Should I Buy an Annuity? Compare Reasons to Buy vs. Reasons Not to Buy

When Annuities Solve Real Problems—and When They Create New Ones

People don’t buy annuities because they’re exciting. They buy them to solve specific risks: income risk, longevity risk, sequence risk, and behavioral risk. When an annuity is used outside those purposes, it becomes the wrong tool. This guide focuses on when annuities work in the real world, and when they’re the wrong tool for the job.

Why People Consider Buying an Annuity

Annuities are considered for income planning—not wealth maximization.

• Income certainty: An annuity can pay income as long as you live, regardless of markets or age.
• Replacing a pension: Most workers no longer have pensions. An annuity can replicate that income structure.
• Reducing market risk near retirement: Annuities can remove the need to sell investments during market downturns.
• Tax deferral: Qualified and Non-qualified annuities defer taxes on gains, which can improve compounding.
• Income insurance—not investing: Annuities insure income. They are not growth vehicles first. You can earn an above-average rate of return, but don’t expect stock market gains.

Reasons to Buy an Annuity

You should only buy an annuity if one or more of these apply.

• You need contractually guaranteed lifetime income: If outliving your money is a real concern, annuities directly solve that problem. They are the only vehicle to provide these contractual guarantees.
• You need a predictable income to cover fixed expenses: Housing, utilities, food, and insurance premiums align well with predictable income.
• You are close to or already retired: Income insurance matters more once accumulation is mostly finished.
• You lack a sufficient guaranteed income: If Social Security and pensions don’t cover essentials, an annuity can fill the gap.
• You want to reduce sequence-of-returns risk: Annuities reduce reliance on market timing early in retirement. This protection avoids a sudden change in retirement, like in the 2008 Great Recession scenario.
• You want risk transferred off your balance sheet: Longevity and income risk move from you to the insurer.
• You are comfortable earmarking money for income: Funds used for annuities should not be emergency money.
• You want to supplement long-term care costs: Certain annuities include riders or structures that increase payouts for long-term care expenses, helping fund care without fully relying on traditional long-term care insurance.
• You want a higher interest rate than a CD: Multi-year and fixed annuities often credit more interest than bank CDs, especially for longer terms, without market volatility.
• You want stock-market-like upside without market losses: Fixed indexed annuities allow participation in market-linked gains while protecting principal from losses due to poor market performance.
• You still want access to your money: Most annuities include built-in liquidity features, allowing penalty-free withdrawals each year, making them usable for income planning—not just lockups.

Reasons NOT to Buy an Annuity

• You want maximum liquidity and flexibility: Annuities come with surrender periods. Early access outside the annual penalty-free withdrawals can be restricted or penalized.
• You are buying for growth instead of income: Fixed and indexed annuities limit upside by design. They are not meant to beat equities. They’re meant to be the “safe” portion of your portfolio. Think of them as bond and CD alternatives.
• You are considering variable annuities or RILAs for growth: Higher fees, complexity, and long-term underperformance relative to risk make them poor accumulation tools for most buyers.
• You don’t understand the contract mechanics: Caps, participation rates, spreads, renewal changes, rider fees, and income bases are often misunderstood. If clarity isn’t there, the product shouldn’t be purchased.
• You are attracted to bonuses instead of outcomes: Premium bonuses often come with vesting schedules, recapture clauses, and reduced long-term growth. “Free money” usually isn’t free.
• You dislike declining renewal terms: Caps and rates might not be guaranteed long-term (some are guaranteed, and some are not). Renewal terms often move lower over time.
• You want full market participation: Annuities trade upside potential for stability. If you want uncapped growth in the stock market, annuities are the wrong vehicle.
• You plan to annuitize without understanding the consequences: Annuitization is irreversible. Once elected, control and flexibility are gone. This is why GLWBs are often preferred instead.
• You want a step-up in basis at death: Non-qualified annuities do not receive a step-up in basis. Beneficiaries pay ordinary income tax on gains. Life insurance is an affordable way to offset the negative tax rule.
• You expect FDIC-style protection: Annuities are insurance contracts, not bank products. Protection comes from the insurer and state guaranty associations—not the FDIC.
• You don’t need income guarantees at all: If pensions, Social Security, and investment income already cover expenses, an annuity adds friction without solving a problem. If you have a pension and want to maintain control over your account, consider rolling the lump sum option into an IRA annuity with a GLWB, which will provide the lifetime income without the headache.

Buyer Beware: Before you commit, make sure you aren’t walking into a trap. We’ve compiled a specific list of who should not buy an annuity—if you match any of these profiles (like needing short-term liquidity), stop immediately.

When an Annuity Fits vs. When It Doesn’t

An annuity fits when:

• Income matters more than growth
• Longevity risk is a concern.
• Market risk near retirement must be reduced.
• Predictability is valuable

An annuity doesn’t fit when:

• Liquidity is critical
• Growth is the primary objective.
• Risk tolerance is high, and the time horizon is long.
• Income is already secured.

Other Ways to Address the Same Problems

An annuity is not the only option—but it is the only one that insures income for life.

• Investment withdrawal strategies: Flexible but fully exposed to market and longevity risk.
• Bond or CD ladders: Useful for short-term, weak against inflation, and long lifespans.
• Delaying Social Security: Strong income increase, but limited by timing constraints.
• Tax planning strategies: Manage taxes but don’t stabilize income.

Each method solves part of the problem. Only annuities insure lifetime income.

Other Insurance That Strengthens Retirement Plans

Annuities work best when layered, not isolated.

• Life insurance: Protects spouses and replaces lost legacy
• Long-term care insurance: Covers extended care costs, but annuities don’t
• Medicare supplements: Controls healthcare uncertainty
• Disability insurance: Protects income before retirement

Bottom Line

The right question isn’t “Should I buy an annuity?”

It’s “Which risks am I trying to eliminate—and is an annuity the right tool for that?”

Annuities are effective when used deliberately. They are costly mistakes when used emotionally or for the wrong reasons.

One Last Tip: Don’t buy an annuity on your own. Use a broker (like The Annuity Expert). It’s a free service. There are so many financial professionals in this industry who are limited on their product selection, have a lack of knowledge and experience in annuities, or worse, oversell the product and underdeliver. Don’t put yourself in that situation.

Compare Before You Commit

Annuities are long-term contracts. Structure matters more than the product name.

Contact The Annuity Expert to compare free quotes, structures, and alternatives before buying coverage.

Book A Free Consultation

Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.

Let Us Answer Your Questions

Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.

Frequently Asked Questions