How to Save Money on Medicare Plan F Without Losing the Coverage You Need
Medicare Supplement Plan F was once the most comprehensive standardized Medigap option available. It covers the major deductibles, copayments, and coinsurance obligations that Plan F is designed to cover under Original Medicare, including the Medicare Part B deductible. However, Plan F is no longer available to people who became newly eligible for Medicare on or after January 1, 2020. If you already have Plan F, you can generally keep it. The question is whether the premium you are paying still makes financial sense.
If your Medicare Plan F premium keeps increasing, do not assume you should automatically drop it. Depending on your circumstances, alternatives such as Plan G, High-Deductible Plan G, Plan N, or Medicare Advantage may lower your costs. But switching Medigap policies can involve medical underwriting when you do not have guaranteed-issue rights, so the goal is to save money without accidentally giving up coverage you may not be able to get back.
Your Main Options
| Strategy | Best For | Main Advantage | Main Drawback |
|---|---|---|---|
| Keep Plan F | People with competitive Plan F premiums | Very predictable Medicare cost sharing | Premiums may be higher |
| Switch to Plan G | Plan F owners who can qualify and save enough | Nearly identical standardized coverage | You pay the Part B deductible |
| High-Deductible Plan G | Healthy retirees comfortable assuming more upfront costs | Lower premiums | $2,950 deductible in 2026 |
| Plan N | People willing to accept some copays | Often lower premiums | Copays and possible Part B excess charges |
| Medicare Advantage | People prioritizing lower premiums and bundled benefits | May include drug, dental, vision, and hearing benefits | Networks, copays, and prior authorization may apply |
| Optimize Part D | People staying with Original Medicare and Medigap | Can reduce prescription spending | Requires annual review |
| Dental, Vision, and Hearing | People with recurring routine-care needs | Can fill gaps Medicare and Medigap leave behind | Additional premium and benefit limits |
| Long-Term Care Coverage | People protecting retirement assets from extended care | Can help fund custodial and extended care | Medical qualification and cost |
| Fixed Indexed Annuity With Lifetime Income | Retirees needing predictable retirement cash flow | Can create another guaranteed income layer | It is not health or long-term care insurance |
1. Compare Plan F With Medigap Plan G
For many Plan F owners, Plan G should be the first comparison. Plan G generally provides the same standardized Medigap benefits as Plan F except that it does not pay the Medicare Part B deductible. That deductible is $283 in 2026.
The important number is not simply the premium for either plan. It is the annual premium difference. If comparable Plan G coverage costs $600 less per year than your Plan F policy, you would be paying an extra $600 in premiums to have Plan F cover a $283 deductible. In that situation, Plan G may produce meaningful savings. If your Plan F premium is only slightly higher, keeping Plan F may be perfectly reasonable.
✔ Pros: Potentially lower premiums while retaining very comprehensive standardized Medicare Supplement coverage.
✘ Cons: You pay the Part B deductible yourself, and a switch may require medical underwriting.
Who Could Benefit: Plan F owners whose premiums have become substantially more expensive than comparable Plan G coverage.
Who Might Not Benefit: Someone whose Plan F rate remains competitive or who may not medically qualify for a replacement policy.
You can also review the broader pros and cons of Medicare Plan G before deciding whether the premium savings justify a change.
Do Not Cancel Plan F Until You Know the Replacement Is Approved
This is one of the most important parts of the decision. Medicare’s annual enrollment periods do not automatically give everyone a federal right to move freely between Medigap companies. Your strongest protections generally occur during your Medigap Open Enrollment Period and in specific guaranteed-issue situations. Outside those protections, a carrier may be allowed to review your health history depending on the situation and state rules.
Do not cancel Plan F first and apply for another Medigap plan afterward. Apply for the replacement coverage, confirm the effective date and approval, and only then decide whether to terminate the old policy. If you are unsure whether you have a protected enrollment right, learn how guaranteed-issue coverage differs from medically underwritten insurance and speak with a licensed Medicare Supplement agent about the rules that apply to you.
2. Consider High-Deductible Plan G
If you are relatively healthy and mainly want protection against larger Medicare cost-sharing expenses, High-Deductible Plan G can reduce the premium substantially. In 2026, you must pay $2,950 of qualifying Medicare-covered deductibles, coinsurance, and copayments before the high-deductible Medigap coverage begins paying covered benefits.
