Our Professional Opinion on the Prudential WealthGuard Annuity
We would consider WealthGuard when its guaranteed rate is competitive, but we would not pay a substantial rate penalty just to buy the Prudential name. The first-year withdrawal allowance and the ability to leave after the original term without starting a new surrender period are features we like. The rate still needs to earn its place against other financially strong insurers.
Prudential is a great insurance company. WealthGuard is issued by Pruco Life Insurance Company, which holds an A+ (Superior) AM Best rating—above our A− minimum. We like the issuer; our recommendation depends on the rate, term, and access rules offered to you.
The drawback is the early exit: taking too much can trigger both surrender charges and a market value adjustment. Compare fixed annuity rates for the same three-, five-, or seven-year term, deposit, withdrawal allowance, and MVA. If a competitive longer guarantee fits your plans, we would not reject it simply because a shorter term is available.
What We Like
- First-year access: You can withdraw up to the allowance without waiting a year.
- No new lockup at renewal: After the initial term, interest is declared yearly without restarting surrender charges or an MVA.
- Three initial terms: Choose a three-, five-, or seven-year guarantee based on when you need the money.
- No annual contract fee: There is no annual administrative or contract fee in the base design.
- A strong issuer: Pruco Life’s A+ AM Best rating exceeds our minimum.
What We Don’t Like
- An MVA on early access: An adjustment can reduce what you receive above the free allowance, on top of a surrender charge.
- The original rate ends: After the selected term, the annual renewal rate may be lower.
- A $25,000 minimum: This is not a practical home for every small deposit.
- Interest is not lifetime income: Spending the interest does not lock in a paycheck for life.
Prudential WealthGuard Annuity Overview
WealthGuard is a single-premium fixed annuity, also called a multi-year guaranteed annuity (MYGA). You make one deposit, generally at least $25,000, and select a three-, five-, or seven-year initial rate guarantee. Additional deposits are not accepted; availability varies by state and financial firm.
Key Features
- Guarantee: A fixed interest rate for the selected initial term.
- First-year access: Up to 10% of the purchase payment without surrender charges or an MVA.
- Later annual access: Generally 10% of the prior anniversary’s account value.
- Early withdrawal: Surrender charges and an MVA may apply to the excess.
- Renewal: One-year rates are declared after the initial period, without a new surrender period.
- Death benefit: Generally the greater of account value or minimum guaranteed surrender value.
- Medical and RMD provisions: Qualifying waivers or Prudential-calculated RMDs may provide additional charge-free access.
Withdrawals and Your Income
In the first year, the penalty-free withdrawal is up to 10% of your purchase payment. After the first anniversary, it is generally based on 10% of your account value at the prior anniversary. Amounts over the allowance can trigger charges during the initial term.
If you plan to live on the interest: Compare it with a guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit using the same deposit, income start date, and single or joint coverage. WealthGuard’s interest payments do not guarantee a lifetime paycheck.
If you need withdrawals but not lifetime income: Compare an annuity with an upfront premium bonus credited to the account. A bigger starting balance might leave more to compound after the same withdrawals, even with a lower credited rate. Include fees and bonus recapture in the comparison.
If your health is poor or you expect a shorter retirement: Compare the actual death benefit with a bonus annuity whose bonus fully vests and is payable at death. WealthGuard pays its applicable death benefit, but interest you have not yet earned is not paid in advance.
Surrender Charges and the Market Value Adjustment
surrender charges apply to amounts withdrawn above the free allowance during the original guarantee period. The following schedule applies to the standard terms; check your contract and state.
| Contract year | 3-year term | 5-year term | 7-year term |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 7% | 7% | 7% |
| 2 | 7% | 7% | 7% |
| 3 | 7% | 7% | 7% |
| 4 | — | 6% | 6% |
| 5 | — | 5% | 5% |
| 6 | — | — | 4% |
| 7 | — | — | 3% |
A market value adjustment can also increase or decrease an early withdrawal above the allowance. Generally, rising rates can produce a negative adjustment and falling rates can produce a positive one. A negative adjustment on top of the charge can leave you with less than you deposited. Review the account value and surrender value before requesting a full surrender.
What Happens When the Guarantee Ends?
After the initial term, WealthGuard moves to a one-year guarantee and Prudential declares the new rate, subject to the contract’s minimum. The original rate does not continue automatically. You can reassess your options at that point, and the annual renewal does not begin a new surrender-charge or MVA period.
We like this design because you are not forced into another multiyear commitment by missing a renewal window. Still, check the new rate against alternatives. A strong company does not make an uncompetitive renewal rate a good deal.
Medical Waivers and Required Minimum Distributions
The medical waiver can remove surrender charges and the MVA for a qualifying terminal illness or a medical-facility confinement of 90 consecutive days, subject to eligibility and state rules. If an entity owns the contract, the annuitant’s condition applies. Do not use this limited waiver as a replacement for emergency savings or long-term care insurance.
Required minimum distributions calculated by Prudential and attributable to this contract can also be free of surrender charges and the MVA. Confirm the calculation before requesting the withdrawal, particularly when the contract is held as an IRA annuity.
Death Benefit and Spousal Continuation
The death benefit before annuity payments begin is generally the greater of the account value or minimum guaranteed surrender value. Withdrawals reduce what remains. The minimum is calculated under the contract’s formula; it is not necessarily a full return of the original deposit on an early surrender.
If your spouse is your beneficiary, ask whether spousal continuation is available for your contract and what ownership and beneficiary rules apply.
Our Final Verdict on WealthGuard
WealthGuard has two features we value: first-year free access and annual renewal without a new surrender period. We would consider it when the guaranteed rate is competitive for the term you need. If its rate is weak or you expect to need more than the allowance early, we would compare other contracts rather than buy it for the Prudential name.
Contact The Annuity Expert for free annuity quotes. We can compare WealthGuard with other fixed and income annuities using your deposit and timeline.
Book A Free Consultation
Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.
Let Us Answer Your Questions
Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.