Why Tapping a Small Inheritance Might Make More Sense Than You Think
Scenario:
You inherited two small Flexible Premium Deferred Annuities (FPDAs) worth about $3,500 each after the passing of your parents. They contributed only small amounts over the years. There’s no life insurance, no significant assets, and you’ve taken on debt due to their care. You’re considering whether to cash these out to pay down that debt or let them sit and grow.
1. Cash Out the Annuity Now to Reduce Debt
Strategy Summary: Liquidate the annuities and apply the funds toward existing debt to reduce interest costs and free up cash flow.
Key Stat: You have access to ~$7,000 total from both accounts.
How It Works:
- As the beneficiary, you can take a lump-sum death benefit.
- There’s no early withdrawal penalty since your parents passed away, but you will owe income tax on any gains.
- If your mom only made small contributions and these annuities didn’t grow significantly, the taxable portion may be minimal.
Pros:
- ✔ Immediate help with debt and interest costs
- ✔ Clears out small, low-growth accounts
- ✔ Simplifies financial housekeeping
Cons:
- ✘ Income tax on the gains in the year you cash out
- ✘ Eliminates any potential future growth (though likely minimal)
Who Needs It:
- Someone with high-interest debt and limited cash flow
- Someone who prefers simplification over long-term tax-deferred accumulation on small accounts
Who Doesn’t:
- Someone with no debt, stable income, and interest in compounding even small amounts tax-deferred
- Someone already in a high tax bracket who wants to delay additional income
Also Consider: If you’re in a low tax bracket this year due to caregiving, cashing them out now may come at a very low tax cost.
2. Transfer the Annuity to a Beneficiary IRA Annuity
Strategy Summary: Move the funds into a nonqualified inherited annuity and stretch out taxable distributions over 5 years.
Key Stat: Inherited annuity rules generally require full withdrawal within 5 years if not a spouse.
How It Works:
- Rather than cashing out immediately, you can transfer the funds into a new annuity contract in your name as the beneficiary.
- You’d still owe taxes as you withdraw over time, but you could spread out the tax impact over 5 years.
Pros:
- ✔ Reduces immediate tax hit
- ✔ Maintains tax deferral
- ✔ Optional: Pick an annuity that guarantees a fixed return or offers death benefits to your heirs
Cons:
- ✘ Complex paperwork for such small balances
- ✘ May have limited product availability due to low dollar amount
- ✘ You’re still paying debt interest while these sit
Who Needs It:
- Someone in a high-income year who wants to spread taxes out
- Someone already financially stable with no pressing debt
Who Doesn’t:
- Anyone dealing with credit card or personal loan debt
- Someone who would rather consolidate and simplify finances
Helpful Tip: Most annuity carriers require minimum premiums of $5,000 or $10,000 for new contracts. So this may not even be an option without combining the funds.
3. 1035 Exchange to a Short-Term MYGA or Fixed Annuity
Strategy Summary: Move the funds into a Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuity to earn guaranteed interest for 2–3 years before cashing out.
Key Stat: MYGAs currently offer 5–6% annual returns, which is better than most banks.
How It Works:
- If you don’t need the money this year, you could do a tax-free 1035 exchange to a MYGA, earn a fixed return, and access it when the term ends.
- After that, use it to pay off whatever’s left of your debt.
Pros:
- ✔ Higher return than letting it sit in a savings account
- ✔ Delays tax until the end of the MYGA term
- ✔ More value when you do cash out
Cons:
- ✘ Might not qualify due to low balance (some carriers have $5,000+ minimums)
- ✘ Delays debt payoff
Who Needs It:
- Someone with low-interest debt or no rush to repay
- Someone with room in their budget to wait 2–3 years for a better payout
Who Doesn’t:
- Someone facing high-interest credit card debt
- Someone who needs to clean up financial stress now
Also Consider: Ask The Annuity Expert to compare low-minimum MYGAs—some carriers allow contracts as low as $2,500.
Additional Protection Options
- Life Insurance: Your parents didn’t have any. That’s why you’re left with a financial mess. You can avoid repeating this by purchasing final expense or term life insurance for yourself, so your own heirs aren’t left scrambling.
- Disability Insurance: If debt is already a concern, a sudden loss of income due to illness could make things worse. A small policy can protect your income and help you avoid taking on more debt.
- Annuities for Yourself: Down the road, a Guaranteed Lifetime Withdrawal Benefit (GLWB) annuity could secure guaranteed income for life and protect your family from going through this again.
Final Takeaway
These accounts were never built for long-term wealth—they were small gift-based annuities that have run their course. At just $3,500 each, there’s little benefit to holding them long-term. The simplest and most helpful route is to cash them out now, pay any minimal taxes, and knock down your debt. That gives you breathing room and lets you put future dollars toward saving, not interest.
Next Step:
Contact The Annuity Expert for a free quote or consultation to:
- Compare fixed annuity or MYGA options (if you want to grow the money a little longer)
- Review your own financial plan and see how annuities or insurance could simplify your legacy
- Ask how to structure your finances so your loved ones won’t face what you’ve just gone through
👉 Book a call with our agents for free quotes and no-obligation advice.
Book A Free Consultation
Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.
Let Us Answer Your Questions
Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.