The concept is straightforward: you accept more responsibility for smaller and moderate medical expenses in exchange for paying less to the insurance company every month. That can be attractive if you have enough emergency savings or retirement income to comfortably absorb the deductible during a bad healthcare year.
✔ Pros: Lower monthly premiums and meaningful protection against larger Medicare cost-sharing expenses after the deductible is satisfied.
✘ Cons: You need enough cash flow or savings to handle the deductible and other costs before the policy begins paying its covered benefits.
Who Could Benefit: Healthy retirees with emergency savings who want a lower-cost Medigap strategy.
Who Might Not Benefit: Someone who would struggle financially if several thousand dollars of healthcare costs arrived early in the year.
If you are not yet enrolled in Medicare and are still eligible to contribute, an HSA may also help you build tax-advantaged funds for future qualified healthcare expenses. HSA contribution eligibility changes once Medicare coverage begins, so coordinate contributions carefully as you approach enrollment.
3. Compare Plan N
Plan N is another Medigap option worth pricing. It generally shifts a little more cost sharing back to you than Plan G. Certain office visits can involve copayments, some emergency-room visits can involve a copayment when you are not admitted, and Plan N does not cover Medicare Part B excess charges.
The tradeoff is that Plan N premiums may be lower. If you do not visit doctors frequently and are comfortable paying predictable copays in exchange for a lower monthly premium, Plan N can be an efficient middle ground between richer first-dollar coverage and a high-deductible design.
✔ Pros: Often lower premiums than richer Medigap options while still covering many major Original Medicare cost-sharing gaps.
✘ Cons: Office and emergency-room copays may apply, and Part B excess charges are not covered.
Who Could Benefit: Retirees who want Medigap flexibility but are willing to trade some first-dollar coverage for a lower premium.
Who Might Not Benefit: People who want the most predictable possible medical expenses or frequently see providers who charge Part B excess charges.
4. Consider Medicare Advantage, but Understand What You Are Giving Up
Another possible way to reduce premiums is to move from Original Medicare plus Medigap to Medicare Advantage (Part C). These are different coverage systems, and Medigap is not used to pay Medicare Advantage cost sharing.
Many Medicare Advantage plans have low or $0 additional plan premiums and may bundle prescription drugs, dental, vision, hearing, fitness, or other benefits. The tradeoff is that you may have a provider network, copays, and prior-authorization requirements. Depending on the plan, you may be using an HMO or PPO structure rather than the broad provider access associated with Original Medicare and Medigap.
✔ Pros: Potentially lower premiums and bundled benefits such as drug, dental, vision, hearing, or fitness coverage.
✘ Cons: Provider networks, service-area rules, copays, and prior authorization can make care less flexible than Original Medicare plus Medigap.
Who Could Benefit: Cost-conscious retirees who are comfortable receiving care within a plan’s network and prefer bundled benefits.
Who Might Not Benefit: Frequent travelers, people with specialized doctors, or anyone who places a high value on broad provider flexibility.
A hospital indemnity policy may also be worth comparing for a Medicare Advantage member who wants additional cash protection against inpatient cost sharing. Someone keeping comprehensive Plan F should first compare the indemnity premium against the medical expenses Plan F already absorbs so they do not pay for unnecessary overlapping protection.
Do not switch solely because a plan advertises a $0 premium. Compare your doctors, hospitals, prescriptions, maximum out-of-pocket exposure, travel needs, and the likelihood that you could obtain Medigap again later. You can also review the ways Medicare Advantage could reduce certain retirement healthcare costs.
5. Shop Your Part D Drug Plan Every Year
Plan F and modern Medigap policies do not include outpatient prescription drug coverage. If you use Original Medicare and Medigap, you generally need a separate Medicare Part D plan if you want prescription coverage.
Do not automatically renew the same Part D policy forever. Your prescriptions can change, formularies can change, preferred pharmacies can change, and premiums can change. In 2026, a Part D plan’s annual deductible cannot exceed $615, and the annual out-of-pocket threshold for covered Part D drugs is $2,100.
The lowest-premium plan is not necessarily the lowest-cost plan. A policy that costs a few dollars less per month can become much more expensive if it places one of your prescriptions on an unfavorable tier or does not include your preferred pharmacy in its network.
✔ Pros: Annual shopping can align your coverage with your actual medications and potentially reduce prescription spending.
✘ Cons: Formularies and pharmacy arrangements require regular review, and delaying Part D without other creditable drug coverage can create a late-enrollment penalty.
