Irresponsible Advice That Harms Retirees
Clark Howard, a popular consumer advocate, is not a licensed financial advisor and has zero retirement financial planning experience in both the field and academia. Despite his widespread influence, his recommendations for SPIAs and QLACs may not be the best option for retirees. Taking financial advice from someone without professional experience is dangerous and can lead to costly and irreversible retirement mistakes.
Giving financial advice without real-world experience is reckless because Clark Howard actively influences his audience to make irreversible financial decisions while earning commissions from third-party advertisers. You would think a consumer advocate would prioritize keeping consumers in control of their own money, yet Clark recommends retirees hand over their nest egg to an insurance company and permanently lose access to their funds. This isn’t hundreds of dollars. This is hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of dollars put at risk. I was shocked to read this, and it is hard evidence he should “stay in his lane”.
If he had real financial experience, he would know that Guaranteed Lifetime Withdrawal Benefits (GLWBs) correct all the problems of SPIAs by:
- Providing higher income in most cases compared to SPIAs.
- Allowing retirees to maintain control of their assets.
- Ensuring that any remaining balance passes to beneficiaries—something life-only SPIAs do not.
Instead, Clark is pushing retirees to give away their money, lock themselves into a rigid income stream, and screw over their heirs. This is the opposite of consumer advocacy.
Annuities are not for everyone—and that’s perfectly fine—but SPIAs are not the right choice for most retirees, and QLACs are only useful for wealthy individuals. The problem is, you wouldn’t know that from Clark’s advice—because he has ZERO professional financial experience.
The Downsides of SPIAs and QLACs
Cons of Single Premium Immediate Annuities (SPIAs)
- Irrevocable Decision: Once purchased, you lose access to your lump sum. Sorry, it’s gone bye-bye.
- Fixed Income, No Growth: SPIA payments do not increase unless you start with a much lower payment and you miss potential market gains, earning barely 1% in interest in normal interest rate environments.
- Inflation Risk: Without an inflation rider, purchasing power declines over time. SPIA COLA riders suck in general.
- No Legacy Benefits: If you die early, the insurance company keeps the remaining balance unless you pay extra for a period-certain rider.
- No Liquidity: Unexpected expenses cannot be covered with this annuity.
- Low Payouts in a Low-Rate Environment: If purchased when interest rates are low, your lifetime income will also be low.
Cons of Qualified Longevity Annuity Contracts (QLACs)
- Delayed Income Access: Payouts begin at 75+, making them useless for early retirees.
- Contribution Limits: The IRS caps contributions at $210,000 (2026), restricting potential income.
- No Investment Growth: Your money does not accumulate beyond the set payments.
- No Liquidity: You cannot access funds before payouts begin.
- Risk of Early Death: If you die prematurely and don’t add a costly death benefit, the insurance company keeps your money. Sorry spouse. Sorry children.
- Not Always a Good RMD Strategy: While it defers Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs), alternative solutions might be more tax-efficient.
Why Clark Howard’s Advice Is Misguided
Clark Howard’s recommendation to buy SPIAs and QLACs oversimplifies annuities and ignores options that provide more flexibility, growth, and protection against inflation. His advice is likely influenced by advertising revenue and lacks first-hand experience in retirement planning.
Red Flags to Look Out For
- Advertisements Everywhere – If a website is filled with ads, they may prioritize profits over unbiased recommendations.
- Commission Disclosures – Websites that earn commissions from recommended products have a financial interest in pushing specific options.
- Unqualified Authors – The author of an article may lack financial planning experience or proper licensing, making their advice unreliable.
- For example, an article titled “The Only Two Exceptions to Clark Howard’s Annuity Rule” was written by Christopher Smith, who has no publicly listed financial planning credentials.
Even though Clark.com claims it does not accept paid endorsements, indirect financial incentives may still influence its content.
Better Alternatives to SPIAs and QLACs
1. Fixed Index Annuities (FIAs) with Guaranteed Lifetime Withdrawal Benefits (GLWBs)
- Guaranteed lifetime income with market protection.
- Income can increase to combat inflation.
- Provides liquidity for emergencies.
- Any remaining balance goes to beneficiaries.
2. Hybrid Annuities
- Combines guaranteed income with long-term care benefits.
- Helps cover healthcare costs without depleting retirement savings.
3. Deferred Income Annuities (DIAs) with Inflation Riders
- Future income grows with inflation.
- Higher payouts than SPIAs due to deferral.
Who Needs SPIAs or QLACs?
- Retirees who don’t need liquidity and want a set-and-forget guaranteed income.
- People who don’t care about leaving money to heirs.
- Those looking for a way to defer RMDs past age 73 (QLACs only).
Who Doesn’t Need SPIAs or QLACs?
- Anyone who needs flexibility, liquidity, or market growth potential.
- Retirees concerned about inflation risk and declining purchasing power.
- Those who want to leave money to heirs instead of giving it all to the insurance company.
Conclusion
SPIAs and QLACs aren’t the best options for most retirees. Fixed Index Annuities with GLWBs provide better income, growth, and flexibility.
Before making a decision, compare all annuity options to ensure you get the best retirement income strategy.
For personalized annuity recommendations that fit your needs, not a website’s advertising goals, contact The Annuity Expert today!
Book A Free Consultation
Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.
Let Us Answer Your Questions
Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.