Comparing Annuities and REITs for Retirement Security
Scenario
You’re planning for retirement or are already retired and comparing annuities and Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) to secure income, grow your wealth, or hedge against inflation. These options serve very different purposes, and choosing the wrong one could jeopardize your financial goals.
Pro Tip: REITs offer liquidity, but they don’t provide the same tangible benefits as owning physical property. If you are debating between being a landlord or an annuitant, we recommend you evaluate the pros and cons of annuity vs rental income to understand how maintenance costs and vacancies impact your net retirement pay.
Guaranteed Income with Annuities
Stat to Know: Some annuities offer a 5%–8% lifetime income withdrawal rate with no risk of running out.
Annuities are contracts with insurance companies that offer guaranteed income for life, often with options like long-term care benefits or death benefit enhancements. With fixed indexed annuities and GLWBs (Guaranteed Lifetime Withdrawal Benefits), you can grow your money based on a market index while still locking in income for life—even if your account value drops to zero.
- Pros:
- Contractual income you can’t outlive
- Market risk protection (fixed or indexed options)
- Optional inflation, long-term care, or death benefits
- Can automate retirement withdrawals
- Cons:
- Illiquid during the surrender charge period
- May have caps and spreads on gains (indexed annuities)
- Some products have fees
- Who Needs It:
- Retirees who need a guaranteed income
- Those concerned about longevity risk
- People looking to avoid managing investments in retirement
- Who Doesn’t:
- Investors wanting liquidity and control over assets
- Those who are comfortable managing market risk themselves
Helpful Add-on: Use a fixed index annuity with a GLWB to beat the 4% rule, automate income, and protect against inflation.
Passive Real Estate Exposure with REITs
Stat to Know: Public REITs typically yield 3%–6% annually, depending on the sector and market.
REITs (Real Estate Investment Trusts) allow you to invest in real estate without owning physical property. You buy shares in a company that owns and operates income-producing properties, and in return, you receive dividends. They’re liquid, growth-oriented, and often used to diversify a portfolio.
- Pros:
- Regular income through dividends
- Liquidity (especially public REITs)
- Potential for capital appreciation
- Diversification across property types
- Cons:
- No income guarantees—dividends fluctuate
- Volatility—REITs are correlated to stock market swings
- Taxable income from dividends (not tax-deferred like annuities)
- Who Needs It:
- Growth-focused investors are still accumulating wealth
- People looking for real estate exposure without managing properties
- Those who are comfortable with market volatility
- Who Doesn’t:
- Retirees who need a predictable, steady income
- Investors who want to avoid equity risk
- Anyone with a low risk tolerance
Also Consider: REITs can be used inside IRAs to defer taxes, but they don’t offer guarantees like annuities.
MYGAs vs. REITs
MYGAs (Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuities) offer a fixed interest rate for a set term—similar to a CD but issued by an insurance company and with tax deferral. They provide a stable, guaranteed return but little to no flexibility or upside. In contrast, REITs are volatile real estate investment vehicles designed to deliver income and growth through property market exposure.
| Category | MYGA | REIT |
|---|---|---|
| Income Stability | Guaranteed interest | Fluctuates with market and rent cycles |
| Risk Level | None (backed by insurer) | High (market and sector risk) |
| Liquidity | Limited; early withdrawals penalized | High (if publicly traded) |
| Growth Potential | Fixed, limited | High potential, but volatile |
| Tax Treatment | Tax-deferred | Dividends taxed annually |
| Inflation Protection | None | Partial (rent may rise) |
Who Should Use MYGAs:
Conservative investors need principal protection, predictable growth, and low taxes. Not suited for aggressive growth or liquidity needs.
Who Should Use REITs:
Investors with a higher risk tolerance, looking for yield and real estate diversification. Poor choice for those who can’t afford loss or volatility.
