Understanding the Two Withdrawal Methods
Premium-Based Penalty-Free Withdrawals
This method allows you to take a set percentage (usually 10%) of your original investment (premium) each year without a surrender charge, regardless of how much the contract has earned or lost.
Account Value-Based Penalty-Free Withdrawals
This method allows you to take a percentage (typically 10%) of your current total account value—including gains, fees, and any losses or bonuses.
Examples in Good and Bad Market Conditions
Positive Market Scenario (Account Value Grows)
You invest $100,000 in a Fixed Indexed Annuity (FIA).
- After Year 1: The annuity grows to $112,000 due to strong market performance.
Premium-Based Withdrawal:
- You can withdraw 10% of $100,000 = $10,000 penalty-free.
Account Value-Based Withdrawal:
- You can withdraw 10% of $112,000 = $11,200 penalty-free.
✅ Advantage: Account value-based contracts give you more liquidity in a rising market.
Negative Market Scenario (Account Value Declines)
You invest $100,000 in the same FIA.
- After Year 1: Due to market volatility, the account value drops to $95,000 (e.g., index was flat or only credited a low fixed interest).
Premium-Based Withdrawal:
- You can still withdraw 10% of $100,000 = $10,000 penalty-free.
Account Value-Based Withdrawal:
- You’re limited to 10% of $95,000 = $9,500 penalty-free.
✅ Advantage: Premium-based contracts protect your access regardless of short-term market movement.
How This Affects Planning
- If You Want Stable Income Early On
You’ll want premium-based withdrawals. They offer predictable access to capital, especially helpful in years when market-linked crediting underperforms.
- If You’re Focused on Long-Term Growth
You might prefer account value-based withdrawals, which reward strong performance with increased liquidity over time
Who Needs Premium-Based Withdrawals
- Best For:
- Retirees planning to draw income within the first 5 years of the annuity.
- Conservative investors who want liquidity that doesn’t fluctuate.
- People using annuities as bond alternatives or emergency funds.
- Not Ideal For:
- Investors who never plan to take withdrawals before turning on income.
- People using annuities strictly for legacy or tax deferral purposes.
Who Needs Account Value-Based Withdrawals
- Best For:
- Growth-oriented investors with longer time horizons.
- Buyers who want access to more funds as performance improves.
- Clients layering annuities over time and tracking performance.
- Not Ideal For:
- Buyers who want certainty in down markets.
- Those taking income early in the contract term.
What Happens When You Trigger a GLWB
A Guaranteed Lifetime Withdrawal Benefit (GLWB) rider calculates income based on a benefit base—not premium or account value. This base grows through roll-ups or market-based gains (depending on the rider), and once income begins, you receive guaranteed payments for life.
Important Distinction:
- GLWB withdrawals do not count against your 10% penalty-free withdrawals. They are treated separately under the rider.
- Once GLWB income begins, the 10% withdrawal feature often becomes irrelevant unless you want to access more than the guaranteed income, which may reduce future payments.
Compare GLWB Income Payouts
Waivers That Improve Access Regardless of Withdrawal Type
- Nursing Home Confinement Waiver: Allows full or partial withdrawals with no surrender charge if confined to a qualified facility.
- Terminal Illness Waiver: Same as above if diagnosed with a terminal condition.
- Return of Premium (ROP) Waiver: In select annuities, allows you to surrender the contract and get your original premium back.
Who Benefits Most: Retirees concerned about long-term care, terminal illness, or needing an exit strategy.
Types of Annuities Offering Each Withdrawal Type
| Annuity Type | Premium-Based | Account Value-Based | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fixed Indexed Annuities (FIA) | ✓ Common | ✓ Common | Check contract – many offer both options |
| MYGAs (Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuities) | ✓ Rare | ✗ Rare | Most do not allow penalty-free withdrawals |
| Variable Annuities (VA) | ✗ No | ✓ Common | Based on fluctuating account value |
| Deferred Income Annuities (DIA) | ✗ No | ✗ No | No liquidity during deferral period |
| Single Premium Immediate Annuities (SPIA) | ✗ No | ✗ No | Annuitized; no penalty-free withdrawals |
What Else You Need to Protect Your Liquidity
- FIA with GLWB: Offers both income and liquidity. Can be funded with IRA, 401(k), or non-qualified funds.
- Standalone LTC Annuities: Provide greater care protection than traditional waivers and return unused premiums.
- Life Insurance: Used to replace legacy value lost due to withdrawals or annuitization.
- MYGA with ROP: If you want a CD alternative with penalty-free access in emergencies.
Why This Matters Now
Many annuity buyers make the mistake of focusing only on growth or income potential without considering how they’ll access funds if life throws a curveball. Choosing the wrong withdrawal structure could cost you thousands—or deny access when you need it most.
Work Backwards to Choose the Right Product
- If your goal is guaranteed income, shop for the annuity with the highest GLWB income payout, then compare penalty-free access, riders, and carrier strength.
- If your goal is safe accumulation, look for FIAs with premium-based withdrawals and strong index options. Avoid engineered indexes without history.
- If your goal is principal protection and emergency access, use a MYGA with penalty-free withdrawals or a flexible FIA with return of premium.
While comparing annuity penalty-free withdrawals based on account value vs. premium, annuities with penalty-free withdrawals can show how much money remains accessible through penalty-free withdrawals, return-of-premium features, shorter surrender periods, or other liquidity provisions.
Get Help From a Professional Who Can Shop It For You
Don’t try to guess which method is in your contract, or assume all 10% withdrawal features are created equal. Some carriers quietly reduce access in down years if you’re not careful. Contact The Annuity Expert today for a free review of your options and a custom quote. We’ll shop every top-rated annuity on the market to find the one with the most flexible penalty-free access and the best value based on your goals. Make the right choice once, because switching later could cost you.
Book A Free Consultation
Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.
Let Us Answer Your Questions
Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.