Annuity Loans: How They Work and What You Need to Know

Understanding Annuity Loans

If you are looking for a way to access cash from an annuity without surrendering the entire contract, you may come across the term “annuity loan.” However, borrowing against an individually owned annuity does not generally work like borrowing against a 401(k) or a cash value life insurance policy.

For federal income tax purposes, a loan from an individually owned commercial annuity is generally treated as a nonperiodic distribution when the loan is made. This means an annuity loan should not be marketed as a way to access cash while automatically preserving tax deferral.

What Is an Annuity Loan?

Some annuity contracts may allow you to borrow against the contract rather than completely surrendering your annuity. However, the fact that the insurance company calls the transaction a loan does not necessarily mean the IRS treats it like a traditional loan.

For an individually owned commercial annuity, a loan is generally treated as a distribution for federal tax purposes. If the annuity has accumulated gains, some or all of the amount borrowed may be taxable as ordinary income. If you are under age 59½, the taxable portion may also be subject to an additional 10% federal tax unless an exception applies.

How Does Borrowing Against an Annuity Work?

If your contract permits a loan, the amount available may depend on the annuity’s cash value and the specific terms of the contract. The insurer may also charge interest on the loan.

The important difference is the tax treatment. With an individually owned commercial annuity, the IRS generally treats the loan as a nonperiodic distribution when it occurs. Repaying the loan later does not simply erase the original tax treatment.

Potential Advantages and Risks

Potential Advantages

• Access to Cash: If the contract permits loans, you may be able to access funds for emergencies or other expenses without completely surrendering the annuity.
• Contract Remains in Force: Depending on the contract terms, the remaining annuity value may continue earning interest or receiving index credits.
• Qualified Plan Exception: Certain employer retirement plans can permit participant loans that are not immediately taxable when all applicable IRS requirements are satisfied.

Risks

• Immediate Tax Consequences: A loan from an individually owned commercial annuity is generally treated as a distribution for federal income tax purposes.
• Early Distribution Tax: If you are under age 59½, the taxable portion may also be subject to an additional 10% federal tax unless an exception applies.
• Interest Charges: If the insurer charges interest on the loan, those costs can further reduce the economic value of the transaction.
• Reduced Benefits: A loan may affect the contract value, death benefit, or future retirement income, depending on the annuity.
• Limited Availability: Most individual annuities are not designed to function as revolving credit, and loan provisions are not universally available.

Tax Implications of an Annuity Loan

Annuity loans can have significant tax consequences. For an individually owned nonqualified commercial annuity, the IRS generally treats a loan as a nonperiodic distribution.

Before the annuity starting date, nonqualified annuity distributions are generally taxed gain first. In other words, the taxable amount is generally the lesser of the distribution or the amount by which the contract’s cash value exceeds your investment in the contract. After the taxable gain has been distributed, additional amounts may represent a return of your after-tax basis.

If you are under age 59½, the taxable portion of the distribution may also be subject to the 10% additional federal tax on early distributions unless you qualify for an exception.

Because annuity taxation depends on the type of contract, its tax status, your cost basis, and how the transaction is structured, review the transaction with your insurance company and a tax professional before proceeding.

Be Careful Using an Annuity as Collateral

Warning: Pledging or assigning all or part of an individually owned annuity as collateral for a bank, business, or personal loan can also be treated as a distribution for federal tax purposes. The taxable amount depends on the value pledged and the applicable annuity distribution rules.

If a lender requires collateral, do not assume your annuity can be pledged without tax consequences. Depending on your situation, a lender may accept other assets. A properly structured collateral assignment of life insurance may also be worth discussing when life insurance is already part of your financial plan, but the suitability and tax treatment should be reviewed separately.

The Important Exception: Qualified Employer Plan Loans

The rules are different for certain qualified employer retirement plans. Qualified plans, certain qualified employee annuities, 403(b) plans, and governmental plans may permit participant loans that are not immediately treated as taxable distributions if they satisfy IRS requirements.

A qualifying participant loan generally must stay within IRS borrowing limits, have a legally enforceable repayment agreement, and be repaid through substantially level payments made at least quarterly. Repayment generally must occur within five years, although a longer term can be available for a loan used to purchase a principal residence.

This exception should not be confused with borrowing from an individually owned commercial annuity. IRAs and IRA-based plans do not permit participant loans.

Why Annuity Loans Are Rare and Risky

Rarity:
You rarely see loan provisions in individual annuity contracts because annuities are primarily designed to provide guaranteed retirement income or deferred growth, not to function as revolving credit.

Tax Risk:
For an individually owned commercial annuity, the loan itself can generally be treated as a distribution when it is made. This is different from a qualified employer-plan loan, where a loan that initially satisfies IRS requirements can later become a deemed distribution if the applicable repayment or other plan-loan requirements are violated.

That distinction matters. An individual annuity owner should not assume that borrowing money and paying it back later will preserve the contract’s tax deferral.

Safer Alternatives to Annuity Loans

1. Penalty-Free Withdrawals

Many annuities allow annual penalty-free withdrawals of a specified percentage or amount under the contract. “Penalty-free” generally means the insurer waives its surrender charge on that amount. It does not automatically mean the withdrawal is free from income tax or the IRS additional tax on early distributions.

