Understand Your Non-Annuity Options Before Committing to a Long-Term Contract
Scenario
You’re deciding if an annuity is right for you—or if something else could do the job better. You want income or growth with safety, but without locking up money or paying fees. Here’s a breakdown of every major annuity alternative and why some people choose them instead.
1. Dividend-Paying Stocks – Income with Growth Potential
Key stat: The S&P 500 has averaged ~10% returns historically, with ~2% coming from dividends.
Dividend stocks generate income while offering capital appreciation potential. Many retirees use them to replace annuity income with more flexibility.
✔ Pros
- ✔ Income potential through dividends
- ✔ Liquidity and growth opportunity
- ✔ Step-up in basis for heirs
✘ Cons
- ✘ Market volatility
- ✘ Dividends are not guaranteed
Who Needs It:
People with a higher risk tolerance who want income and growth without handing money to an insurance company.
Who Doesn’t:
Those who need a guaranteed income or can’t afford market losses.
Helpful Add-on: Pair with term life insurance to protect income if markets drop.
Helpful Tip: Unsure if the risk of stocks is worth the reward? Read our direct head-to-head guide on annuities vs. other investments to see exactly what you give up (and what you gain) when choosing market exposure over insurance guarantees.
2. Bonds and Bond Ladders – Safer, Steady Payouts
Key stat: Current Treasury yields range from 4% to 5%, depending on term.
Bonds are a traditional alternative offering predictable income. Bond ladders reduce reinvestment risk by spreading maturities.
✔ Pros
- ✔ Predictable income
- ✔ Can match cash flow needs
- ✔ Liquidity if needed
✘ Cons
- ✘ No longevity protection
- ✘ Inflation risk
Who Needs It:
Conservative investors seek predictable payouts over a fixed term.
Who Doesn’t:
People who need income for life or fear outliving their money.
Also Consider: Income annuities with inflation protection for longer-term needs.
3. CDs and High-Yield Savings – Simple, Low-Risk Vehicles
Key stat: Top 1-year CD rates are ~5.00% as of 2025.
CDs and HYSA accounts offer principal protection and steady returns with short lock-up periods.
✔ Pros
- ✔ FDIC-insured
- ✔ No fees or market risk
- ✔ Easy access (HYSA)
✘ Cons
- ✘ Interest rates may drop
- ✘ No lifetime income
Who Needs It:
Short-term savers who prioritize liquidity and safety.
Who Doesn’t:
People needing lifetime income or higher long-term growth.
Helpful Tip: Use short-term annuities to lock in better yields over 3-5 years.
4. Real Estate – Income and Appreciation
Key stat: Rental property yields range from 6%–10%, depending on location and leverage.
Rental properties offer both rental income and long-term appreciation potential. Some use REITs instead to avoid management hassle.
✔ Pros
- ✔ Inflation hedge
- ✔ Tax benefits like depreciation
- ✔ Cash flow and appreciation
✘ Cons
- ✘ Illiquid and management-intensive
- ✘ High upfront costs
Who Needs It:
Those comfortable managing property or outsourcing it, and who want income plus tax benefits.
Who Doesn’t:
Those wanting a simple, hands-off guaranteed income.
Also Consider: Annuities with real estate-linked indices (like REIT-based fixed index annuities).
5. Managed Portfolios – Personalized Diversification
Key stat: Robo-advisors charge ~0.25%–0.50% per year vs. ~1%+ for human advisors.
Managed portfolios, whether DIY or via advisors, offer diversified exposure to stocks, bonds, and alternatives, tailored to your needs.
✔ Pros
- ✔ Flexible and customizable
- ✔ Rebalancing and tax loss harvesting (with some platforms)
✘ Cons
- ✘ Not guaranteed
- ✘ Subject to advisor fees or algorithmic flaws
Who Needs It:
People with moderate to high risk tolerance who want long-term growth and liquidity.
Who Doesn’t:
People who want a guaranteed income without managing portfolios.
Helpful Add-on: Add a GLWB annuity to cover basic income needs, then invest the rest.
6. Life Insurance – Growth with Guarantees
Key stat: Indexed Universal Life (IUL) policies can offer 0–10% returns with downside protection.
Permanent life insurance, like IUL or whole life, offers tax-deferred growth, death benefits, and cash value access—often used as a wealth-building alternative.
✔ Pros
- ✔ Tax-free withdrawals (via loans)
- ✔ Guaranteed death benefit
- ✔ No RMDs
✘ Cons
- ✘ Requires underwriting
- ✘ Slower growth vs. investing
Who Needs It:
Those wanting a tax-free legacy, cash value access, and some downside protection.
Who Doesn’t:
Those needing simple, liquid, or short-term growth options.
Also Consider: Life insurance retirement plans (LIRPs) for tax-free income.
Bonus: Annuities With GLWBs Still Offer The Best Income Guarantees
While the above options offer flexibility and control, only annuities with Guaranteed Lifetime Withdrawal Benefits (GLWBs) offer income for life, no matter how long you live—even if the market crashes or your balance hits zero.
Book A Call
Not sure what combination works best for you? Our agents will compare annuities and non-annuity options side-by-side—free, fast, and with no obligation. Contact The Annuity Expert’s financial advisors and insurance agents for free quotes to buy coverage.
Book A Free Consultation
Get help from a licensed financial professional. This service is free of charge.
Let Us Answer Your Questions
Not quite ready for a meeting, but you have a question that needs answering? We’re happy to help. Leave an inquiry below, and one of our staff will respond via email.