, and A+ insurers using the same premium and term.
Product Overview
The Select™ Fixed Annuity is tailored for prudent investors who prioritize stability and guaranteed returns in their retirement portfolio. Northwestern Mutual designed this product as a dual-purpose financial tool, serving both as a retirement accumulation vehicle and a source of retirement income.
Guaranteed Safety of Principal
One of the key features of the Select™ Fixed Annuity is the guaranteed safety of your principal. This means that no matter how the market performs, your initial investment is protected, and the value will never fall below what you originally put in.
Guaranteed Interest Rate Options
The annuity offers a choice of guaranteed interest rate periods—one, three, or five years. These options allow you to lock in a predictable growth rate for your investment, ensuring a stable and consistent return over time.
Optional First-Year Rate Enhancement
If you have a minimum investment of $50,000, you can opt for a first-year rate enhancement, giving you a higher interest rate during the first year of your contract. This feature can provide an early boost to your earnings, further accelerating your wealth accumulation.
Tax-Deferred Earnings Growth
The Select™ Fixed Annuity allows your earnings to grow tax-deferred, meaning you won’t pay taxes until you withdraw the funds. This tax deferral can significantly enhance your wealth accumulation, particularly over long periods.
Portfolio Diversification and Flexibility
As a low-risk option, this annuity is ideal for diversifying your retirement portfolio, especially as you near retirement. Additionally, the product offers various income options, including the ability to structure your income in a way that suits your specific needs.
Access to Funds and Additional Benefits
While early withdrawal charges usually apply, there are circumstances where these fees are waived. For instance, you can withdraw interest earned in the last year or access funds in cases of terminal illness or nursing home care without incurring penalties. Furthermore, the product includes a guaranteed death benefit, ensuring that your loved ones can access the full account balance without penalties if you pass away before the income phase.
Final Thoughts
The Select™ Fixed Annuity from Northwestern Mutual is a robust option for those approaching retirement who value stability and security. While the product offers numerous benefits, including guaranteed safety of the principal, tax-deferred growth, and flexible income options, it’s essential to consider the potential drawbacks. High initial investment requirements, withdrawal penalties, and potentially lower interest rates compared to other products should be carefully weighed. Overall, this annuity is best suited for conservative investors who prioritize predictability and long-term financial security.
What We Recommend
We recommend getting an independent MYGA comparison before purchasing a Northwestern Mutual fixed annuity. Contact The Annuity Expert for free quotes and a no-obligation comparison of guaranteed rates, maturity values, liquidity, surrender provisions, and insurer ratings across the broader market.
Book A Free Consultation
Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.
Let Us Answer Your Questions
Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.
Related Reviews
- Is Athene Ascent Pro 10 Any Good?
- American Equity Annuity Reviews
- Are Fidelity Annuities Any Good?
- Is The IncomeShield 10 Fixed Index Annuity Any Good?
- Is the Allianz 222® Annuity Any Good?
- Transamerica Annuity Review
- Is The Accumulation Protector PlusSM Annuity Any Good?
- Is Allianz Core Income 7® Annuity with Core Income Benefit Rider Any Good?
- Is The Guardian SecureFuture Income AnnuitySM Any Good?
- Are North American Life Insurance And Midland National Reliable Annuity Companies?
- Is The USAA Protected Retirement Income Annuity Any Good?
- Is Nex Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuity (MYGA) by The Ohio State Life Insurance Company Any Good?
- Is NAC VersaChoice 10 Fixed Index Annuity Any Good?
- Is The Guardian Fixed Target Annuity Any Good?