Scenario
You’re deciding between your Prudential pension and rolling those funds into a fixed index annuity with a Guaranteed Lifetime Withdrawal Benefit (GLWB) inside an IRA. Your concerns: lifetime income, inflation protection, flexibility, and whether your spouse or heirs get anything after you’re gone. The fine print matters—especially what happens if you die early.
1. Keep the Prudential Pension: Irrevocable Monthly Income With No Death Benefit
Key Stat: Pension choices are irrevocable after retirement begins.
How It Works: You elect a pension payout (single or joint life) and receive guaranteed income for life. If you die early, the payments stop unless you select a joint-life or period-certain option, which usually reduces the monthly amount. The decision is permanent and has no death benefit for heirs.
✔ Lifetime income without market risk
✔ No investment decisions required
✔ Simplifies retirement planning
✘ Irrevocable once income starts
✘ Zero death benefit unless you reduce your payout
✘ No inflation adjustment unless COLA is included
✘ No access to a lump sum for emergencies or opportunities
Who Needs It: People who prioritize simplicity and don’t plan to leave a financial legacy.
Who Doesn’t: Anyone who wants flexibility, inflation protection, or to leave money to loved ones.
Helpful Add-on: Buy a cheap life insurance policy to replace your pension income for your spouse or children if you pass away early.
2. IRA Fixed Index Annuity With GLWB: Lifetime Income, Flexibility, and a Death Benefit
Key Stat: GLWB annuities offer 5%–8% withdrawal rates for life—even if the account hits $0.
How It Works: Roll your pension lump sum into a fixed index annuity in an IRA. Add a GLWB rider to receive lifetime income—even after your account is depleted. If you pass away, your remaining account value goes to your heirs. You also get inflation-sensitive income growth tied to market indexes (with no market loss).
✔ Lifetime income with market protection
✔ Built-in death benefit for heirs
✔ Optional inflation growth and long-term care features
✔ Access to your money if needed
✘ May have annual fees for GLWB (0.95%–1.25%)
✘ Income isn’t 100% fixed until you activate the rider
✘ Contracts can be complex
Who Needs It: Retirees wanting guaranteed income, flexibility, and to leave a financial legacy.
Who Doesn’t: Those with other lifetime income sources and no need for market exposure.
Helpful Add-on: Add long-term care benefits to double income if you need care—something pensions and Medicare won’t do.
Note: This tool illustrates two types of annuity payouts: Advanced and Level payouts. An advanced income annuity provides much higher income early on, then decreases after 10+ years. A level income annuity, by contrast, pays the same amount every year for life.
3. Take the Pension Lump Sum and Buy a GLWB Annuity: Best of Both Worlds With Control and Death Benefit
Key Stat: Rollovers from pensions to IRAs are tax-free and allow income planning on your terms.
How It Works: Choose the lump sum option instead of monthly pension payments. Roll the money into a fixed index annuity with a GLWB. You decide when income starts. If you die before using the funds, your heirs get what’s left. You’re not locked in and can plan around taxes, inflation, and legacy goals.
✔ Full control over retirement income
✔ Income can be delayed for higher future payouts
✔ Built-in death benefit for your spouse or heirs
✔ Flexibility to change plans or access money
✘ Requires setup and product selection
✘ Income isn’t instant—planning is required
✘ Penalties may apply if you withdraw early in the surrender period
Who Needs It: Retirees who want maximum control, long-term income, and to protect their family financially.
Who Doesn’t: Those unwilling to manage contracts or who want automatic simplicity.
Final Thoughts
Pension or Annuity? Get Both Income and Legacy Protection
Don’t lose your savings to an irrevocable decision. Compare pension payouts vs. top IRA GLWB annuities today.
Book a call with The Annuity Expert for free, no-obligation quotes and help choosing the right income strategy.
Book A Free Consultation
Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.
Let Us Answer Your Questions
Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.