Who Could Benefit: Anyone using Original Medicare and Medigap who takes prescriptions or wants protection against future drug expenses.
Who Might Not Benefit: Many Medicare Advantage members already receive Part D coverage through their Medicare Advantage plan, so they should review the drug component of that plan rather than buying duplicate coverage.
Helpful Tool: Use Medicare’s Plan Finder during the appropriate enrollment period to compare your prescriptions and pharmacies against available plans.
6. Add Dental, Vision, and Hearing Coverage Only When the Math Works
This surprises many retirees. Buying Plan F does not mean every healthcare expense is covered. Original Medicare and Medigap plans generally do not provide routine dental, routine vision, eyeglasses, or hearing-aid benefits in the way many retirees expect.
If you routinely need cleanings, crowns, implants, glasses, or hearing aids, compare standalone coverage or a dental, vision, and hearing bundle. You can also review other ways to obtain dental coverage with Medicare.
Run the numbers before buying. If a dental policy charges a large annual premium but has a low annual benefit maximum, waiting periods, and substantial coinsurance for major work, self-funding some routine care may be more economical. Insurance is most useful when it solves a financial problem you would otherwise have difficulty absorbing.
✔ Pros: Can fill routine-care gaps and make recurring dental, vision, and hearing expenses more predictable.
✘ Cons: Additional premiums, waiting periods, networks, annual benefit caps, and cost sharing can limit the value.
Who Could Benefit: People expecting recurring dental, vision, or hearing expenses and retirees without other private health coverage for those services.
Who Might Not Benefit: Someone with employer or retiree benefits already covering these services, or a person whose expected expenses are low enough to comfortably self-fund.
7. Long-Term Care May Be a Bigger Retirement Risk Than Your Medigap Premium
This is one of the biggest retirement-planning misunderstandings. You can have Medicare and an excellent Medigap plan and still have a major hole in your protection: long-term custodial care.
Medicare and Medigap were not designed to pay indefinitely for custodial help with activities of daily living. If Alzheimer’s disease, dementia, Parkinson’s disease, a stroke, or another condition leaves you needing ongoing assistance, you could eventually need home care, assisted living, memory care, or a nursing home.
Someone turning 65 has roughly a 70% chance of needing some form of long-term services and supports during the remainder of life. Depending on the type of care and where you live, annual costs can easily reach tens of thousands of dollars and may exceed $100,000 for intensive nursing-home care. That is why long-term care deserves its own strategy rather than being treated as a Medigap problem.
Medicaid Is Not the Same as Having a Long-Term Care Plan
Medicaid can become an important source of long-term-care funding, but eligibility is based on state-specific financial, functional, and other rules. Middle-income households may first spend significant personal resources on care before becoming financially eligible. Spousal-protection rules can preserve certain income and resources for a husband or wife who remains at home, but relying on Medicaid alone can sharply limit how much control you have over the assets available to your family.
If preserving assets, protecting a spouse, maintaining care choices, or leaving an inheritance matters to you, address long-term care before a health event removes your insurance options.
8. Consider Traditional or Hybrid Long-Term Care Insurance
Long-term care insurance can help pay for qualifying home care, assisted living, memory care, or nursing-home expenses when the policy’s benefit triggers are satisfied. Traditional policies are designed primarily around long-term-care benefits. Hybrid designs may combine life insurance or annuity benefits with long-term-care protection.
A long-term care annuity can be worth comparing when you have existing cash or assets you are willing to reposition for potential future care. Life insurance with a long-term-care or chronic-illness rider may make sense when you also have a death-benefit need. The best design depends on age, health, liquidity, family history, income, assets, and whether your priority is care leverage, legacy protection, premium certainty, or access to cash.
✔ Pros: Can protect retirement assets, give you a dedicated source of care funding, and reduce the financial pressure on a spouse or family.
✘ Cons: Coverage can be expensive, medical underwriting may apply, benefits are subject to policy definitions and limits, and waiting too long can make qualification difficult or impossible.
Who Could Benefit: People with assets or income they want to protect from a prolonged care event, especially those with a spouse or heirs they want to protect.
Who Might Not Benefit: People who can comfortably self-fund a multi-year care event or who already have sufficient government, employer, VA, or other long-term-care benefits.
