What You’re Really Buying With a Variable Annuity
A variable annuity is a hybrid investment-insurance product. You invest in mutual fund-like subaccounts and take on market risk, but in exchange, you get optional features like:
- Tax-deferred growth
- Optional death benefit protection
- Optional income riders for guaranteed lifetime income
The sales pitch is appealing: market growth + lifetime income. But what’s often left out is that variable annuities are the most expensive annuities you can buy, and for seniors, that can be devastating in retirement.
How a Variable Annuity Works (And Why That Matters for Seniors)
You make a lump-sum or series of premium payments, which go into subaccounts tied to the market (like mutual funds). The value of your account rises and falls based on market performance.
You can choose to add income riders (e.g., a GLWB, or Guaranteed Lifetime Withdrawal Benefit), which lets you withdraw a set percentage for life—even if your account value goes to $0.
Sounds great, right? But here’s the fine print:
- The “income base” is not your account value. It’s a phantom value used only to calculate future income. You can’t cash it out.
- All withdrawals come from your real money first.
- Once your account hits $0, you’re fully dependent on the insurer and the GLWB rider terms.
- If you skip the GLWB, you’re fully exposed to market losses.
Why Most Seniors Should Avoid Variable Annuities
✅ Tax-Deferral: Benefit or Redundant?
If you’re funding the annuity with an IRA, 403(b), or 401(k), you already have tax-deferred growth. A variable annuity adds no extra benefit, just extra fees. It’s cheaper to buy the mutual fund on its own.
❌ Complexity = Confusion
Variable annuities are layered with multiple values:
- Account value
- Income base
- Surrender value
- Death benefit base
Each one has different rules. If you don’t fully understand them, you’re putting your retirement savings into something you can’t control or predict.
❌ The Highest Fees in the Annuity Industry
Total fees can exceed 4% annually:
- M&E (Mortality & Expense): ~1.25%
- Admin Fees: ~0.30%
- Subaccount Fees: 0.50%–1.50%
- GLWB Rider: 1.00%–1.50%
Over 20 years, these fees could consume half or more of your gains—and that’s assuming positive performance.
❌ Market Losses Late in Life Are Devastating
If you’re 70+ and take a 20% market loss, it’s nearly impossible to recover. The sequence of returns risk can destroy your retirement plan—even with a GLWB, you lose flexibility and principal.
❌ Surrender Charges Lock You In
Most contracts have 7 to 10-year surrender periods. If you need your money early, you’ll pay a hefty fee—on top of market losses and taxes.
❌ Taxed at Ordinary Income Rates
Even when you grow your money in a variable annuity, any gains are taxed as ordinary income, not capital gains—meaning higher taxes for most retirees.
Who Might Still Consider a Variable Annuity?
- Seniors age 60–65 who won’t need income for 10+ years and want market growth potential with guaranteed future income.
- Affluent investors who maxed out other retirement vehicles and want an additional tax-deferred wrapper.
- Those who don’t mind fees and want a death benefit guarantee for estate planning.
But even in these cases, other annuities typically provide better outcomes.
Better Options Than Variable Annuities for Seniors
✅ Fixed Indexed Annuities (FIAs) – With GLWB Rider
FIAs offer market-linked gains without market losses. The insurance company uses the index (like the S&P 500) as a measuring stick, not as an investment. Returns are based on the index’s movement, capped or with a participation rate.
Income riders on FIAs offer guaranteed lifetime income—often more efficiently and with lower fees than a variable annuity.
- Safer than variable annuities
- Lower fees
- Guaranteed income
- Death benefit flexibility
Best for: Seniors wanting lifetime income but can’t afford a market crash.
✅ Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuities (MYGAs)
MYGAs work like CDs issued by insurance companies. You get a guaranteed fixed interest rate for 3–10 years, and some allow annual penalty-free withdrawals.
Best for: Seniors who want a safe, predictable return and access to their money.
✅ Immediate Annuities (SPIAs)
Pay guaranteed income right away. No market risk. But once you annuitize, the contract is irreversible. You lose access to your principal, and remaining balances may not go to heirs.
Best for: Seniors with no legacy goals and needing immediate income.
✅ Deferred Income Annuities (DIAs)
You give a lump sum now, and income starts 5–20 years later. Works better for younger retirees; not ideal if you’re over 75.
Best for: Younger seniors planning long-term income, not those needing cash now.
What Insurance Products Can Enhance Retirement Security?
- Long-Term Care Insurance or LTC Annuities Protects your assets from being spent down on nursing home or home health care.
- Permanent Life Insurance Used for legacy planning, tax-free wealth transfer, or building cash value for emergencies.
- Hybrid Annuity + LTC Some fixed index annuities offer long-term care benefits. Be cautious—some just pay your own money back faster.
Funding Sources for Annuities
- Qualified funds: IRAs, 401(k)s, 403(b)s (via rollover)
- Non-qualified funds: Savings, CDs, brokerage accounts
- Inherited IRA funds: Rules apply—especially after the SECURE Act
Summary: Variable Annuities Are Usually a Bad Deal for Seniors
| Factor | Variable Annuity | Fixed Indexed Annuity | MYGA |
|---|---|---|---|
| Principal Protection | ❌ No | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes |
| Market Upside | ✅ Yes | ✅ Limited | ❌ None |
| Market Loss Risk | ✅ Yes | ❌ None | ❌ None |
| Income Rider Option | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes | ❌ No |
| Fees | ❌ Very High | ✅ Moderate/Low | ✅ Low |
| Liquidity | ❌ Limited | ✅ Moderate | ✅ Moderate |
| Ideal Age Group | 50–60 | 60–75 | 65+ |
Bottom Line
Variable annuities are too expensive, too risky, and too complex for most seniors. Most will never see the benefits promised unless they live long enough and use the contract exactly right. There are better ways to protect your income, grow your money, and preserve your legacy.
Contact The Annuity Expert for free quotes to compare annuities, find the safest options, and avoid costly mistakes. Let us reverse-engineer the right solution based on your goals.
Book A Free Consultation
Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.
Let Us Answer Your Questions
Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.