Our Professional Opinion on the EquiTrust SmartBoost Index Annuity
SmartBoost Index is a specialized accumulation annuity built around a 40% year-ten value enhancement. The product can establish an Enhanced Accumulation Value equal to 140% of the initial premium, subject to vesting, withdrawals, and contract rules. The headline sounds dramatic, but it is roughly equivalent to a 3.42% compound annual floor over ten years—not a 40% immediate cash bonus.
EquiTrust is a financially established annuity company, but its B++ AM Best rating is below our preferred A- minimum. Other rating agencies may view the company differently, but our long-term annuity standard is based on AM Best. That does not make every EquiTrust contract unsuitable; it means the product must provide a meaningful advantage over an A- or better-rated insurer before we accept the lower rating.
We do not recommend SmartBoost for most accumulation buyers. The contract requires a full ten-year holding period to receive the complete enhancement, limits normal annual liquidity to 7% of the original premium, and uses special death-benefit choices during the vesting period. Index credits apply to the normal account value, not automatically to the enhanced value.
SmartBoost can be considered when the contractual year-ten value is materially better than an A- or better-rated alternative and the buyer can stay for the entire term. A guaranteed 3.42% equivalent may have been attractive in a low-rate environment, but it must be compared with current fixed annuity and cap-lock FIA opportunities.
This product should not be compared by retirement income because it does not include a GLWB. Compare the vested surrender value, year-ten Enhanced Accumulation Value, death-benefit election, and realistic account value with other accumulation annuities.
Bottom line: The 40% boost is useful only when the buyer stays long enough for it to vest and when the resulting value clearly beats better-rated alternatives. It is not a reason by itself to choose a B++ insurer.
What We Like
- Contractual year-ten enhancement: The product establishes a defined value target instead of relying entirely on index performance.
- No separate rider fee for the boost: The enhancement is built into the contract design.
- True S&P 500 choices: Traditional index strategies are available.
- Zero-percent market floor: Negative index performance does not directly reduce account value.
- Health waivers: Nursing-home and terminal-illness provisions can provide additional access.
- Beneficiary choices: The contract offers a lump-sum vested value or a larger payment stream during the vesting period.
What We Don’t Like
- B++ AM Best rating: The issuer is below our preferred A- minimum.
- Ten years required for full value: Leaving early can materially reduce the benefit.
- The 40% headline is misleading without annualization: It is about 3.42% compounded over ten years.
- Limited normal liquidity: The standard annual free amount is 7% of initial premium, not 10% of account value.
- Single-premium design: Additional deposits are not normally accepted.
- Index credits do not compound on the full enhanced value: They are applied to the normal account value.
- Complex death benefit: Beneficiaries may need to choose between a smaller lump sum and installments.
- No lifetime-income rider: It is not designed to guarantee a retirement paycheck while retaining account control.
What Is the EquiTrust SmartBoost Index Annuity?
SmartBoost Index is a single-premium fixed indexed annuity that combines an ordinary account value with a separate Enhanced Accumulation Value. The enhancement vests over ten contract anniversaries and can establish a 140% year-ten value under the contract rules.
The product also offers fixed and index-linked crediting choices. Market losses do not directly reduce the account value, but withdrawals, surrender charges, an MVA, and the vesting schedule can reduce what the owner or beneficiaries receive.
SmartBoost Index Product Details
| Feature | Current Product Design |
|---|---|
| Product type | Single-premium fixed indexed annuity with an enhanced accumulation value |
| Issue ages | Generally 0–80 |
| Minimum premium | $10,000 |
| Additional premiums | Not normally accepted |
| Enhanced value | 140% of initial premium, subject to vesting and withdrawal adjustments |
| Vesting | 10% increments over ten contract anniversaries |
| Surrender period | Ten years |
| Penalty-free access | Generally 7% of initial premium after the first contract year |
| Index choices | S&P 500 and proprietary strategies plus a fixed account |
| Death benefit during first ten years | Vested enhanced value as a lump sum or full enhanced value through scheduled payments, subject to contract terms |
| Death benefit after year ten | Generally account value |
How the 40% SmartBoost Works
The enhanced value is a separate component within the contract’s annuity values. It begins at 140% of the initial premium for benefit calculations, but only a portion is vested during the early contract years.
The vesting percentage generally increases from 10% after the first anniversary to 100% after the tenth. A surrender before full vesting uses the vested enhanced value or other applicable contract value—not the full 140% headline amount.
What Is the Annualized Value of a 40% Ten-Year Boost?
Growing from 100% to 140% over ten years is approximately 3.42% compounded annually. That calculation is the correct starting point for comparing SmartBoost with a guaranteed fixed annuity.
Compare the resulting year-ten value with current fixed annuity rates and with accumulation FIAs that lock traditional-index crediting terms. A better-rated contract may provide a higher guaranteed maturity value without the same vesting complexity.
