Our Professional Opinion on the Penn Mutual Guaranteed Foundation Fixed Annuity
Guaranteed Foundation’s biggest weakness is the first-year withdrawal restriction. If you might need your money soon, we would choose a MYGA with first-year access or keep that money outside an annuity. Having to pay a surrender charge to access an emergency fund stinks.
We like the choice of guarantee periods from three through ten years. A longer guarantee can be worthwhile when the rate is competitive, and the timeline fits your plan; the shortest term is not automatically the best one. But the contract generally renews automatically if you do not make an election, so you must pay attention before the guarantee ends.
Penn Mutual is a great insurance company. The Penn Mutual Life Insurance Company has an A+ (Superior) AM Best financial-strength rating, comfortably above our A− minimum. We are comfortable with the company, but the rate and access rules still have to earn your business.
Compare the offered rate with other fixed annuity rates from insurers rated A− or higher. Match the guarantee period, deposit, and withdrawal rules. We would not accept a weaker rate or first-year access restriction just because Penn Mutual is a familiar name.
What We Like
- A wide choice of guarantees: Initial periods range from three through ten years.
- A predictable rate: Your initial interest rate is guaranteed for the period you select.
- A strong insurer: Penn Mutual exceeds our financial-strength standard.
- A renewal decision window: You can generally withdraw without surrender charges during the 30 days before the guarantee ends, subject to state rules.
What We Don’t Like
- No ordinary first-year free withdrawal: This is not the place for money you may need right away.
- Automatic renewal: If you ignore the renewal notice, the contract can enter another guarantee period.
- Early surrender charges: Withdrawing too much before the period ends can reduce what you receive.
- Interest withdrawals are not lifetime income: The renewal rate can change and the payments are not guaranteed for life.
Guaranteed Foundation Fixed Annuity Overview
Guaranteed Foundation is a multi-year guaranteed annuity. You make one deposit, select a guarantee period, and receive the stated fixed interest rate for that period. The minimum deposit is $10,000; additional deposits are not accepted after issue.
Initial guarantees are available for three, four, five, six, seven, eight, nine, or ten years. The surrender-charge period matches the guarantee period. The offered rate can depend on the term and deposit amount, so use your own quote rather than assuming you qualify for an advertised rate.
Key Features
| Feature | What to know |
|---|---|
| Initial guarantees | Three through ten years. |
| Minimum deposit | $10,000, with no additional deposits after issue. |
| First-year withdrawals | No ordinary free-withdrawal allowance. |
| Later withdrawals | Generally up to 10% of contract value annually without surrender charges. |
| Surrender period | Matches the selected guarantee period. |
| Renewal | Generally automatic unless you make an election; state rules apply. |
Withdrawals and Liquidity
There is no ordinary annual free-withdrawal allowance in the first contract year. Beginning in year two, you can generally withdraw up to 10% of the contract value annually without a surrender charge. Taking more can trigger a charge on the amount above the free allowance.
A qualifying medical or disability event may permit additional access, subject to the contract’s waiver rules. That can help in a crisis, but it does not make the annuity a replacement for an emergency fund.
If you plan to live on the interest: Compare this MYGA with an annuity offering a guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit. Use the same deposit, income start date, and single- or joint-life coverage. Fixed interest withdrawals are not guaranteed to continue at the same amount for life.
If you want withdrawals without lifetime income: Compare an annuity with a real upfront account bonus. The larger starting balance may produce more interest dollars and leave more to compound even at a lower rate. Compare the same withdrawals, dates, fees, and surrender values.
If your health is poor or you expect a shorter retirement: Compare a bonus that fully vests and is payable on a qualifying death. Look at what your beneficiaries would actually receive after withdrawals and any restrictions. Guaranteed Foundation pays its applicable death benefit, but it does not pay future unearned interest in advance.
Surrender Charges
A surrender charge can apply to amounts withdrawn above the available allowance during the guarantee period. Early charges can be as high as 8%, and the schedule generally declines over the term. Ask for the schedule for your selected guarantee period and state.
For example, a ten-year guarantee can lock in a competitive rate for a decade, but it can also make a large early withdrawal costly. Match the term to when you may need the principal rather than choosing the longest rate lock automatically.
What Happens When the Guarantee Ends?
During the 30 days before the guarantee period ends, you generally can take a full or partial withdrawal without a surrender charge. You may also select an available renewal term, including a one-year option, or choose another available payout. State rules can differ.
If you make no election, the contract generally renews for the same number of years when available, at the rate then offered. A renewal can have its own surrender terms. Mark the decision date, request the renewal rate, and compare alternatives before allowing another commitment to begin.
For Florida owners who were age 65 or older at issue, the one-year fixed account is the only renewal choice. Check the renewal provisions that apply to your policy.
Death Benefit and Spousal Continuation
If you die before annuity payments begin, the remaining contract value is generally paid to your beneficiaries under the policy terms. Any withdrawals you take during your lifetime reduce the money left for them.
An eligible spouse named as beneficiary may be able to choose spousal continuation rather than receiving the proceeds immediately. Verify eligibility and beneficiary designations before assuming the spouse can continue the contract.
Our Final Verdict
Guaranteed Foundation has an unusually broad range of terms, but its first-year liquidity restriction is a dealbreaker for money you may need soon. We would consider it only when Penn Mutual’s rate is competitive for the term and you have adequate cash elsewhere. Put the renewal window on your calendar before you buy.
Contact The Annuity Expert for free quotes. We can compare Penn Mutual with other highly rated companies for your deposit, timeline, and access needs.
Book A Free Consultation
Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.
Let Us Answer Your Questions
Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.