What Is an Index in a Fixed Index Annuity?
An index is the benchmark used to measure your interest crediting potential. Your money isn’t directly invested in these indexes. Instead, the annuity company uses the performance of the index to calculate how much interest to credit your contract. You may earn nothing some years, but you will never lose money due to market declines.
As you are comparing fixed index annuity crediting options, compare fixed index annuity strategies by prioritizing simple annual crediting, renewal protections, realistic participation terms, and index design over aggressive backtested illustrations.
Types of Indexes Available on FIAs
1. Traditional Market Indexes
- S&P 500
- Dow Jones Industrial Average
- Nasdaq-100
- iShares ETFs (e.g., Core S&P 500, Russell 2000, MSCI EAFE)
- Gold (LBMA Gold Price, SPDR Gold Shares ETF)
How they work: Traditional indexes are widely followed and have decades of performance history. Interest is credited using participation rates or caps. These indexes are typically offered with no additional costs or volatility control overlays.
Pros:
- Transparent and widely researched
- No volatility control or artificial adjustments
- Easier to track performance independently
Cons:
- Lower crediting limits (caps or participation rates)
- Higher risk of earning 0% in down years
Who needs this: Conservative investors who want full transparency and a trackable index history. Best for clients who prefer straightforward interest potential.
Who doesn’t: Investors looking for steady, more smoothed returns or those seeking higher annual crediting consistency.
2. Volatility-Controlled and Engineered Indexes
- Barclays, JP Morgan, BlackRock, Morgan Stanley, and BNP indexes
- S&P MARC 5%, S&P RavenPack AI, Nasdaq Premier, Shiller Barclays CAPE
- Goldman Sachs Momentum Builder, Franklin SG Select
How they work: These indexes use rules-based strategies to control volatility and smooth out returns. Most maintain a volatility target (e.g., 5% or 10%), rebalancing between stocks, bonds, commodities, or cash to stay within that target.
Pros:
- More consistent returns
- Higher participation rates due to lower volatility
- Often paired with higher cap rates or no caps at all
Cons:
- Complex and hard to research
- Often includes hidden costs (index fee or spread)
- Simulated performance, no long-term real history
Who needs this: Investors who want reduced volatility, especially when using a GLWB (Guaranteed Lifetime Withdrawal Benefit) for lifetime income.
Who doesn’t: Those who demand transparency and want an index they can independently verify or track historically.
Pro Tip: Choosing a volatility-controlled index might offer higher participation rates, but it changes the overall yield profile of the contract. Before you select a strategy, you should evaluate the historical index annuity performance to understand how different crediting methods handle various market cycles.
3. Proprietary or Blended Indexes
- AB 500 Plus, Barclays Agility Shield, AI-Powered Global Opportunities
- Morningstar Global Wide Moat, First Trust Capital Strength, etc.
How they work: Often a blend of multiple asset classes or unique sector strategies (AI, dividends, ESG, etc.). These indexes are designed to offer steady returns through diversification.
Pros:
- Unique strategies tailored for different market conditions
- Can outperform traditional indexes in certain market cycles
Cons:
- Usually have short performance histories
- Not transparent
- Often not available for public investment or independent research
Who needs this: Income-focused retirees using GLWB riders who want smoother returns, or comfortable investors relying on insurer-provided backtests.
Who doesn’t: Investors who are skeptical of engineered indexes or want predictable, historically verified performance.
4. Fixed Account Option (Declared Interest Rate)
Most FIAs also include a 1-Year Fixed Account:
- You earn a declared rate, similar to a MYGA or CD.
- This is guaranteed for one year and resets annually.
Pros:
- Guaranteed return
- No market performance risk
Cons:
- Lower long-term growth potential
- The interest rate may decline annually
Who needs this: Ultra-conservative clients who don’t want any index risk—even if it’s just for interest calculation.
Can The Fixed Account Beat The Indexes?
Other Insurance That Enhances Fixed Index Annuities
- Lifetime Income with GLWB Riders: Essential if your goal is retirement income. These riders grow a fictitious income base and convert it into guaranteed income for life—no matter how long you live. These often benefit from engineered indexes with consistent returns.
- Life Insurance: Offers a tax-free death benefit. You can use life insurance to recover annuity value lost through annuitization or to cover long-term care.
- Long-Term Care Annuities or Hybrid Life Insurance: Best if you’re concerned about out-of-pocket healthcare costs. Some FIAs include enhanced withdrawal benefits for confinement, terminal illness, or ADL limitations.
Funding Options
- IRA, 401(k), or other pre-tax retirement accounts
- Roth IRA (for tax-free growth and income)
- Non-qualified funds (after-tax money)
The Right Way to Choose an Index
Reverse engineer your goal:
- If your goal is income, choose the index that consistently supports the highest GLWB income payouts—then evaluate index options.
- If your goal is safe growth, prioritize traditional indexes or low-cost volatility-controlled indexes with transparent return history.
- If you want CD alternatives, consider a MYGA or the 1-Year Fixed Account inside an FIA.
Final Thought: Compare, Then Choose Wisely
Buying the wrong FIA with the wrong index could mean missing out on thousands in interest or income. Don’t fall for hypothetical performance or engineered “backtests” without understanding what you’re giving up.
Contact The Annuity Expert to compare every available index option and get a free quote on the best fixed index annuity for your needs. Let us help you reverse-engineer your plan and avoid costly mistakes.
Expert Recommendation: Past performance is never a guarantee of future results, especially as insurance carriers adjust their rates monthly. If you want to see an illustration based on today’s current caps and participation rates, you can get a fixed index annuity quote from our brokerage to find the top-performing carrier for your specific needs.
Book A Free Consultation
Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.
Let Us Answer Your Questions
Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.