Fixed Annuity (Traditional Fixed Annuity)
- How it works: A traditional fixed annuity offers a guaranteed interest rate that’s declared and locked in for a specific period—typically one year at a time. The insurance company assumes all investment risk.
- Features:
- Annual guaranteed interest rate.
- Principal protection and tax-deferred growth.
- Renewed annually at the carrier’s discretion.
- Income Options:
- Can be annuitized for lifetime income.
- GLWB riders are rarely available on traditional fixed annuities—this is a major limitation compared to FIAs.
- May lack flexible income options or customization.
- Best for: Someone who wants a simple, conservative savings vehicle and doesn’t plan to rely on the annuity for long-term income.
Compare Fixed Annuity Rates
Fixed Indexed Annuity (FIA)
- How it works: A fixed indexed annuity offers interest linked to the performance of a market index (such as the S&P 500), with no downside risk. It includes multiple crediting strategies like annual point-to-point, participation rate, cap rate, or spread.
- Declared Rate Option: FIAs include a 1-Year Fixed Account, which earns a declared interest rate and is ideal for conservative years or when the market underperforms.
- Features:
- Market-linked upside potential with no loss of principal due to market performance.
- Minimum Guaranteed Value (MGV) protects your contract.
- More growth potential than a traditional fixed annuity or MYGA.
- Income Options:
- Most FIAs offer a GLWB rider, allowing you to receive guaranteed lifetime income without annuitizing.
- GLWB income can be level, increasing (CPI-based or interest-based), or advanced.
- You maintain full control over the contract, and any remaining value goes to beneficiaries.
- Best for: Someone who wants long-term income with control and growth potential, especially if income will be needed 5–10+ years from now.
Buying Tip: If you are comparing indexed and fixed annuities, fixed indexed annuities for accumulation should be judged by annual crediting mechanics, renewal terms, index simplicity, and realistic upside—not by the most impressive hypothetical backtest.
Compare Annuity Lifetime Income
Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuity (MYGA)
- How it works: A MYGA is a type of fixed annuity that locks in a guaranteed interest rate for a multi-year term—typically 3, 5, 7, or 10 years. It functions like a tax-deferred CD issued by an insurance company.
- Features:
- Fixed rate locked in for the full term.
- Principal protection and tax-deferred growth.
- Usually includes penalty-free withdrawals (up to 10% annually).
- Income Options:
- Can be annuitized after the term.
- GLWBs are not offered on MYGAs.
- Not ideal for income unless used to bridge to another income strategy.
- Best for: Someone who wants safe, predictable growth and doesn’t need income during the term.
Annuitization vs. GLWB
- Annuitization: Converts your annuity into a stream of income you cannot outlive, but you lose control of the asset, and it becomes irreversible. Once started, you cannot change beneficiaries or access lump sums.
- GLWB (Guaranteed Lifetime Withdrawal Benefit): Available primarily on FIAs. It allows lifetime income without giving up control. You can start, stop, or delay income and leave any unused value to beneficiaries.
We do not recommend annuitization unless absolutely necessary. GLWBs offer more flexibility, legacy value, and potential growth.
Which Product Is Best for You?
| Goal | Best Option |
| Short-term, predictable growth | MYGA |
| Safe growth with market upside and future income | FIA with GLWB |
| Simple interest growth, no market exposure | Traditional Fixed Annuity |
| Immediate lifetime income (last resort) | Annuitization (not recommended) |
Indexed vs. Fixed Annuities
Final Thoughts
All three annuity types—MYGAs, fixed annuities, and FIAs—offer principal protection and tax deferral. However, only FIAs offer GLWB riders, which are critical if your goal is to generate guaranteed lifetime income without giving up control.
That’s why most income-focused retirement strategies start with an FIA, not a fixed annuity or MYGA. And since no two products are alike, comparing annuities is essential to ensure you’re getting the highest income, lowest cost, and strongest carrier for your specific financial goals. A broker can help you navigate these choices and find the right solution.
Book A Free Consultation
Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.
Let Us Answer Your Questions
Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.