Our Professional Opinion on the USAA Fixed Indexed Annuity
We like USAA’s straightforward S&P 500 strategy, but we would shop other annuities before committing $100,000 to this one. USAA can change the cap every year while you remain subject to surrender charges for seven years. That is a significant tradeoff when other annuities may guarantee their crediting terms for longer.
An attractive first-year cap is not enough. We would compare USAA with a competitive annual S&P 500 annuity that locks its cap for the surrender period, along with a fixed-rate annuity that guarantees its interest for a comparable term. A locked cap still has to be competitive; it does not guarantee a higher return.
We think USAA Life Insurance Company is a great insurance company. Its A++ (Superior) AM Best rating is the highest available and comfortably above our A− minimum. That financial strength is excellent, but it does not mean this particular annuity automatically offers the best growth opportunity.
USAA offers this product directly through its own retirement specialists. That is a captive-style sales channel: the discussion centers on USAA’s lineup rather than a broad comparison of other insurance companies. USAA also distributes certain other annuities through outside financial institutions, so the distribution of every USAA annuity is not the same.
What We Like
- A great insurance company: USAA Life’s A++ AM Best rating gives us confidence in the company standing behind its guarantees.
- A familiar index: The annual S&P 500 strategy is easier to evaluate than many proprietary indexes.
- Annual interest opportunities: Index performance is measured each year, and interest credited at the end of a period is protected from future index declines.
- A fixed account option: You can allocate money to a declared fixed rate instead of relying entirely on index-linked interest.
What We Don’t Like
- The cap can change annually: Your upside can shrink during the seven-year surrender period.
- A $100,000 minimum: That is a steep requirement, especially when other indexed annuities accept smaller deposits.
- No ordinary first-year free withdrawal: Needing money in the first year can trigger a surrender charge.
- A limited direct sales comparison: A USAA specialist does not automatically shop the market for you.
- No guaranteed indexed interest above zero: Your account can go a year without indexed interest, even though your money remains committed.
USAA Fixed Indexed Annuity Overview
The USAA product is a single-deposit fixed indexed annuity designed to grow money before you begin taking income. You can allocate money to an S&P 500 indexed account, a fixed account, or both. It is not available in New York; other state restrictions and contract terms can apply.
- Insurance company: USAA Life Insurance Company.
- Minimum deposit: $100,000.
- Surrender period: Seven years.
- Indexed account: Annual S&P 500 interest calculation with a cap and 100% participation.
- Fixed account: A declared interest rate that can change after the first year, subject to the contract minimum.
- Ordinary withdrawals: After the first year, one withdrawal of up to 10% each year without a surrender charge, subject to contract rules.
- Income option: All or part of the balance, with a $20,000 minimum, may be transferred to an immediate annuity.
Funding choices include cash, an eligible retirement-plan rollover, or an IRA transfer. Compare your current account’s features and costs before moving retirement money into any annuity.
How the S&P 500 Strategy Works
USAA measures the S&P 500 over an annual crediting period. If the index rises, the indexed account can receive the gain up to the declared cap. A 100% participation rate means the calculation uses the entire index gain up to that cap; it does not mean you receive unlimited stock market returns.
For example, assume the index rises 8% during the year and the cap is a hypothetical 6%. The interest credit would be 6%. If the index falls, the index-linked interest credit is 0% for that period. These examples exclude dividends and do not predict future results.
We like annual crediting because each year offers a new opportunity to lock in interest. But a 0% credit is possible, and the annuity is not directly invested in the S&P 500. Early withdrawals and applicable charges can reduce what you receive even when the indexed account is protected from index losses.
The Cap Can Change During Your Commitment
USAA declares the cap annually. The cap you receive for the first crediting period is not guaranteed for all seven years. If USAA lowers it later, you have less upside potential, even though leaving early may trigger a surrender charge.
That is why we prefer comparing other indexed annuities with a competitive S&P 500 cap guaranteed for the full surrender period. A longer cap guarantee gives you more certainty about the rules, but compare the actual cap, withdrawal terms, company strength, and surrender period before deciding. A lower locked cap is not automatically better.
Fixed Account vs. a Guaranteed Fixed Annuity
The fixed account provides a declared rate for its initial interest period. USAA may change that rate after the first year, subject to the applicable minimum guarantee. It is not a seven-year guaranteed rate simply because the annuity has a seven-year surrender period.
If knowing your interest in advance matters more than having an opportunity for additional growth, compare fixed annuity rates for a multi-year guaranteed annuity, or MYGA. Compare the same deposit, time horizon, and withdrawals. The USAA indexed account may earn more, but it may also credit zero interest in a given year.
Withdrawals and Surrender Charges
The first-year restriction stinks if you need access quickly. USAA’s ordinary free-withdrawal allowance starts after the first year. You can then generally make one withdrawal of up to 10% annually without a surrender charge, subject to the contract’s calculation and rules.
Withdrawals during year one and amounts above the allowance in later years can incur a surrender charge during the seven-year period. The schedule differs by state, including California. Before buying, ask for the schedule for your state and how the free amount is calculated; keep money you may need sooner elsewhere.
If you expect to take required minimum distributions, confirm how the contract treats them and whether a withdrawal above the ordinary allowance is subject to a charge. Do not assume that a required distribution automatically overrides the annuity’s withdrawal rules.
Is This the Right Annuity for Lifetime Income?
USAA allows you to transfer all or part of the balance, with a $20,000 minimum, to an immediate annuity. That can provide guaranteed income, but converting money to an income stream generally means giving up lump-sum access to the amount converted.
If your main goal is a paycheck you cannot outlive, we would also compare an annuity with a guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit, or GLWB. A GLWB can provide lifetime withdrawals under its rules while leaving any remaining account value accessible. Compare the actual guaranteed payments, fees, access, and beneficiary outcomes using the same deposit, income start date, and number of people covered.
Death Benefit and Spousal Continuation
Before buying, confirm how the death benefit is calculated, what happens if you die during an index crediting period, and whether any surrender charges apply to the benefit. If your spouse is your beneficiary, ask whether spousal continuation is available under your contract and what choices your spouse would have. Do not assume all beneficiary options are identical.
Who Should Consider This Annuity?
This annuity is worth comparing if you have at least $100,000 to set aside, want protected S&P 500-linked growth, and value USAA’s financial strength. It becomes more compelling when its initial cap is competitive and you understand that later caps can change.
We would look elsewhere first if you need first-year access, want to deposit less than $100,000, or want a cap guaranteed throughout the surrender period. If you need a dependable rate rather than index-linked growth, a MYGA is the cleaner comparison. If guaranteed lifetime income is the priority, compare a GLWB before deciding.
Our Final Verdict
USAA is a great insurance company, but this annuity’s annually reset cap and high minimum keep it from being an automatic recommendation. We like the familiar annual S&P 500 option; we dislike committing to seven years of surrender charges without knowing the cap for that whole period.
We would compare the actual offer with a competitive locked-cap indexed annuity and a MYGA before buying. Contact The Annuity Expert for free annuity quotes, and we can help you compare the guarantees, withdrawal features, and tradeoffs for your retirement.
Book A Free Consultation
Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.
Let Us Answer Your Questions
Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.