• Pros: Provides access to a portion of the contract without an insurer surrender charge when the withdrawal falls within the contract’s allowance.
• Cons: Withdrawals may reduce account value and benefits and may still create taxable income.
• Best for: Small or occasional cash needs.
• Not suitable for: Someone who needs a large amount of money beyond the contract’s penalty-free withdrawal provisions.

2. Hardship and Crisis Waivers

Some annuities waive surrender charges for contract-specific qualifying events such as nursing home confinement, terminal illness, or certain other serious health conditions. The exact triggers and eligibility rules vary by insurer and contract.

A surrender-charge waiver does not automatically make a withdrawal income-tax-free or exempt it from federal early-distribution rules.

• Pros: Can provide additional liquidity during a qualifying health or crisis event.
• Cons: Waiver provisions vary significantly and do not eliminate applicable income taxes.
• Best for: Contract owners who experience an event specifically covered by their annuity’s waiver provisions.
• Not suitable for: Planned expenses that do not meet the contract’s waiver requirements.

3. Rule 72(t) – SEPP

Substantially Equal Periodic Payments may allow qualifying distributions before age 59½ without the 10% additional federal tax on early distributions. The payments must follow IRS rules and generally must continue for at least five years or until you reach age 59½, whichever period is longer.

• Pros: Can create structured access to retirement funds before age 59½ without the additional 10% tax when all requirements are satisfied.
• Cons: The strategy is rigid, and an improper modification can create significant tax consequences.
• Best for: Early retirees who need predictable ongoing income.
• Not suitable for: Anyone who needs flexible or occasional withdrawals.

4. Rule of 55

If you separate from service with an employer during or after the calendar year in which you reach age 55, the Rule of 55 may allow qualifying distributions directly from that employer’s retirement plan without the 10% additional federal tax on early distributions. Different age rules can apply to certain public safety employees.

This exception applies to eligible employer plans, not to a personal nonqualified annuity simply because you are age 55.

• Pros: Can provide earlier access to eligible employer-plan funds without the additional 10% federal tax.
• Cons: Ordinary income tax can still apply, and rolling the funds to an IRA can eliminate access to this particular exception for those funds.
• Best for: Workers separating from an employer during or after the year they reach the applicable age.
• Not suitable for: Personal non-employer annuities.

5. 1035 Exchange

A properly structured Section 1035 exchange lets you move from one annuity to another without recognizing the gain at the time of the exchange. This can be useful when your existing contract no longer fits your needs but you do not need to spend the money.

A 1035 exchange provides a way to reposition the contract; it does not give you cash for current expenses. Surrender charges may also apply to the old contract, and the new annuity may begin a new surrender-charge period.

• Pros: Allows an eligible annuity to be repositioned without recognizing the existing gain at the time of a properly completed exchange.
• Cons: Does not provide spendable cash and may restart surrender periods or other contract restrictions.
• Best for: Someone who wants a different annuity with stronger rates, income features, liquidity provisions, or other benefits.
• Not suitable for: Someone who actually needs cash for a current expense.

Summary Table

Option	How It Works	Best For
Penalty-Free Withdrawal	Uses the contract’s annual withdrawal allowance without an insurer surrender charge	Short-term, smaller cash needs
Hardship Waiver	May waive surrender charges after a contract-specific qualifying event	Health or crisis situations
Rule 72(t) SEPP	Uses qualifying scheduled distributions before age 59½	Early retirees needing steady income
Rule of 55	May permit penalty-exempt withdrawals from an eligible employer plan after qualifying separation from service	Workers separating from an employer at the applicable age
1035 Exchange	Moves an eligible annuity directly to another annuity without recognizing existing gain at the time of exchange	Repositioning an annuity rather than taking cash

Final Word: Why Borrowing Against an Annuity Is Usually Not the Best Option

Borrowing against an individually owned annuity is generally not a tax-free way to access your money. A loan or collateral assignment can be treated as a distribution, potentially creating ordinary income tax and, when applicable, an additional 10% federal tax before age 59½.

Before borrowing against an annuity, first check the contract’s penalty-free withdrawal provisions, health-related waivers, and other liquidity options. If the annuity itself no longer fits your goals, a 1035 exchange may provide a better way to reposition the money without cashing out the contract.

If you are considering a replacement contract for future needs, review annuities with flexible withdrawal options before accepting a new surrender period. Compare those terms with the access your current contract already provides.

At The Annuity Expert, we’re an independent annuity broker and insurance agency. We can compare your existing contract with other options and help determine whether taking a withdrawal, using an available waiver, completing a 1035 exchange, or simply leaving the annuity alone makes the most sense.

Schedule a free consultation or contact us for free, no-obligation annuity quotes and comparisons.

Book A Free Consultation

Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.

Let Us Answer Your Questions

Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.

Contact Us

Name *

First

Last *

Last

Email *

Subject *

How May We Help You? *

Submit

If you are human, leave this field blank.

Δ

Questions From Our Readers