9. Use Guaranteed Retirement Income to Make Healthcare Costs Less Disruptive
This is not health insurance and it is not long-term care insurance. It is an income-planning strategy. A fixed indexed annuity with a Guaranteed Lifetime Withdrawal Benefit (GLWB) can be structured to provide a contractually guaranteed lifetime withdrawal stream, subject to the terms of the contract.
Think of Social Security as the first retirement paycheck. An annuity can potentially become the second. If your household needs $8,000 per month and Social Security provides $4,500, there is a $3,500 monthly income gap that must be funded from pensions, investments, annuities, employment, or another source.
Instead of depending entirely on portfolio withdrawals, an appropriately designed annuity can provide predictable income for life. Joint-life options may be available for spouses. Depending on the contract, remaining account value at death may pass to beneficiaries, and a fixed indexed annuity may earn interest based in part on the performance of an external market index without directly investing the account in that index.
The healthcare connection is consistency. Dental work, prescriptions, hearing aids, home repairs, and family emergencies do not wait for the stock market to recover. If your retirement income depends entirely on selling investments, a large unexpected bill during a market decline can force you to withdraw more assets at an unfavorable time. A guaranteed income stream does not eliminate the medical bill, but it can keep a predictable retirement paycheck arriving while you deal with it.
✔ Pros: Predictable lifetime withdrawals, less dependence on selling investments for routine income, and the ability to create another contractual income layer above Social Security.
✘ Cons: Surrender charges, rider costs, liquidity limits, caps or participation rates, tax considerations, and contract-specific restrictions can apply. An annuity should not be mistaken for Medicare, Medigap, or long-term care insurance.
Who Could Benefit: Retirees seeking dependable income to fill a recurring gap between Social Security and monthly living expenses.
Who Might Not Benefit: People who need immediate access to all of their assets, have adequate guaranteed income already, or would be uncomfortable with the contract’s surrender period and restrictions.
Helpful Tool: Use our GLWB annuity calculator to compare potential lifetime payouts rather than choosing an annuity based only on an advertised bonus or accumulation rate.
Other Coverage Plan F Owners Should Consider
Having Plan F does not necessarily mean your retirement protection is finished. Depending on your situation, you may still need Part D prescription coverage, dental and vision insurance, hearing benefits, long-term care insurance, hybrid life and long-term-care coverage, life insurance for a surviving spouse, or a guaranteed-income strategy to make retirement cash flow more predictable.
More insurance is not automatically better. The objective is to insure expenses capable of damaging your retirement plan while avoiding premiums for risks you can comfortably self-fund.
Who Probably Should Keep Plan F?
Plan F can still make sense if you already own it, your premium remains competitive, you value extremely predictable Medicare expenses, you have significant medical needs, or changing policies would require underwriting you may not pass. There is nothing inherently wrong with Plan F. The problem is paying materially more for it than the additional benefit is worth to you.
Who Should Seriously Compare Alternatives?
You should shop your options if your Plan F premium has increased significantly, you are relatively healthy, you have sufficient emergency savings, or the annual premium difference between Plan F and Plan G is substantially greater than the $283 Part B deductible Plan G leaves you responsible for in 2026. Just do not make the switch until you know you can obtain and keep the replacement coverage.
What We Recommend
Start with the math. Compare what you are paying for Plan F against Plan G, High-Deductible Plan G, Plan N, and, when appropriate, Medicare Advantage. Then look beyond the Medigap premium. Review Part D every year, determine whether dental, vision, and hearing insurance actually pays for itself, and build a separate long-term-care strategy because Medicare and Medigap were never designed to fund years of custodial care.
Finally, make your retirement income predictable. Social Security can provide the first guaranteed paycheck. An appropriately designed annuity can potentially provide another. The purpose is not to make healthcare expenses disappear; it is to prevent every hospital bill, dental procedure, long-term-care expense, or market downturn from turning your monthly retirement income into a moving target.
How The Annuity Expert Can Help
The Annuity Expert is an independent insurance agency serving consumers throughout the United States. We can help you compare Medigap coverage, Medicare-related insurance, long-term-care insurance, hybrid LTC solutions, life insurance, and annuities with guaranteed lifetime income based on the problem you are actually trying to solve.
Contact The Annuity Expert for free quotes and comparisons. We can help you determine whether keeping Plan F, moving to another Medicare strategy, protecting against long-term care, or creating more dependable retirement income is the better fit. There is no obligation, and our service is free of charge.
Book A Free Consultation
Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.
Let Us Answer Your Questions
Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.