Take What You Gain Upfront vs. What You Gain Over Time and Which Actually Pays More
Fixed Index Annuities (FIAs) sometimes come with two types of bonuses: premium bonuses and income bonuses. These bonuses seem similar at first glance, but they serve very different purposes, are calculated differently, and only one actually puts real money in your pocket. Understanding the distinction is critical for anyone planning to buy a fixed index annuity.
Premium Bonuses: What They Are and How They Work
Definition
A premium bonus is a percentage added directly to your initial investment. If you invest $100,000 and the bonus is 10%, your account value becomes $110,000 on day one.
How It Works
- Credited immediately to your accumulation value or account value.
- Treated as part of your investment, growing with index performance or fixed interest.
- May vest over time—meaning you could lose part or all of it if you surrender early.
- Subject to recapture if you withdraw or cancel before the end of the surrender period.
Pros
- Tangible increase in account value on day one.
- Can boost early index interest earnings if it counts toward the growth base.
- It can help recover prior investment losses if you switch from another product.
Cons
- Often comes with longer surrender schedules or lower cap/participation rates.
- Vesting schedules may limit your access to the full bonus for 10+ years.
- Not always available in advisory-fee-based annuities.
Who Needs It
- Investors looking to accelerate early accumulation, especially after a market loss.
- Someone who is not planning to take a lifetime income, but who wants the growth potential.
Expert Tip: While a high percentage on day one is attractive, it is vital to check if the bonus is worth the potential trade-off in caps or participation rates. To ensure you are getting the strongest current offers, you can talk to a licensed annuity bonus broker to see a side-by-side comparison of the top-rated bonus contracts available today.
Who Doesn’t Need It
- People buying an FIA only for lifetime income—you’ll want to focus on income bonuses instead.
Income Bonuses: What They Are and How They Work
Definition
An income bonus is added to the income benefit base, which is a fictitious value used to calculate lifetime income payments, not available as a lump sum or walkaway value.
How It Works
- Usually applies to contracts with a Guaranteed Lifetime Withdrawal Benefit (GLWB) rider.
- Added only to the income base, not the actual account value.
- Often combined with roll-up rates (e.g., 7% compound) for a set number of years.
- Used to determine how much income you receive annually for life, not how much money you can walk away with.
Pros
- Can substantially increase lifetime income payments.
- Often higher than premium bonuses in dollar terms.
- Not subject to market volatility once the base is set and income starts.
Cons
- Not real money you can access—it’s a calculation tool only.
- No impact on death benefits, surrender value, or walkaway value.
- Often comes with GLWB rider fees, ranging from 0.95% to 1.5% annually.
Who Needs It
- Anyone wanting a guaranteed income for life, especially if retirement is near.
- Great for replacing a pension, creating your own paycheck from a 401(k) or IRA.
Expert Advice: Income bonuses are almost exclusively found on indexed contracts, but not all “roll-up” rates are created equal. If your primary goal is to turn a 401(k) or IRA into a guaranteed paycheck, you should get a fixed index annuity quote from our brokerage to find the specific carrier that offers the highest guaranteed payout for your retirement age.
Who Doesn’t Need It
- Investors focused on growth, not income.
- Anyone uncomfortable with paying ongoing fees for a rider.
Other Types of Insurance That Can Help
- Permanent Life Insurance: Can replace the lost funds if you die before using the income or if annuitized.
- Standalone Long-Term Care Annuities: Better for long-term care than annuities with LTC riders (those often return your own money).
- Return of Premium Riders: Help protect your premium from loss if income isn’t needed long-term.
What Types of Accounts Can Fund These Annuities?
Both premium and income bonus annuities can be funded with:
- IRA
- 401(k) rollover
- Non-qualified cash
- Roth IRA (only if you’re seeking income tax-free lifetime income in retirement)
Final Word: Which Is Better?
- If you’re focused on accumulating value or growing your retirement savings, go with a premium bonus.
- If your goal is to maximize guaranteed lifetime income, prioritize the income bonus, but make sure the product includes a GLWB rider and that you don’t annuitize—the GLWB keeps your income flexible and inheritable.
Want to compare premium bonus vs. income bonus annuities based on your retirement goals? Contact The Annuity Expert for free quotes and let us help you buy the right annuity with the best benefits at the lowest cost.
Book A Free Consultation
Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.
Let Us Answer Your Questions
Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.