FIAs vs. REITs
Fixed Indexed Annuities (FIAs) provide returns linked to a stock index (like the S&P 500), with downside protection and optional income riders (GLWB). Compared to REITs, FIAs offer safety and predictable retirement income without stock market losses, though with capped upside.
| Category | FIA | REIT |
|---|---|---|
| Income Guarantee | Available with GLWB rider | None |
| Downside Risk | None | Full exposure |
| Growth Potential | Capped or participation-limited | High (unrestricted) |
| Liquidity | Limited (often 10% free per year) | High (if public) |
| Tax Treatment | Tax-deferred | Immediate dividend taxation |
| Inflation Protection | Moderate with index-based growth | Stronger (market and rent growth) |
Who Should Use FIAs:
People nearing or in retirement need protected growth and a lifetime income. Ideal for those who want to avoid market downturns and sequence-of-return risk.
Who Should Use REITs:
Investors seeking long-term wealth growth through real estate, and who can tolerate sharp value fluctuations. Not suitable for income guarantees or downside protection.
Variable Annuities vs. REITs
Variable Annuities (VAs) invest in mutual-fund-like subaccounts with full market risk. Like REITs, they offer high growth potential, but with added fees and optional income or death benefits. REITs, while also market-sensitive, tend to focus on income and are less complex.
| Category | Variable Annuity | REIT |
|---|---|---|
| Income Guarantee | Optional (via GLWB) | None |
| Market Risk | Full | Full |
| Tax Treatment | Tax-deferred | Taxable dividends |
| Fees | High (2–4%/yr typically) | Low (brokerage only) |
| Liquidity | Limited (surrender charges) | High (public REITs) |
| Estate Benefit | Optional death benefit | Market-based inheritance value |
Who Should Use VAs:
High-income investors who need tax deferral, optional income protection, and legacy features. Less suited for fee-conscious or conservative investors.
Who Should Use REITs:
Those seeking income and growth with low overhead. Not ideal for those who want contractual guarantees or are fee-averse but risk-sensitive.
Summary Comparison Table
| Feature | MYGA | FIA | Variable Annuity | REIT |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Guaranteed Interest | ✔ | ✘ | ✘ | ✘ |
| Income Guarantee | ✘ | ✔ (GLWB) | ✔ (GLWB) | ✘ |
| Market Exposure | ✘ | ✔ (no downside) | ✔ (full risk) | ✔ |
| Growth Potential | ✘ | Moderate | High | High |
| Loss Protection | ✔ | ✔ | ✘ | ✘ |
| Tax-Deferred Growth | ✔ | ✔ | ✔ | ✘ |
| Liquidity | ✘ | Limited | Limited | ✔ |
| Fees | Low | Low to Moderate | High | Low |
| Inflation Hedge | ✘ | Some | Some | ✔ |
Use Case: Blended Strategy Example
A 60-year-old couple with $600,000 split across tax-deferred and taxable accounts:
- $250,000 in a FIA with GLWB: Guarantees $1,000+/month income starting at age 65 for life, regardless of market conditions.
- $100,000 in a 5-year MYGA: Grows safely while deferring taxes, with penalty-free withdrawals allowed annually.
- $100,000 in a public REIT ETF inside a Roth IRA: Tax-free dividend income and growth to help offset inflation.
- $150,000 in a Variable Annuity with death benefit: Allows market participation, legacy protection, and tax-deferred growth for a younger beneficiary.
Recommended Insurance Tie-Ins
| Need | Insurance Solution |
|---|---|
| Protect REIT loss | Use FIA income floor |
| Offset annuity loss at death | Buy term or permanent life insurance |
| Cover long-term care needs | Add an LTC rider to FIA or buy a standalone LTC annuity |
| Need income before age 59½ | SPIA with life-only payout + life insurance |
| Maximize Roth conversion window | Use MYGAs or FIAs to defer growth now and convert assets over time |
Final Word
If you value certainty and income protection, annuities—especially MYGAs and FIAs—are superior. If you’re willing to take market risk for growth and yield, REITs belong in your portfolio.
But for the best results, combine both:
- Annuities create your income floor
- REITs give you inflation and growth exposure
This balance reduces sequence-of-return risk, taxes, and behavioral mistakes that derail retirement plans.
Want to compare MYGAs, FIAs, or Variable Annuities to REITs based on your goals?
Contact The Annuity Expert for free quotes and expert advice on building a secure and flexible income plan.
Book A Free Consultation
Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.
Let Us Answer Your Questions
Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.