Our Professional Opinion on the Prudential Elevate Accumulator Annuity
We would not make Elevate Accumulator our first choice for protected growth. Prudential can reset its caps and participation rates when an index term ends, but you may face surrender charges for seven or ten years. We prefer a competitive annuity that locks the crediting terms for the full surrender period. A great first-year cap is not much comfort if it falls while your money is still committed.
Prudential is a great company. Pruco Life Insurance Company issues Elevate and has an A+ (Superior) AM Best rating, above our A− minimum. The issue is the contract’s renewal flexibility for the insurer, not its financial strength.
We would start with the annual S&P 500 strategy and compare it with other indexed annuities, including products that guarantee their cap or participation rate through the surrender period. We would also compare a MYGA: if its guaranteed result meets your goal, Elevate’s uncertain index credits have to justify giving up that certainty.
What We Like
- Traditional index option: The S&P 500 is available, so you do not have to rely entirely on a complicated index.
- Protection from index losses: A negative index result does not itself subtract an index loss from the account.
- Fixed account option: You can allocate money to a fixed strategy with a one-year declared rate.
- Death benefit: An eligible beneficiary can receive account value or the minimum guaranteed surrender value, whichever is greater, with applicable interim index interest.
What We Don’t Like
- The cap can change: A cap locked for one index term is not locked for the entire surrender period.
- No ordinary first-year free withdrawal: The standard allowance starts after the first anniversary.
- Longer index terms can disappoint: A two- or three-year strategy can finish with no interest after you have waited the entire term.
- Interest can be lost on a withdrawal: Money taken from an indexed strategy before its term ends misses that term’s index credit.
- Early exit is expensive: Surrender charges and a market value adjustment can apply above the allowance.
Prudential Elevate Accumulator Overview
Elevate Accumulator is a fixed indexed annuity issued by Pruco Life. You can allocate money among a fixed strategy and available indexed strategies. The seven- and ten-year versions define the surrender period; California offers seven- and nine-year versions. Availability and terms vary by state.
Key Features
- Index options: The S&P 500, MSCI EAFE, and other indexes, depending on availability.
- Index terms: One, two, or three years, depending on the strategy.
- Interest calculation: Caps, participation rates, or performance triggers, depending on your selection.
- Ordinary withdrawals: Generally up to 10% of the prior anniversary’s account value after the first anniversary.
- Early-exit costs: Surrender charges and an MVA may apply to amounts above the allowance.
- Beneficiaries: The greater of account value or minimum guaranteed surrender value, plus any applicable interim credit.
How Elevate Earns Interest
Your interest depends on the selected index and strategy. A cap limits the index gain used to calculate interest; a participation rate determines the share of the gain used by that strategy. A performance trigger uses a stated credit when its conditions are met. A negative index result produces no indexed interest for the term rather than an index loss to your account.
We prefer the traditional S&P 500 over a proprietary or volatility-controlled index we cannot easily compare. A larger participation rate on a managed index is not automatically better: the index itself may use different assets, volatility controls, and adjustments. You do not own the underlying stocks or receive their dividends directly.
The one-year fixed strategy offers a known rate for that term. Prudential declares a new fixed rate at renewal. If you expect to leave most of your money in that account for several years, compare a MYGA instead: it can guarantee the actual interest rate for a defined multiyear period.
Why We Prefer the Annual Strategy
Elevate also offers two- and three-year index terms. We would generally choose an annual point-to-point strategy. Think of it like baseball: over six years, an annual strategy gives you six opportunities for an interest credit; a three-year strategy gives you two. More opportunities do not guarantee a better result, but they do offer more chances to lock in a gain.
For example, an index could rise in year one and fall back before a three-year term ends. A long-term strategy might then credit nothing, while an annual strategy could have credited interest at the first anniversary. We would not choose the longer term solely because its participation rate looks higher.
Withdrawals and Surrender Charges
After the first anniversary, the ordinary penalty-free withdrawal is generally 10% of the account value at the prior anniversary. There is no ordinary allowance during the first contract year. A withdrawal above the allowance can incur surrender charges and a market value adjustment.
A free withdrawal can still cost you interest. Money taken from an indexed strategy before its term ends is not eligible for that term’s index interest on the withdrawn amount. That makes the three-year option particularly frustrating for someone who may need access during the term.
Prudential-calculated required minimum distributions attributable to this contract are not subject to the surrender charge or MVA. Confirm the calculation before requesting a distribution. The minimum guaranteed surrender value is calculated under the contract and does not automatically equal the original deposit.
Death Benefit and Your Spouse
The death benefit before annuity payments begin is generally the greater of the account value or the minimum guaranteed surrender value. A death during an index term may also receive applicable interim interest, unlike an ordinary mid-term withdrawal. Withdrawals reduce what remains for family.
When spouses co-own the annuity, an eligible survivor may be able to choose spousal continuation instead of receiving the death benefit. Ownership and beneficiary designations matter; confirm the arrangements before buying.
Our Final Verdict on Elevate Accumulator
Elevate gives you a traditional index and a strong insurer, but the renewable cap is a weak point in a long surrender commitment. We would compare a locked-cap annuity and fixed annuity rates first. If you still choose Elevate, we would start with the annual S&P 500 strategy and make sure the withdrawal rules fit your plans.
Contact The Annuity Expert for free annuity quotes. We can compare the actual strategies, guarantees, and access rules for your situation.
Book A Free Consultation
Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.
Let Us Answer Your Questions
Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.