Index Interest Is Credited to the Normal Account Value
SmartBoost offers strategies linked to the S&P 500, including caps, participation rates, and a performance trigger. Index interest is credited to the normal account value, not automatically to the full 140% enhanced amount.
Current terms can change at renewal. Review how FIA renewal rates work and do not treat the current rate sheet as a ten-year forecast.
Penalty-Free Access and Surrender Charges
After the first contract year, the normal free-withdrawal amount is generally 7% of initial premium. That is more restrictive than a typical 10% of account value provision. Excess access faces the following surrender schedule:
| Schedule | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Contract year | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
| Surrender charge | 9% | 8% | 7% | 6.5% | 5.5% | 4.5% | 3.5% | 2.5% | 1.5% | 0.5% |
Chargeable withdrawals can also receive a Market Value Adjustment. Withdrawals reduce the enhanced value proportionally and can permanently reduce future free-withdrawal amounts.
Death Benefit Choices
During the first ten years, beneficiaries may be able to receive the vested enhanced value as a lump sum or the full enhanced value through scheduled payments. This is more complex than a standard account-value death benefit. Review how annuity inheritance options affect taxes and timing.
After the enhancement period, the death benefit generally becomes the normal account value. Buyers who need a guaranteed lump-sum legacy should compare life insurance or a dedicated enhanced-death-benefit annuity.
Tax Treatment
Interest grows tax-deferred and is generally taxed as ordinary income when distributed under annuity tax rules. A distribution before age 59½ may also face the federal 10% additional tax unless an exception applies.
An IRA already provides tax deferral. Qualified money should be used only when SmartBoost’s contractual value and protection features justify the product—not for additional tax benefits.
EquiTrust Financial Strength and the B++ Issue
An annuity guarantee is only as strong as the issuing insurance company. Because EquiTrust is rated B++ by AM Best, we apply a higher burden of proof than we would to an A- or better-rated carrier. SmartBoost offers a distinctive year-ten guarantee, but the equivalent annualized floor must materially exceed what an A- or better-rated insurer can guarantee before the lower rating is justified.
For a large purchase, consider insurer diversification and the limits of your state guaranty association. State guaranty protection is a backstop, not a substitute for choosing financially strong insurance companies.
Who Should Consider SmartBoost Index?
- A buyer who can commit the money for the full ten-year vesting period.
- Someone who values a contractual year-ten value more than annual liquidity.
- A consumer whose guaranteed year-ten value materially exceeds better-rated alternatives.
- A buyer who understands the beneficiary payout choices during the vesting period.
Who Should Avoid It?
- Someone who may need more than 7% of initial premium annually.
- A buyer seeking guaranteed lifetime withdrawals.
- Someone who views the 40% boost as an immediate cash bonus.
- A consumer who can lock a higher guaranteed annual rate with an A- or better-rated insurer.
- Anyone unwilling to manage a complex death-benefit election.
Other Insurance Coverage to Consider
- Long-term care insurance: Protects retirement assets from extended home care, assisted-living, or nursing-home expenses.
- Life insurance: Provides a defined death benefit when the annuity is intended primarily for the owner’s retirement rather than inheritance.
- Medicare Supplement coverage: Helps limit healthcare cost-sharing so the annuity is not used as the first source for routine medical expenses.
Alternatives to Compare
Oceanview CapLock offers traditional-index cap locks that can make the accumulation outcome easier to evaluate.
Sagicor Sage Accumulator provides another accumulation design with locked crediting terms and more typical liquidity.
A MYGA: Compare the 3.42% equivalent year-ten floor with current annuity rates and guaranteed maturity values.
Our Final Recommendation
We generally do not recommend SmartBoost Index unless its guaranteed year-ten value is materially higher than what an A- or better-rated insurer will provide. The 40% boost is a ten-year value, not an immediate return. Full vesting, limited liquidity, death-benefit complexity, and the B++ rating create a high hurdle.
Contact The Annuity Expert for free quotes and a no-obligation comparison of SmartBoost Index with annuities from A- or better-rated insurers. We will compare the guarantee, income or accumulation value, fees, surrender period, liquidity, death benefit, company strength, and any care benefits before you buy coverage.
Book A Free Consultation
Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.
Let Us Answer Your Questions
Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is SmartBoost Index a good annuity?
It can fit a buyer who stays for ten years and receives a materially better guaranteed value than stronger-rated alternatives. It is not our default accumulation recommendation.
Is the 40% boost available immediately?
No. The enhanced value vests over ten contract anniversaries and is adjusted for withdrawals.
What annual return equals 140% after ten years?
Approximately 3.42% compounded annually.
Do index credits apply to the full enhanced value?
No. Index credits are applied to the normal account value under the selected strategy.
How much can I withdraw penalty-free?
The standard annual amount after year one is generally 7% of initial premium, subject to the contract rules.
Does SmartBoost provide lifetime income?
It can be annuitized, but it does not include a guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit for retaining normal account access.